[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/his/ - History

Historical Discussion

Catalog

8chan Bitcoin address: 1NpQaXqmCBji6gfX8UgaQEmEstvVY7U32C
The next generation of Infinity is here (discussion) (contribute)
Email
Subject
Comment *
File *
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Flag
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
dicesidesmodifier
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


We oughta get a board mascot eventually. Feel free to stop by the sticky meta thread with suggestions.

File: 1437916627438.jpeg (304.58 KB, 1198x1600, 599:800, Decline and Fall.jpeg)

fd9a68 No.24508[Reply]

Does /his/ know this book? Any opinions?

9e6b42 No.24511

It looks like something one would read while under the influence of cannabis, what is this anon?


fd9a68 No.24525

>>24511

Basically it's a humorous description of various rulers and famous people ranging from some of the Egyptian Pharaos to (if memory serves) Louis XIV. It's been written somewhere in the fifties, so some of the descriptions are outdated (and some are not intended to be taken serious), but Cuppy faux-seriously describing Lucrezia Borgia (and her brothers) as a being of saint-like innocence that only had people dropping dead left and right around her out of coincidence is pretty funny.

Cuppy also mocks other classic and contemporary historians - the name of the book itself is a parody of Gibbons The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. In a chapter about Alexander the Great, he also describes how Alexander was being called "The Great" because he killed more people than anyone before him as a Warlord, and adds a footnote according to which one other historian (whose name evades me) therefore described him as an Apostle of Peace

It's pretty amusing imho, but I was wondering if anyone else here had read it.


9e6b42 No.24547

>>24525

Never really liked Gibbons, too many moralistic reasons on the why of things. I think ill go look for this book actually, is it being sold on places like amazon anon? Or is it a special editorial book or something


fd9a68 No.24560

>>24547

You should be able to find a copy on amazon or most other stores that sell used books. However, I'm pretty sure there's also a PDF of it flying somewhere around it on the net.




File: 1436435975444.jpg (110.03 KB, 600x800, 3:4, ac6.jpg)

05ae01 No.23480[Reply]

Ave, my name is Gneo Giulio Ken.

I’m a 27 year old Italian res publica fanaticus (early roman republic fan for you barbarians). I draw dicks and shitpost on my wall, and spend my days perfecting my graffiti art and playing superior roman games. (Pancratium, Cestus and Petarum)

I train with my Gladius every day, this superior weapon can pierce clean through steel because its tip has a perfect angle, and is vastly superior to any other weapon on earth. I earned my sword license two years ago, and I have been getting better every day thanks to my training in the campus martius.

I speak Latin fluently, and I write fluently as well (especially on walls). I know everything about roman history and their pietas code, which I follow 100%

When I get my Lazio visa, I am moving to Rome to attend a prestigious High School to learn more about their magnificent culture. I hope I can become an archeologist.

I own several loricae, which I wear around town. I want to get used to wearing them before I move to Rome, so I can fit in easier. I bow to my pater and seniors and speak Latin as often as I can, but rarely does anyone manage to respond.

Wish me luck in Rome!

32 posts and 15 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

8d6081 No.23721

File: 1436742337925.png (26.62 KB, 853x543, 853:543, template.png)

>>23684

"freedom ain't free"

original one is the american

this is the template


f4ffba No.23732

File: 1436754725658.jpg (14.43 KB, 190x200, 19:20, image.jpg)

>>23480

Quality post


c6fe5b No.24264

File: 1437543534179.jpg (77.11 KB, 333x500, 333:500, caesarbust.jpg)


356fc2 No.24557

File: 1437990563966.png (756.26 KB, 1600x660, 80:33, ken-sama derivatives.png)

ごめんなさい。わたしの名前はケン様です。

27歳のアメリカ人のオタク(アニメファンのことだよ、外人ども)です。タブレットでアニメとマンガを描いています。自分のアートを向上させることと上質な日本製ゲーム(ディスガイア、ファイナルファンタジー、ペルソナシリーズ)をプレイすることに日々を費やしています。

