[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/his/ - History

Historical Discussion

Catalog

8chan Bitcoin address: 1NpQaXqmCBji6gfX8UgaQEmEstvVY7U32C
The next generation of Infinity is here (discussion) (contribute)
Email
Subject
Comment *
File *
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Flag
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
dicesidesmodifier
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


We oughta get a board mascot eventually. Feel free to stop by the sticky meta thread with suggestions.

File: 1432340260032.jpg (17.03 KB, 350x277, 350:277, 1334628464173.jpg)

6ffd86 No.20481[Reply]

more people would lurk here should they learn about it



File: 1423487539438.jpg (235.92 KB, 802x584, 401:292, apadana_soldier.jpg)

4bb570 No.15003[Reply]

How many genuine ethnic Persians do still exist in Iran,Afghanistan and Tajikistan today? Most of them seem to be mixed with other peoples.
17 posts and 7 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

d4c692 No.20423

I'm Persian-Turk and Persian-Russo.


000000 No.20430

>>20423

What the fug are you trying to say? Turkmen and Tajik?


9fc22f No.20453

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

>>19834

Still very far from Mandarin (in all fairness Chinese from 500+ years ago sounds like random gibberish)


cc6275 No.20462

>>20453

sounds like vietnamese mixed with thai, then fed through a blender


3ef233 No.20476

>>15109

>there will never be another Persian empire

>Zoroastrianism will never be a dominant religion again




File: 1431743561530.jpg (131.49 KB, 364x550, 182:275, Propaganda-1.jpg)

665253 No.20079[Reply]

In this thread, post interesting/funny propaganda.

I will start by dumping a few. This one is poster by the French communist party, post WW2.

"No ! France will not become a colonized country !

Americans in America !"

82 posts and 78 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

e94a0d No.20354

>>20110

is that sargent d? also the writer sounds like the chinese guy from south park


e41d59 No.20414

is one on the left supposed to be pro-west?

I wouldn't want to live in either of the places as depicted


e41d59 No.20415


4e2366 No.20428

>>20125

Does anyone have any more with Santa? I like the idea of Santa going out to crush some Nazis or Jaos.


8bbda0 No.20434

>>20119

This is from World War 1?

It's completely objectively accurate.




YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

6a859b No.20152[Reply]

prepare your feels

0f9a10 No.20327

File: 1432084880201.jpg (124.69 KB, 500x500, 1:1, 1414535467348.jpg)


6a859b No.20339

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

7d4ea5 No.20367

>>20327

>picture of a german soldier in a british trench

hurr durr hurr


b5a35f No.20370

File: 1432180235980.gif (1.94 MB, 160x200, 4:5, Eat shit.gif)

>>20327

I regret ever using this picture, that's the Battle of Somme in the background, at least I hope that's WW1 German and not a Wehrmacht.


9b6881 No.20417

>>20367

>>20370

Maybe he got captured and is butthurt because it was Bratwurst night?




File: 1430593847896.jpg (49.09 KB, 441x518, 63:74, Ck_larax[1].jpg)

871886 No.19278[Reply]

Did anyone else history LARP as a young kid? I'm not talking about SCA type stuff, but just pretending to be famous kings and going out and "conquering" places.

871886 No.19279

I had this friend in 4th through 6th grade that was obsessed with the Huns, so we would gather in this baseball dugout on the playground and hold tribal councils and defend against this group of girls that would attack us.

I was a bit more involved in creating a backstory for all of this, so I assigned a country for all the groups on the playground, lumping all sorts of different time periods together.

The girls we fought were Egypt, a sort of fantasy Egypt ruled by sulty Oriental princesses and such. The football jocks were Babylon, the area by the door into the basement on the right was Antioch, the built-up area with the climbing walls was Phoenicia, etc. We would occasionally smuggle in big sticks and shields to fight battles, and when we had to go inside in the wintertime, we would surround ourselves with wrestling mats to create a "fortress". Still don't really know why I made everything Middle Eastern, since I really haven't been interested in that period much.

So, anyway, he would assign different historical figures to the five or so other guys in the group, like one guy was Bleda the Hun, I was Panu the Diplomat from RTW: Barbarian Invasion, etc.

The identity of our nation would change alot, depending on what nation or faction from video games we were interested in at the time.he was a massive Byzantineboo, so he styled himself Emperor Constantine for a while and gave me control of Adrianople. There were periodic exiles of certain members, and even an attempted coup once. Over the whole period from 4th to 6th grade, we were the Huns, Seleucids, Byzantines, the Novgorod Republic, Medieval Wales, Arthurian-era Wales (he was Welsh) a Scottish clan, an Iron Age Danish tribe, and even the Nootka Indians from the Pacific Northwest. Maximum autism all around.

