[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/his/ - History

Historical Discussion

Catalog

8chan Bitcoin address: 1NpQaXqmCBji6gfX8UgaQEmEstvVY7U32C
The next generation of Infinity is here (discussion) (contribute)
Email
Subject
Comment *
File *
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Flag
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
dicesidesmodifier
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


We oughta get a board mascot eventually. Feel free to stop by the sticky meta thread with suggestions.

File: 1431772218705.jpg (16.21 KB, 289x237, 289:237, kronstadt-sailors.jpg)

96a280 No.20158[Reply]

I'm planning on writing a story on the Kronstadt Sailors from 1917 to 1921, has anyone got any sources or speculation on what military campaigns and battles they had partook in?

I know they would have fought the Whites who were advancing towards Petrograd but I don't really know much else, to be honest.

4 posts omitted. Click reply to view.

1c3082 No.20235

>>20210

This isn't about the Kronstadt sailors specifically but useful for wider context (covering as it does both the October Revolution and Civil War afterwards): https://archive.org/details/TheGreatOctoberSocialistRevolution


96a280 No.20236

>>20235

Thanks anon but I just did a fuck-load of Russian History in my college course, just want to know a lot specifically about Kronstadt and military campaigns during the Civil War


96a280 No.20237

>>20194

Were the sailors separated into separate regiments or were they all still together? Probably a stupid question but this could change a lot of the plot


1c3082 No.20238

>>20237

I'm pretty sure people were sent all over the campaigns of the Civil War, wherever they were needed.


96a280 No.20239

>>20238

Brilliant, cheers anon




File: 1431349912584.jpg (189.02 KB, 563x721, 563:721, sad soldier.jpg)

24492e No.19750[Reply]

>you will never live in the Victorian era

5 posts and 4 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

d8f159 No.20063

>You will never be a noble of the Duchy of Burgundy, serving under Philip the Good.

>You will never fight the French alongside the English.

>You will never marry a German countess to secure your line, and sire many children


2eec4e No.20064

File: 1431728905307.jpg (32.56 KB, 521x521, 1:1, 1386891271938.jpg)

>>19754

Iktf, life is suffering

On a side note: anyone got some good literature on life in imperial Germany? I wanna know how much truth there is to this romantic view of prussian society


9eb560 No.20071

>>20036

>you will never be part of the UPA

>you will never fight off the home army , nazis ,and the gommies

>you will never drive the poles off your rightful clay

>you will never put up resistance to the soviets up until late '47

>you will never kill a general as creative as Nikolai Vatutin


ca1cba No.20072

File: 1431735523173.gif (987.87 KB, 500x400, 5:4, Whooooooooaaa.gif)

>>20071

>Slavs who fought communism and everyone else


35025b No.20227

>>20064

Considering the height of Prussiaboo Germany was during the Weimar Government and the Great Depression, it was probably better than what they had then.




File: 1430684592354.jpg (53.11 KB, 500x432, 125:108, 8chan_mongol_pimp.jpg)

f6d7d2 No.19324[Reply]

Friendly reminder that my business includes not only horses, but camels and goats as well

17 posts and 3 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

4538b8 No.19636

>>19608

Could you perhaps post a link anon? That way other friends will be able to learn


000000 No.19677


4538b8 No.19687

File: 1431266122363.jpg (358.28 KB, 307x397, 307:397, 8chan_his_happy_mongol.jpg)

>>19677

Many thanks


ddd009 No.20176

What is your internet and freedoms like? Do you get oppressed by China a lot?


9f42d2 No.20212

>>20176

Apart from this board i do not use computers much, i cannot tell you much about internet freedoms. China is a great exporter of rice and other crops to us, as far as i know they leave us be. But i live in the steppes most of my time, i cannot tell you much




File: 1431136753747.jpg (93.29 KB, 1536x1343, 1536:1343, T07573_10[1].jpg)

119671 No.19578[Reply]

Friendly reminder that duchamp is a faggot and ruined art.

>Art shouldn't be about skill but about expression!

27 posts and 16 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

9014f4 No.20066

File: 1431731288690.jpg (43.51 KB, 200x285, 40:57, 1637-cohen04culturalcoldwa….jpg)

Friendly reminder modern art was funded in the 60's by the CIA and that's the only reason it has ever been taken seriously by anyone. Because someone threw enough money at it.


22d9b8 No.20075

>>20062

Yes, if I own something I would only let people use it on my own terms (contract). That is inevitable when you don't have a moderating power that binds you by it's laws simply because you were born under it's dominion (state, council, syndicate, etc).