刀の訓練を毎日しています。この優れた武器は、1000回以上折り返し鍛錬を重ねて作られていて地球上のどんな武器よりも圧倒的に優れているため、鋼鉄を完全に切り裂くことができます。2年前に刀ライセンスを取得して、日々上達しています。

日本語を流暢にしゃべれます(漢字と大阪弁の両方です)。書くのも上手にできます。日本史と武士道の規律(わたしは100%従っています)について全てを知っています。

日本のビザを取得したら、壮大な日本文化を一流の高校でさらに学ぶために東京に住みます。スタジオジブリのアニメーターかゲームデザイナーになりたいです!

着物を何着か持っていて、着物で街に繰り出しています。日本到着前に、着物の着こなしを身に付けておきたいです。そうすれば、より容易に日本に融け込めるからです。年長者にはおじぎをして日本語を話すようにできるだけしていますが、あまり誰も反応してくれません。

日本でうまくいくように祈ってください!


e1ca23 No.24559

>superior Roman games. (Pancratium, Cestus and Petarium).

>Pancratium

>Roman

Get the fuck out, you cultural leech.




File: 1435924020988.jpg (132.45 KB, 960x720, 4:3, 1359900307430.jpg)

e34aec No.22973[Reply]

So can you guys recommend me any good documentaries or youtube channels to watch to learn history? I do kind of prefer medieval history but any history related media would be cool.

I'll settle for just really realistic TV show or movie.

15 posts and 1 image reply omitted. Click reply to view.

3e2bd9 No.23973

File: 1437118475731.jpg (24.54 KB, 250x333, 250:333, 83ba227df1d41ad02e1c54bc20….jpg)

>>22973

>So can you guys recommend me any good documentaries or youtube channels to watch to learn history?

Matt Easton (scholagladiatoria on Youtube) talks about historical martial arts. He is pretty legit and entertaining.

CaspianReport is some Azerbaijani independent documentary guy, he is interesting in that his stuff is well researched and he gives the unusual point of view of somebody from the east.

Most documentaries and Youtube channels are from a western point of view, and the guy is both ex USSR and a muslim, so he is good for flavor. Good to listen to people you subjectively disagree with from time to time.

BBC has these excellent educational documentary series about how life was for the ordinary man in different times of the history of England - Victorian Farm, Victorian Pharmacy, Edwardian Farm, Tudor Monastery Farm and Wartime Farm.

All of those are very, very good, well researched and are done like a reality TV show, in that the historians are living like they used to in that period and finding things out through experimental archeology.

Actually, most BBC documentaries are good and I enjoy them, as long as you remember they are entertainment programs first and only second educational ones.


425ae4 No.23981

>>23973

>Matt Easton (scholagladiatoria on Youtube) talks about historical martial arts. He is pretty legit and entertaining.

Love that guy

I also listen to Skallagrim and Lindybiege


000000 No.23985

>>23973

>CaspianReport

Never heard of this guy before, looks interesting

>>23981

>Lindybiege

He's a cool mofo


425ae4 No.24101

>>23985

I also appreciate how Lindy talks about games as well which is pretty fun


3e2bd9 No.24558

https://www.youtube.com/user/TheGreatWar/videos

This channel explains events in WWI, exactly 100 years after they happened, going week by week.

Its pretty good and I really enjoy it. Note of advice, though, it lacks the pro-German feeling that 99% of all historians who are into WWI seem to have.




File: 1411264302687.jpg (190.19 KB, 1023x647, 1023:647, Rhompaia.jpg)

108733 No.363[Reply][Last 50 Posts]

ITT - Underappreciated weapons.
236 posts and 88 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

b3958f No.24328

>>24077

>"steel"

Anything with more than .3% carbon is steel, it might be mild steel but it is still considered it

>2000 "folds"

Which amounts too 10 stacks and forge welds, it would require less if they used more layers

I would go through point by point but I'm too triggered to type right now ;"(


676960 No.24396

>>24267

I remember Scandinavians having Helmets that looked very similar, with the Chain and Eye piece designs,


676960 No.24398

>>24326

>implying German Trench knives weren't better


8e193d No.24538

File: 1437945679771.jpg (11.86 KB, 650x221, 50:17, kp_m45.jpg)

The Carl Gustav m/45 submachinegun


ac68bf No.24542

>>1876

>pirate Strongman training

any research on this?