Periodically I would try to declare us as a British Iron Age tribe, or as Gaelic Ireland, with constitutions and descriptions of military organizations written up complete with gratuitous use of Gaelic, but that never really took hold. We even used the Pagan symbol frmo Barbarian Invasion as a flag on occasion.


b87e60 No.19322

>>19278

I grew up listening to war stories from WWII vets. Me and my neighborhood friends only did Germans vs Americans. We made wooden MG-42s, thompsons, rifles, etc. We also wore helmets and camo. I guess it's a forum of LARP. We would go out to construction sites and dig foxholes and use smoke bombs as grenades. Seemed pretty real to an 10 year old.


40c1fb No.19341

>>19278

Is this not a usual thing for kids to pretend?


99a5bb No.20254

>>19341

Exactly. I think most kids play out historical shizzle


2708d5 No.20412

I was big into Star Wars as a kid, but as soon as I really began to love history(around 6th grade) I would play with them as if they were rulers of different kingdoms, at first as rulers of certain planets, with each play session being more or less tied to the Star Wars lore, depending on how I felt. Eventually it turned into history, I used to like to take out sheets of paper and draw battle formations and play and draw the progression of a battle, my enemy was always usually pretty stupid though so I always had myself win unless I just wanted to make it more dramatic or something.

Finding Rome: Total War was a real game changer for me.




File: 1432220326728.png (81.81 KB, 220x391, 220:391, 8chan_his_theodor_von_neuh….png)

fc85be No.20387[Reply]

Hey /his/. I know that in the past there were adenturers belonging to the dying caste of aristocrats in Europe, who went abroad searching for adventure in the form of fighting in distant wars. The practice died out eventually during the late 19th and early 20th century thanks to counties implementing laws against soldiers of fortunes, and the world wars. However, i think that the fight against the IS can be our era's Adventurer War. Is there any way one can go and form a foreign brigade or something? Just curious since Iraq and Syria seem to be able to do jack shit against them (Palmyra was LOST after a siege of only 7 DAYS, Assad wont be able to fucking save that shit in time)

29d838 No.20389

>>20387

>Is there any way one can go and form a foreign brigade or something?

Pretty sure there's westerners fighting with the Kurds + Assyrians in northern Iraq.

How to join them?

Idk, google is your friend (and tracks all your shit).

I've seen articles on Vice of dudes from the USA and UK going over there.


00b667 No.20391

>>20387

Have you tried checking on /pol/? A while back they had a few threads regarding that one assyrian militia and threads about Syria.

Apparently they don't really want you to join their army though (according to a Syrian guy on /pol/) but would appreciate donations and the like


fc85be No.20392

>>20391

I usually refrain from from going to places like /pol/ or /leftypol/. I feel dumber each time i visit them




File: 1432064928572.jpg (41.76 KB, 293x360, 293:360, RUStrotsky4.jpg)

df2a40 No.20323[Reply]

The year is 1927. Trotsky has been removed from the Communist Party and has been sentenced to exile. On his way out of Petrograd his vehicle, and escorts are attacked. He is removed from the car to find a group of Red Army officers. They claim to be loyal to Trotsky and want to dissolve the Communist Party, to be rebuilt by Trotsky himself.

What would Trotsky do?

If Trotsky were to agree, would the Five Year Plans have been put in place? The purges also?

>inb4 Trotsky did not want sole rule

He wouldn't have sole rule, he would just remove threats from power, such as Stalin.

>inb4 Trotsky would have agreed to be exiled

Trotsky had already tried to gain party support before his exile so he was now desperate.

>inb4 Trotsky was a Jew, he wouldn't want to be the leader of the Communist Party because of his image

Desperate times called for desperate measures

b6bb97 No.20333

Stalin did nothing wrong. Get fucked mongol


df2a40 No.20335

>>20333

Stalin didn't do anything wrong, I agree, he successfully industrialised Russia, crippled the power of the peasants and won the Second World War for Russia.


c957c4 No.20364

>>20323

Stalin dindu nuffin , he just needed to export more grain fo' dem programs.




File: 1430375221095.jpg (1.16 MB, 1440x757, 1440:757, history-bg-theme-1.jpg)

1354e0 No.19172[Reply]

Hello, I created an Humanities and Social Sciences board. I will be uploading books, articles, podcast and historic material for anyone that's interested in the historic discipline. If you want to share more material and discuss different subjects, you're invited and encouraged to do it. If you're interesed in history and other disciplines, you're invited to share anything you want, the more information and perspectives we have, the deeper our thought can be.

>>>/histories/

14 posts and 2 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

bb21e3 No.20093

>>19263

lol learn to read fag


bb21e3 No.20184

I dig a more academic thread with less shitposting. Will lurk


bb21e3 No.20185

>>20184

>>20046

Also before you guys say something, yes, I'm the same guy but I don't know of a better way to bump.