In a society without centralized power nothing stops you from owning something and trading it for something else that you, subjectively, values more or letting people use it under you own terms (contract). There's no one imposing a fixed set of values or the inability to "own" material things.


d6a1b2 No.20163

>>20075

Sure, but capitalism tends to imply more than that, if it were just what you said there i'd have no problem with it, but the reality is not so simple.


c451ed No.20174

File: 1431795528890-0.jpg (65.12 KB, 1024x782, 512:391, mCovx9M.jpg)

File: 1431795528892-1.jpg (204.06 KB, 1280x977, 1280:977, BTPruVv.jpg)

File: 1431795528893-2.jpg (104.13 KB, 1024x796, 256:199, 8dX7l3j.jpg)

You plebs don't get art.


c451ed No.20175

File: 1431795598374-0.jpg (454.88 KB, 1024x680, 128:85, clip_image001.jpg)

File: 1431795598375-1.jpg (279.89 KB, 1280x977, 1280:977, laFB4VV.jpg)




YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

f1def7 No.15974[Reply]

What's /his/' thoughts on this series?
3 posts and 1 image reply omitted. Click reply to view.

821d7b No.16055

>Singapore
>Pronounce it as Sing-Gah-Pore

Triggered.

aed3cf No.16058

>>16055
How are you supposed to pronounce it?

Don't tell me I've been doing it wrong my whole life

821d7b No.16096

>>16058
Not a complain, really. Just poking fun at the videos they have.
The correct pronunciation (that the people and their neighbours use) is:

See-nga-pore

dad85c No.20055

File: 1431707354017.jpg (58.63 KB, 450x450, 1:1, no no.jpg)

He's fat and still gaining but other than that it's O.K..


f16add No.20151

>>16026

Than watch it in German or Polish?




File: 1423332125964.png (1.36 MB, 1099x837, 1099:837, kingdom_of_bosnia_by_zalez….png)

d2c022 No.14892[Reply]

That battles are indeed won by the mind because most if not almost all battles fought have been won by breaking the enemies morale, not actually killing them to the last man.
>inb4 sacred band of thebes
Also, what's your favourite battle /his/?
>inb4 emu wars
45 posts and 9 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

72121d No.19963

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Vaslui

This is Kebab Removal at its finest


5cec30 No.19965

>>18294

God is a Serb and Serbia once ruled all of the Balkans, all the way up to modern Berlin and down to the deserts of Egypt.

Am I posting real history now, Serbshit?


91dc54 No.20022

>>19965

Getting a little bit butthurt my friend.

Is it because you are poturica?


640e8d No.20048

>>18294

That's just denying historical facts.


ee7afd No.20067

>>20048

What historical facts?

What Bosnian ruler did rule over medieval Serbia?




File: 1429834176587.jpg (719.92 KB, 915x1500, 61:100, tranhungdao1.jpg)

3b7bf1 No.18847[Reply]

Think of your ethnic heritage.

Now post a historic warrior or general you associate most with your ethnicity.

"Tran Hung Dao, original name Tran Quoc Tuan, also called Hung Dao Vuong (born 1229?—died 1300, Van Kiep, Vietnam), figure of almost legendary proportions in Vietnamese history, a brilliant military strategist who defeated two Mongol invasions and became a cultural hero among modern Vietnamese."

http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/602242/Tran-Hung-Dao

8 posts and 3 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

bbbe92 No.19905

File: 1431535793025.jpg (43.75 KB, 251x356, 251:356, Sauerkraut_remover.jpg)

>>18847

i'm more or less 100% slovene barring an italoian grand-grand-grand-grand-grand uncle who was italian and my grand-grand-grand-grand aunt (from another branch than the italian) who was a pure blooded Von Auersperg but ran off with my probably handsome ancestor. So probably this bastard over here. He was an introverted major, who was also a poet in his free time till A-H fell apart. Then he became the first commander of the ex-austrian Slovene army and rekt the Austrians in eastern Slovenia (Maribor), enlarging our national territory.


2618e4 No.20002

File: 1431620014741.jpeg (37.97 KB, 472x594, 236:297, Gabriele-D’Annunzio.jpeg)

Gabriele D'Annunzio, poet and hero.