File: 1437948760033.jpg (27.26 KB, 250x310, 25:31, 470.jpg)

002e78 No.24540[Reply]

what are some modern books dealing with France's past before the disgusting french revolution?

mainly dealing with the catholic and monarchical aspects of french history



File: 1437129673813.jpg (2.24 MB, 2608x2608, 1:1, jihad.jpg)

7fff75 No.23984[Reply]

Jihad thread, in which we talk about the ways muslims declaring jihad have influenced history for better or worse.

To get things started, here are a few points of interest:

>do you see jihad as a code of honor thing or as a send the fools to the meat grinder so our army has an easier time immoral tactic?

>was the ottoman conquest of byzantium and bulgaria jihad or just imperialism?

>does declaring jihad on other muslims make a lick of sense and why?

>is jihad relevant as a military strategy today?

22 posts and 9 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

909bcd No.24269

>>24199

>pre-islamic poetry

Ibn Qayyim Al-Jauziyyah did quote some pre-islamic poetry in Raudah Al-Muhibbin wa Nuzhah Al-Mustaqin as example of jahiliya love.

I wonder if there's any english translation of them.


15ec25 No.24276

>Encouraged by the CIA, Pakistani Intelligence also focused on sabotage operations that would cut Soviet supply lines. But the missions often proved difficult because even the most ardent Afghan Islamists refused to mount suicide operations.

>The afghans whom Yousaf (ISI) trained uniformly denounced suicide attack proposals as against their religion.

>It was only the Arab volunteers - from Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Algeria, and other countries, who had been raised in an entirely different culture, spoke their own language, and preached their own interpretations of Islam while fighting far from their homes and families - who later advocated suicide attacks. Afghan jihadists, tightly woven into family, clan and regional social networks, never embraced suicied tactics in significant numbers.

(Ghost Wars, Steve Coll, chptr 7, pg 134)

I didn't want to make another thread about jihad, so I'll ask this here.

Would anyone be able to inform me on the differences in the way Afghan muslims interpret Islam compared to the way Saudi Arabian, Jordanian, Algerian, and other countries muslims interpret Islam?


000000 No.24333

>>24276

I'm guessing the ones who introduced suicide attacks to the Afghans were Wahhabi


1b780e No.24353

>>24276

Most Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Indian follow Hanafi school. There's already bit about use of violence according Hanafi school in wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanafi#Violence

>>24333

>wahhabi

You mean takfiris? Official wahhabi sponsored by Saudi denounce it.


010dfb No.24521

>>24168

yeah, Palestine's Hamas are legitimately decent people




File: 1436154445772.jpg (75.68 KB, 680x529, 680:529, feels latin.jpg)

b4f2c8 No.23224[Reply]

>tfw this is legitimately the only non-autistic board on this site

15 posts and 2 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

1072a0 No.23568

File: 1436523627320.jpg (16.38 KB, 463x331, 463:331, kaiba.jpg)

>>23555

>self admittedly autistic

That counts for even less than your trips, and you know it, Yugi-boy.


1a42ba No.23682

File: 1436673390246.webm (1.04 MB, 640x360, 16:9, You Have Autism.webm)


123a2c No.23686

File: 1436674596762.webm (Spoiler Image, 2.37 MB, 640x360, 16:9, where do you think we are….webm)


b4f2c8 No.23692

>>23686

REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE


2b9bae No.24520

Autism and history go well together




File: 1436591816872-0.jpg (69.5 KB, 640x427, 640:427, anticav3.jpg)

File: 1436591816872-1.jpg (95.23 KB, 660x790, 66:79, anticav5.jpg)

File: 1436591816873-2.png (173.21 KB, 350x197, 350:197, anticav1.png)

15a64b No.23618[Reply]

LET'S TALK ABOUT POLEARMS

From the simple spear to the hefty halberd, polearms have been used by pretty much every culture across the planet due to (generally) thanks to how simple they are to use and how versatile they are. Alexander conquered the world with the 22 foot long sarissa, the elite heavy cavalry of England were thwarted by Scottish pikes at Bannockburn, and mercenaries like the Landsknecht and the Gallowglass became some of the most feared and sought-after infantry in Europe due to their proficiency with heavy polearms.