0e44c9 No.20266

bump


61ef90 No.20337

File: 1432113896741.jpg (23.57 KB, 300x100, 3:1, banner 3.jpg)

Last bump, promise.

Also I made some banners too.




File: 1431994776279.jpg (116.06 KB, 488x720, 61:90, MV5BMTk5MzU1MDMwMF5BMl5Ban….jpg)

13b97c No.20284[Reply]

Should I kill myself for loving this movie?

13b97c No.20285

I'm just not sure if what it tries to do with the narrative is worth the cliches it pays for them with


4251be No.20300

>being this insecure


06716e No.20307

>>20300

Its an exageration, common in shitposting


3447ff No.20322

No, but aside from some of the acting it was pretty shit.


a66ea3 No.20326

Yes.




File: 1421935145640.jpg (90.4 KB, 685x332, 685:332, image.jpg)

2809b6 No.13771[Reply]

Hey /his/ do you guys prefer "Byzantium" or "The Eastern Roman Empire" personally I think the latter sounds better but everyone seems to love Byzantium.

Side question, where did the name "Byzantium" come from?

>inb4 school

>inb4 homework
Graduated 3 years ago
32 posts and 2 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

b0b3bb No.20287

>>20265

>pretending nothing changed

That's not what I'm doing. Things change, but you don't change the name just because of it. Both a galleon and an aircraft carrier are a ship. The line of emperors was continued virtually unbroken after the fall of the west. It is literally the Roman Empire. Nothing more to it. A citizen in Rome in 500 B.C. is as Roman as a citizen in Constantinople in 1450 A.D.


fec231 No.20291

Eastern Roman Empire. Calling it just "Roman" is confusing, because most of the time it didn't even control Rome.

The city of Byzantium is not the same thing as Constantinople. They weren't the same city, so the term is misleading as well as derogatory. It was coined by a Renaissance historian.


5a2418 No.20292

>>20287

>A citizen in Rome in 500 B.C. is as Roman as a citizen in Constantinople in 1450 A.D.

Roman citizenship in 500 B.C. was a completely different thing to a citizen in Constantinople, or even Rome itself once the empire proper was established.


5a2418 No.20293

>>20291

The term Byzantine is rather elegant as a term, since it still refers to an empire dominated by a city-state (though no longer the city of Rome itself), but which also references the Greek nature and character of that state.


32524d No.20313

File: 1432044746200.jpg (1.43 MB, 4433x1858, 4433:1858, Battle_of_the_Milvian_Brid….jpg)

>>20275

>Rome

>backwater

Considering it hosted the highest religious authority in Western Europe and the lolSenate (okay, the Senate was useless, but old as shit and a symbol), I wouldn't call it unimportant or just a city among others. It was rich and populous, and the heart of at least half the Empire even after Diocletian. The last Western Roman Emperor was crowned in Rome.

The Byzantine rule after the Gothic War was non-existant, the Eastern Emperors didn't give a shit about Rome, and the Pope already ruled de facto before the end of the VI century.

The whole name question seems rather arbitrary to me. For every argument there's a counterexample, so we might as well stick to tradition. If you ask me, Roman Empire should be 27 BC - 395/1453 AD; WRE 395-476; ERE 395-1453 (not expressing opinions about the specific dates, just the nominal splitting of the Empire, Western and Eastern Fall). It's not rigorous, but straightforward. A galleon and an aircraft carrier might be both ships, but you don't call the USS Enterprise a ship, unless you're being vague on purpose.




File: 1431995165244.jpg (345.08 KB, 610x739, 610:739, dsds.jpg)

e0d4ec No.20286[Reply]

Stop scrolling

you now have ten seconds to equate all of life to the rise and downfall of Mesopotamia

go!

4e4ebb No.20294

File: 1432003675327.jpg (223.08 KB, 1200x849, 400:283, 13058141944_e996b3b0c7_o.jpg)

He Who Saw The Deep


44595b No.20296

I'm sorry, but could you repeat the question? I don't understand what you're asking, or at least I don't see the point or manageable scope.


244233 No.20298

I don't know I don't care about shit before thr 20th century.


7f7853 No.20301

>>20298

Do you happen to be American?


dac481 No.20303

Same shit different day, truly a 21st century epic™ tale.




File: 1431617068287.jpg (103.65 KB, 499x747, 499:747, 1431505408986.jpg)

08d1e8 No.19980[Reply]

Lets say a machine is invented that allows for instant revivals and or wound repairs. A new sport of modern rifle combat that is 15 v 15 comes to exist, and most people play it.

Lets say that some hippies chise to do 1v1 1450 combat instead, and they developed a ruleset:you can either get a full plate with a weapon and buckler, or a chainmail with a shield and two weapons. Which woukd you choose, and what armory woukd you bring?