>mfw Italians backstab him too

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_Regency_of_Carnaro


334a45 No.20004

File: 1431622455695.jpg (81.29 KB, 640x861, 640:861, Marcel_Weinum_(1924-1942).jpg)

"I die with a pure heart"

- Michel Weinum, alsatian founder of the first organisation of resistance against the nazi occupation


d2886c No.20008

File: 1431625088726.jpg (147.99 KB, 1095x1480, 219:296, robert_e_lee.jpg)

Anglo-Saxon and American. Most of the best generals joined the confederacy because they were loyal to their home states. Lee is the most iconic.


ddfff3 No.20059

File: 1431724727530-0.jpg (151.28 KB, 577x716, 577:716, cromwell.jpg)

File: 1431724727530-1.jpg (48.04 KB, 600x399, 200:133, alfred-o.jpg)

English, Scottish, Scandinavian and possibly German. Primarily English.

Cromwell or Wellington.

My roots are around Somerset though, so Alfred the Great.




File: 1431624004118.jpg (8.65 KB, 540x694, 270:347, Adam_Smith_The_Muir_portra….jpg)

58b0ab No.20005[Reply]

Would capitalism be viewed as ideological if the axis won in ww2?

fac2a7 No.20018

The Nazis considered themselves anti-Marxist socialists and in theory condemned "decadent capitalism" as much as "Judeo-Bolshevism," so yes. I'd imagine there would still be economists denouncing the Nazi system as totalitarian and calling for free markets and whatnot.




File: 1431566517816.jpg (6.51 KB, 158x200, 79:100, 0228211340.jpg)

69fba4 No.19938[Reply]

>TIL Marx played an important role in the Union winning the Civil War.

At least according to a Russian friend of mine, who has a Soviet book from 1976 (in Russian) on American history. According to the book Karl Marx led the workers of Lancashire and of Britain in general to reject Confederate imports, and the political activity of the British Marxists and allied radical groups successfully prevented Britain from intervening to crush the Union.

According to the Soviet book, this was tantamount to Karl Marx playing an indispensable role in the victory of the Union over the Confederacy. The book also quotes Lincoln praising the British workers led by Marx and of Marx writing a letter to Lincoln praising his re-election, which the book claims Marxists helped ensure.

Conclusion of the book on this subject: "It is not surprising, therefore, that the leader of the international communist and workers' movements should have exercised a world-historical influence in fields as deep as international diplomacy and military strategy. Indeed, Marx and Engels together predicted with brilliant accuracy the course of the Civil War and once more displayed their genius for historical methodology. Their radiant activities during this period showed once again their worldwide influence."

So far I'm trying to find proof of all this. This is what I've found:

Exhibit #1: A biography of one of the first American Marxists, a Colonel in the Union Army: https://archive.org/details/JosephWeydemeyerPioneerOfAmericanSocialism

Exhibit #2, 1952 History of the Communist Party USA, Chapter Three: http://williamzfoster.blogspot.com/2013/01/chapter-three-marxists-in-struggle.html

(quoting excerpts, whole chapter is interesting)

>Hence, from the very beginning, the Marxists raised the decisive slogPost too long. Click here to view the full text.

4401b6 No.19955

>>19938

>1976

>Sovijet book about America

Do you not see the pattern?


69fba4 No.19976

>>19955

Only problem I see is that the Soviets are obviously going to portray Marx in a good light and damn the USA, but in this case they thought Lincoln was a "bourgeois revolutionary" who was destroying an archaic mode of production (slavery) in order to further capitalist development across the whole country, so it's one of the few instances where the USA isn't portrayed as a total hell on earth.


98790b No.19977

File: 1431616386524.jpg (215.27 KB, 700x500, 7:5, ejercitoCSA1.jpg)

>>19938

It's undeniable that when the UK stopped to supply the Confederacy with weapons it was partly because of the strikes and demonstrations of the workers, which refused to work for a state that endorsed slavery. This led to the Confederation's lack of various supplies (Lee-Enfield rifles, blue dye and shoes being the most dearly missed). But to say that Marx played an important role in the Union winning the Civil War is a bit of an overstatement. It fits the context (Sovjet book on Amerika) though.




File: 1430009110750.jpeg (75.6 KB, 334x250, 167:125, ho-chi-minh-AB.jpeg)

878893 No.18942[Reply]

This upcoming April 30th is the 40th anniversary of the Fall of Saigon.

April 30th is Reunification/Liberation Day in Vietnam. A day of celebration for most Vietnamese living within Vietnam.

In terms of Viet Kieu, or Overseas Vietnamese it is a day of reflection. For them it is called Black April or National Day of Shame.

So Vietnam thread. Doesn't gotta be about Vietnam's conflicts with the West in the 20th century either. Ancient history or recent developments are welcome too.

56 posts and 147 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

2aa9a2 No.19067

OP, offer some perspectives you have on the war as a civilian growing up in modern vietnam.


4ec162 No.19076

OP here. I have been kind of busy with school lately. I had only dumped the first 5 sets of pics. Not sure who did the rest.