With a history and diversity as deep and varied as some other topics discussed on this board, lets stop shitposting about horsefuckers and olive-munchers for a few minutes to talk about, arguably, the weapons that have killed more people than any other.

I'll kick us off with a question that's been bugging me for a while. How effective are massed spears at stopping a heavy cavalry charge? Surely the weight of an armoured horse at full pace would be able to disrupt the battle line? Even if the horse is galled or killed, it's still traveling at speed and the sheer weight of it would probably end up falling onto the spearmen in front of it, right?

38 posts and 5 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

cbf5f0 No.24461

>>24404

It makes sense if it is a marching formation. The shot in the center can fan out to cover the pikes on the sides. Just a guess, though, I have no clue. And an aggressive pike formation the center fits the aggressive Swedish tactics.

>>24413

Whoops

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Bagradas

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Cannae

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Carrhae

None of those were on "broken ground" and the Romans outnumbered their enemies.


e73a1a No.24479


57f66f No.24486

>>24479

That battle has already been mentioned here >>23642


b3c88c No.24490

>>24461

>Bagradas

The reason they won that was because of Elephants and the fact their cavalry was outnumbered, and the fact that the split up Roman troops decided to attack the Phalanx on their own instead of regrouping because the commanders were really fucking stupid,and in that battle though Rome lost the Infantry had beat the shit out of the Mercenary troops in the one part of the battle.

>Carrhea

For one Crassus was a retard,

>"haha I'm going to invade without telling anyone"

>March troops for days in hot ass desert

>" lol the enemy has 9000 Horse Archers but it's okay 4 thousand cavalry should be more than enough to beat that advantage of theirs xD"

>Cannae

Hannibal was a crafty motherfucker, but it was also die to, again retardation on the Roman part:

>lol let's interchange command frequently

and then again, Hannibal is a crafty mother fucker and wins not from fighting alone, but severing supply depots, installing fear into roman ranks, and the like.

But if you look at the Gallic wars, and the Various Roman wars in the Balkans you'll see that challenging Romans on open ground (unless you have shit up your sleeve) is really fucking stupid.


e73a1a No.24491

>>24486

Ah I see, sorry will read more carefully next time!




File: 1437621719655.jpg (396.25 KB, 1500x2250, 2:3, augustus statue.jpg)

4ef1a9 No.24338[Reply]

>Walking through the forum

>This guy slaps your slave's ass

What do? Keep in mind he's Imperator and divus

6 posts and 2 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

d35af6 No.24391

>>24377

fucking Nice, most underrated post on the board

>>24384

>wanting those faggots coming here

MC fucking kill yourself


8a8777 No.24448

>>24384

>telling halfchan to come here

Kill yourself faggot.


df2d33 No.24466

>walking through the street with my slave

>Some guy slaps my slaves ass

>Fine take it, he has a penis for some reason anyways

>all of the sudden see legionaries come and chop the motherfucker down

>what the fuck?

>turns out, the slave was actually the gay emperor dressed up as a slave

>I had sex with a gay fucking 14-year old

>eventually die of herpes


9b9d82 No.24469

>>24384

Don't repeat the same mistake twice.


b58aaa No.24481

File: 1437846584010.gif (288.93 KB, 400x225, 16:9, dieinafire.gif)

>>24384

>telling halfchan to come here




File: 1437828328520.jpg (86.28 KB, 752x508, 188:127, Talas.jpg)

de06d2 No.24474[Reply]

>Wake up

>See this

You have been teleported on Talas, 751 AD! @ most strongest empires on earth are clashing!