Id probably choose platemail and bring a claymore, or a large sword with some weight on the hilt so you can hammer them with the hilt or buckler if they are a full plate

2 posts omitted. Click reply to view.

288ac4 No.20029

>>20027

>maille

>big shield

Nigga I'll jump behind you and stab your sorry ass, you'd be as agile as a dead sea lion.


aefb2b No.20043

>>20027

Nice theoretical prowess Will Keith.


b1e2ee No.20249

File: 1431934335721.jpg (359.57 KB, 1600x1005, 320:201, swiss2.jpg)

Plate plus halberd. Maybe a dagger but I doubt I'd need it. I don't give a fuck about your rules.

>not choosing a halberd

>not modifying the game type to be 30 v 30 medieval style battles.


ecdd03 No.20262

>>19980

chairman, wicker shield and harpoon, more of a skirmishing set but that's just the way I like it

also fuck your rules, 30 v 30


d7834c No.20283

>>20023

>Why does the maille guy get two weapons? It's not likely he could get away with swapping them mid-fight, in my opinion.

If you pack a short sword or a dagger it's perfectly feasible you could use it if you were disarmed or they got too close.




File: 1419666289600.png (43.47 KB, 800x480, 5:3, 1411311202275.png)

381910 No.12014[Reply]

Where are my Kaiser fags at? Also, please post anything related. I'm trying to build my folder. Also, This is a Imperial Germany appreciation thread.
87 posts and 66 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

297658 No.15951

>>14196
>They also estimated that, due to Russia’s vast land size, it’d take them around 950 hours to rally all the troops and take them to Germany. That meant that Germany had only a “window of opportunity” of just a bit more than a month to beat the french and get back to the east of Germany to fight the Russians.
It's quite ironic that at the end it was the other way around. I mean the ruskies got wrecked anyway, but still, it's like History tapped on Germanys shoulder and ran off laughing

79d77d No.15987

>>12937
I might be wrong but if I recall correctly, this picture is of a father and son (or grandfather and son?). The young man was about to go off and fight in the Great War, and his father/grandfather is wearing his uniform from when he served in the Franco-Prussian War.

271807 No.20257

File: 1431946274169.jpg (121.22 KB, 909x1433, 909:1433, 619fQsJl8BL.jpg)

I just picked up Iron Kingdom.

Anyone have any recommendations for similar books?


afaab7 No.20267

>>20257

Can't think of any off the top of my head but the guy did a really good job of listing sources and other stuff in the bibliography.

Honestly whatever part of the book interests you, just look up the citation number in the back. (Sorry I can't be more specific).

He lists scores, if not hundreds, of other books on Prussian/German history/culture/industry in the back.


6755bc No.20276

>>20257

If you like it, pick up The Sleepwalkers by the same author about the lead up to World War I. It does a nice job of countering the "it was all Germany and Austria's fault" narrative while not descending into full blown apologia.




YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

682ff8 No.20259[Reply]

sargon of akkad has a channel that he reads ancient texts on just dropped by just to see if /his/ was interested

pls no bully

e82749 No.20377

>>20259

Nice shill Sargon




YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

c699c5 No.15867[Reply]

Now im hating muslims and jews even more
55 posts and 18 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

08bdc5 No.17620

>>17618
Oh, I see. Thanks for the clarification

623db4 No.20205

File: 1431855152946.jpg (5.17 MB, 4272x2848, 3:2, Palmyra,_view_from_Qalaat_….jpg)

Fuck, they are close to take Palmyra too.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-32735677

"Palmyra, one of the archaeological jewels of the Middle East, is said to be under threat from Islamic State (IS) militants in Syria.

The jihadists seized buildings on the eastern edge of the adjacent city of Tadmur on Thursday, but their push was reportedly halted by the Syrian army.

Syria's antiquities chief warned that if IS seizes the Unesco World Heritage site it will destroy everything there.

The group has ransacked and demolished several ancient sites in Iraq.

Palmyra has already suffered some damage during the four-year civil war.

It is situated in a strategically important area on the road between the capital, Damascus and the contested eastern city of Deir al-Zour, and close to gas fields"


623db4 No.20207

File: 1431856176312.jpg (32.88 KB, 534x356, 3:2, 4634760_6_3cf3_la-cite-ant….jpg)


4adc76 No.20246

File: 1431920626676.jpg (36.65 KB, 500x310, 50:31, 1430374899687.jpg)

>>15869

They are both cancer. Muslims are straightforward cultural destruction, jews are insidious cultural destruction.


00c1b3 No.20248

>>15918

Don't forget the /pol/acks.




Delete Post [ ]
[]
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22]
| Catalog
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]