0a10fa No.19086

What's the vietnamese stance on the chinese influence? I'm not talking about recent conflicts, but about when did it start, were there different waves or a continuous, persistent contact, etc.

I know the general view of the chinese was that "the south" (and that included southern China in the earliest times) was inhabited by barbarians who were ripe for conquest, and sometimes it was seen as not worthy the economic and demographic effort.


878893 No.19906

I'm back and free finally.

>>19067

I was born in the United States.

>>19086

For many periods of Chinese history, Vietnam was part of it's territory or vice versa. (Throughout most of Vietnamese history, North Vietnam -was- Vietnam. The lower half was control by Champ and the Khmer Empire). So I think for some periods of history, the land of Vietnam was desired, but it's a bit hard to control due to Vietnam's unique geography.

As for how the people felt there is definitely a sense of bitterness against the Chinese. There was even a huge movement against Chinese culture in Vietnam, which was suppressed by the Ming Dynasty. In response to the destruction of Chinese culture in Vietnam, they destroyed Vietnamese culture and forced the Vietnamese to adopt Chinese cukture. That's why there is a lack of ancient Vietnamese art and Chu Nom writings from this period. That's why there is more overlap between Vietnamese and Chinese culture than say with Korean or Japanese culture.

As for modern times the resentment is still there. Lion Dance festivals are held during special event and Confucius is revered like in China, Japan, and Korea, but resentment is still there as evidenced by recent happenings in the South China Sea. Overseas Vietnamese also view Vietnam or atleast the CPV as puppets of China or the CCP.


ede85b No.19931

A 1972 multilingual Soviet book (in Russian and English) on the Vietnam War got uploaded earlier today: https://archive.org/details/TheVietnamStory




File: 1431392729853.jpg (66.56 KB, 454x453, 454:453, pepefacade.jpg)

057e58 No.19780[Reply]

>got the opportunity to present a lesson on Rome

>chose the period between 100-40 B.C., Marian reforms, Sulla's civil war, Caesar, etc.

>get to make my own quiz too

>I'm such a lazy piece of shit I don't even do it

2 posts omitted. Click reply to view.

e9297d No.19839

Fuck.

I love Sulla you bastard!


057e58 No.19868

>>19790

>>19823

>>19839

Ok false alarm I actually managed to get it done

And I didn't cover Ceasar, just the time from the Jugurthine war to Sulla's death


9eacb3 No.19885

File: 1431506115413.png (284.95 KB, 476x530, 238:265, 1413602895958.png)

>got the opportunity talk about a historical subject of my choosing in a study session

>say I've been studying Rome recently

>poorly attempt to summarize founding legends

>the content of my speech isn't helpful at all in regards to the upcoming test

>people stop caring and get back to studying

>but one qt seemed very interested

>even shushed others when they began speaking among themselves

>accosted me and asked me to continue telling the story

>stumble over myself some more

>got up to the Rape of Sabines and election of Numa Pompilius before she decided that was enough (I guess)

>when she's leaving early, stop her at the door and hastily recommend the History of Rome Podcast and Livy's books

>she seems genuinely grateful

>get back to my seat, female friend asks if I know well enough not to cheat

>I'm already in a relationship

>now blogging about it


5ec860 No.19893

File: 1431524069440.jpg (78.21 KB, 876x773, 876:773, 1431146677971.jpg)

>>19885

>tfw no qt gf to share historical appreciation with


945fdb No.19919

File: 1431544920042.jpg (21.11 KB, 255x254, 255:254, 1429065551212-1.jpg)

>>19893

why live




File: 1431327185791.jpg (49.28 KB, 609x480, 203:160, maa-kali.jpg)

c9157b No.19730[Reply]

ITT: Gods and Goddesses

18 posts and 5 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

c86026 No.19875

>>19866

>Raoh

My nigga of the North Star. I forgot to mention these are called Ni-Oh, legend tells that they were once fearsome demon kings until the Buddha met them and taught the way of wisdom. They protect temples from evil spirits with their fearsome appearance.

>>19736

Also I didn't really answer your question but Bishamonten in Mahayana was a heavenly protector and I think a protector of buddhism.


edaddd No.19909

File: 1431536455989.jpg (Spoiler Image, 304.73 KB, 482x720, 241:360, priapus.jpg)

>he doesn't worship the god of dick


0f725f No.24374

benis


0f725f No.24375

fug :D


0f725f No.24376

e/b/in :DD




File: 1431533939385.jpg (17.9 KB, 532x387, 532:387, hay_diosmio.jpg)

d81df5 No.19901[Reply]

Hey /his/, ive been reading up on the history of the founding of Argentina and i cant make sense of the whole damn thing. First it was a confederation then a federations then a loose union then it was engulfed in 60 years of civil war i mean what the fuck.