Who's side will you choose? Muslims? or Tang Dynasty?

594ae8 No.24475

The thongs.




File: 1435797066847.jpg (6.9 KB, 184x184, 1:1, 8chan_his_steam_group_avat….jpg)

ff8048 No.22872[Reply]

Hey all, im the moderator in the /his/ Steam Group. Ill be posting here everything about this shindig, so please you guy do so too.

SteamLink:

https://staging.steamcommunity.com/groups/hissteam

Im planning a couple of events, however i need to know what /his/-themed games you guys have (including mods). Link here for the strawpoll. Its pretty big so i hope most games will be covered, if i forget any games that you guys might have please post them here.

Game strawpoll:

http://strawpoll.me/4801198

Suggestions, future games, events, and discussions are welcome too, just keep them here

48 posts and 3 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

f843d7 No.24085

19/7/15 UPDATES

New Strawpoll:

http://strawpoll.me/4969942

New event starting at tomorrow 18:00 CET (6:00 pm EST):http://steamcommunity.com/groups/hissteam#events/132078781958746144


4d6223 No.24149

=EVENT STARTING IN 10 MINUTES GET ON TEAMSPEAK AND BOOT UP CHIVLARY=

TS ip:

185.38.148.35:9017


e3324e No.24359

Does anyone here play War of the Roses?


9e61c4 No.24424

>>24359

I never tried it

it looks like a clone of Chivalry. Is it different enough to try out?


e3324e No.24464

>>24424

I haven't played Chivalry yet but from what I can tell the two games are pretty different, War of the Roses plays more like Mount and Blade. It also came out 14 days before Chivalry did.




File: 1422695943436.jpg (9.21 KB, 202x250, 101:125, mfw rome.jpg)

899d27 No.14352[Reply]

>be me a Normal Roman Soldier
>stationed in Britan
>a cute celtic girl comes up to me and asks for help
>be Virgin, too beta to go to whore house
>her father who is ancient needs help walking
>he is very ancient, must have fought against Ceaser (200 years later btw)
>he sees me
>I start to help him
>I take him to the forge (where he worked, good arms but bad legs and hip)
>I leave trying to look as Alpha as a centurion infront of Celtic girl
>she asks me to follow her
>go behind a hut
>awwyeah.ivorysculpture
>no awwyeah.ivorysculpture
>as she starts to take her shirt off someone hits the back of my head with a rock
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.
50 posts and 17 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

03b7ea No.24401

>>24395

Odin/Wotan is a Germanic deity, and most probably was worshipped in Roman times too.


8bb475 No.24415


03b7ea No.24416

File: 1437714521643.gif (29.18 KB, 500x475, 20:19, you-tried.gif)


770f0e No.24419

>>24415

well Odin/Wotan is common to all branches of Germanic languages and based on their linguistic divergence and the fact it went through all the regular changes in different Germanic languages the name had to exist when Germanic was still a single language, as *Wódanaz, derived from the root word *wóþuz, meaning "rage" and "inspiration".

Germanic already diverged at the time of Tacitus' Germania in 90 AD, so Odin was already worshipped then. Tacitus, however, translates his name as Mercury and writes that Germanics worship Mercury as the chief deity.


03b7ea No.24422

>>24419

>Tacitus' Germania in 90 AD

The Germania was written around 98 AD (nitpicking).

Everything else is spot on.




File: 1437421783870.jpg (166 KB, 1200x1200, 1:1, leshortcorporal.jpg)

ff2f76 No.24141[Reply]

If someone didn't know Napoleon's first name how mad would you be at that person?

21b48a No.24144

um, napoleon is his first name


b4b6f8 No.24195

>>24144

Yes, but most people dont know that. They think Napoleon is his last name, and say they dont know his first name.

>>24141

I was confused the first time it happened, but it has occurred a few times now, since when I am at the table with the guys and we've been drinking my conversation often drifts to history.

So at this point I am immune and wont even cringe.


4f95c9 No.24309

>>24195

>>24144

>>24141

If you called him Napoleone Buonaparte he'd probably get pissed despite being his real name


07d45a No.24386

>>24309

What if I called him La Paille-au-Nez?




File: 1437324604934.jpg (378.21 KB, 1388x900, 347:225, serveimage.jpg)

df606e No.24076[Reply]

What are some examples of battles with more than two factions fighting between them? allies being part of the same faction, non modern battles of course.

8 posts and 1 image reply omitted. Click reply to view.

fb8be9 No.24275

>>24137

>Three groups, each with its own agenda, stood on Bosworth Field: Richard III and his Yorkist army; his challenger, Henry Tudor, who championed the Lancastrian cause; and the fence-sitting Stanleys

Yeah, that's the one that made me curious about it, so is that battle the only example?


343772 No.24279

>>24216

AFAIK in the actual Warring States period usually Wei fought against the other two states, but around 220 (roughly the setting of the TV series :^) ) they actually fought each other 1 vs 1 vs 1.


af0d6a No.24343

>>24279

Warring States period 戰國 is different from Three States period 三國.

TV series starts at 189. Most stories about the "Three States" actually focuses more on the fall of Han.


f82c1b No.24344

I don't remember the exact date or place, but I recall a Frankish noble who tricked a Moorish and Magyar raiding party with promises of false alliance against the other party, let the two sides fight, then swooped in to finish off both.


343772 No.24345

>>24343

Heh, when I was told that it was too late, thanks for the correction.




File: 1437570163656.png (145.52 KB, 251x398, 251:398, 1338612207165.png)

ea6734 No.24270[Reply]

Hey guys I am looking to make game on my own time mostly for fun, and I need some research material. The game will be about trade, and I am looking at three different time periods.

These are;

The height of Rome (relatively safe roads and seas from brittania to judia to alexandria and beyond)

Dark ages (very unsafe roads and seas, different "states" (if I recall the concept of a state was very different then) complicate trade a lot and there is generally less wealth, also jews)

>Renaissance(more established trade making it harder for small fry, as well as places further from europe becoming connected to it, and all the fancy new ideas that came with the age of enlightenment)

Bassically I need material that talks about commerce during those periods, and any comments you guys might have would be appreciated as well.

Some things in particular I am interested in are

>differing currencies and cultures complicating trade, how did early trade with china work for example

>tarriffs, how and when they were used, and how harsh were they

>how a peasant would come to be a merchant logically

Thanks!

e38a00 No.24273

I always wanted to make a game about trade as well. Check out Fernand Braudel's Civilization & Capitalism series. It's a grand and sweeping study of the Renaissance and Enlightenment period's economic history, and whether you agree with his thesis or not it's hard to not appreciate the breadth and depth of his work.


b9e4e7 No.24287

>>24273

>>24273

>>24273

>>24273

Thanks, I will look into that book. According to Wikipedia it talks at length about all sorts of daily minutiae so that helps with another request; what are some sources on day to day life of the lower and middle classes during these periods?


e38a00 No.24289

>>24287

I can't say, probably random articles from academia.edu about specific subjects. What sort of game is this? That could narrow things down.


ea6734 No.24335

>>24289

The plan is an ASCII game where the player can become a merchant and travel around trying to gain some profit despite large tarriffs, taxes, and overhead costs while trying not to attract the attention of monopolistic monarch sanctioned merchants.

I mainly want to know about day-to-day activities to get more of an idea about commodities, acceptance of strangers, and how minor trade was handled.


e38a00 No.24336

>>24335

I had a similar idea in mind, not surprising with your choice of OP image really. I hope it gets off the ground. If you have the time I'd love to hear more about it as it develops. I also program and dabble in game design when I'm not grinding my nose in another book.

As for day-to-day activity I think Braudel's books are a really good place to start if you can piece together all the small anecdotes together into a cohesive setting.

You could also check out his 'The Mediterranean in the age of Philip II' series which is an older work that touches on a lot of the same material but with a slight detour now and then on local politics, religion, and livelihoods among the various cultures surrounding the Mediterranean Sea.




Delete Post [ ]
[]
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22]
| Catalog
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]