>pic related

Any help?



File: 1428327282838-0.jpg (132.18 KB, 800x1204, 200:301, sangokushi-4055257.jpg)

File: 1428327282838-1.jpg (268.65 KB, 929x1400, 929:1400, 0289-002.png.jpg)

File: 1428327282838-2.png (301.31 KB, 700x1047, 700:1047, 0004.png)

88cba7 No.17830[Reply]

When you recommend something, post a decent download link as well, if you can.

Sangokushi
https://www.mediafire.com/sangokushi
An epic manga adaption of the most famous work of historical literature in china, the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Decades of political intrigue, warfare and dramatic characters, set in the Three Kingdoms period of ancient china, 169 AD.

Simple, but beautiful art, well done storytelling and easy to follow. A great gateway into the world of RoTK.
32 posts and 34 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

d046f9 No.19718

>>19717

Batoto can be kind of shitty for having all of a series if it's licensed or the group doesn't allow hosting. It I can't find something I usually check for it on kissmanga.

http://kissmanga.com/Manga/Gunka-no-Baltzar


d046f9 No.19719

File: 1431293999750.jpg (405.57 KB, 1456x1038, 728:519, 3.jpg)

Arslan Senki-In the prosperous kingdom of Pars lies the Royal Capital of Ecbatana, a city of splendor and wonder, ruled by the undefeated and fearsome King Andragoras. Arslan is the young and curious prince of Pars who, despite his best efforts, doesn't seem to have what it takes to be a proper king like his father.

At the age of 14, Arslan goes to his first battle and loses everything as the blood-soaked mist of war gives way to scorching flames, bringing him to face the demise of his once glorious kingdom. However, it is Arslan's destiny to be a ruler, and despite the trials that face him, he must now embark on a journey to reclaim his fallen kingdom.

The writer of this is the guy who wrote LoGH for anyone that cares. Also has an anime currently airing that isn't half bad.


255f26 No.19879

Two mangas from me. One, Samurai Executioner. Its about the Shogun's sword tester nicknamed Kubikiri Asa (Headcutter Asa). It shows you how savage Sengoku Era Japan could be, but also how diametric human nature could be. The main character is a man who constantly walks the line between life and death, a line which he clearly understands

http://mangafox.me/manga/samurai_executioner/

The second one is a manga called Bokko. About the kingdoms of China pre-Jin dynasty unification. An interesting work that shows the perils of both siege warfare, the relationships between soldiers and peasants and the machinations that lead to war.

http://mangafox.me/manga/bokko/


c5c8df No.19886

File: 1431509119260.jpg (107.23 KB, 333x500, 333:500, sighs one-eyedly.jpg)

>>19879

>links 404

I wanted to spend hours searching for them in the local Book-Off 100 yen section anyway, aniki.


255f26 No.19897

>>19886

Sorry Kouhei, but these links work for me. Her let me provide you an alternative. Oh and Bokko is only available in french.

http://kissmanga.com/Manga/Bokko

For samurai executioner, you can find it online as a book, since it was published by dark horse. Sorry for the links aniki.




File: 1426315113622.jpg (134.79 KB, 1200x1031, 1200:1031, 1410229234534.jpg)

149402 No.16657[Reply]

So there's this thread on /pol/:
http://8ch.net/pol/res/1434169.html

What I've gathered from the posters is that Islam ended the Classical world. Now /pol/ is generally shit but sometimes I get a nice talk on economics in between the piles of threads on white nationalism. For History stuff like this, I'd thought I'd ask you guys since experience has taught me to treat /pol/ infographic stuff with a grain of salt.

Thoughts?

Pic unrelated, was just something /his/ that happened to be in my fap folder.
33 posts and 2 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

b8740c No.19711

>>19702

It wasn't a question of if, but how much.

Neglect doesn't just mean to completely abandon.


204c07 No.19746

>>19691

Touché, you obviously know more than i do.

You seem to know deeply the Late Antiquity, do you have any books to recommend?


7382a6 No.19761

>>19746

Lots of PDFs from JSTOR and Academia.edu, but for accessible books try Wickham's "Inheritance of Rome" for a broad overview.


472375 No.19856

File: 1431458470516.jpg (96.52 KB, 963x603, 107:67, 1430593612812.jpg)

Relevant.


1259f2 No.19895

>>19856

Do you have the equivalent map for the V century?




Delete Post [ ]
[]
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22]
| Catalog
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]