[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/his/ - History

Historical Discussion

Catalog

8chan Bitcoin address: 1NpQaXqmCBji6gfX8UgaQEmEstvVY7U32C
The next generation of Infinity is here (discussion) (contribute)
Email
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Flag
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
dicesidesmodifier
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


We oughta get a board mascot eventually. Feel free to stop by the sticky meta thread with suggestions.

File: 1420092937940.jpg (131.9 KB, 615x615, 1:1, 大阪城.jpg)

f725e3 No.12372[View All]

""We want to eventually have a resources sticky with links and suggestions of good books, podcasts, etc""

And yet here we are in the year 2015 without such a thing. Let's change this, /his/torians: post up your resources and books you've found invaluable in your quest for knowledge.

And don't be a dick about it: don't just link something random. Try and give a very brief review of it, indicate why it's good and who its target audience would be. Introductory stuff is always going to be welcome, but sometimes it can be hard to find where to go next, so help your brothers out.
87 posts and 18 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.

9c458b No.18427


f147d8 No.18788

>>12397

As a chilean,I'm intrigued by those books.

Thanks a lot, anon.


3414d7 No.18932

Anyone know where to find diaries/journals of soldiers during wars (any, really)? I'm interested in the source of what's going on, and not so much "historians" writing about things.


65fdcf No.18981

>>18932

There are a lot of great memoirs you can read. After WWI a shit ton of men just wrote books about their stories.

http://www.amazon.com/Essential-WWI-Memoirs/lm/2MNKPM4WLQ39G


d2a641 No.19184

>>18390

go back to /pol/


f7da3d No.19213

File: 1430439994302.jpg (1.2 MB, 3672x3024, 17:14, 1417412103502.jpg)


e148b0 No.19239

File: 1430474961999.jpg (15.11 KB, 320x240, 4:3, 1251067126656.jpg)

>>19213

This is pretty rad, anon.

Did you make it yourself?

Or, if you lifted it from elsewhere, were there any covering other cultures?

Because it's pretty rad.


0ed0dd No.19361

I'd like to read more influencial historic works, like Vom Kriege, Wealth of Nations and Il principe for example. However, when I go looking to buy these books online there is often a big difference in the amount of pages between the various publishes, so I'm assuming there is a variety in content. Am I just being pickey,or is there an actual difference in historical accuracy between different publishes of a book? and are there some publishers I should or shouldn't trust? What's your experience with this?


65fdcf No.19429

>>18390

fuck off faggot


67a42a No.19450

>>18390

Its a shame, because the actual book is really good. Instead you focus on your /pol/ memes and go full retard. I suggest the book for anyone who wants to know what it was like in Dresden and the post war period in Germany.


65fdcf No.19842

http://sashamaslov.com/veterans/#

Not really super informative, but it's a guy who traveled around the world interviewing WWII vets from almost all of the countries involved. Gives some good little snippits.


bbb9c3 No.19852

File: 1431456559260.jpg (130.41 KB, 800x1061, 800:1061, der-grosse-krieg-oesterrei….jpg)

Well I got a few books on World War 1, but none in English. If you can speak french/german/italian I recommend you check them out.

>LE NAOUR, J-Y, La Première Guerre mondiale pour les nuls, Éditions First, 2008

French

A very well written (for once) book from the "For Dummies" series. Offers a very detailed insight into France during the first world war. The author is a socialist, but it isn't that annoying. He even denounces some liberal myths, such as the use of colonial troops as cannon fodder, which never happened. Comes with a nice list of books to check out if you want to know more about France in ww1.

>FUNCKEN, F & L, Uniformes et Armes - Guerre 1914-1918, Éditions HIBOU, 1978

French

The go-to reference for any question regarding armament or equipment. Comes with illustrations that literary took 10 years to research. Also comes with a big-ass list of primary references for your enjoyment.

COLIGNON, J-P, Petit Abécédaire de la Grande Guerre, Éditions Le Courrier du Livre, 2014

French

A very well researched dictionary of the slang of the French soldier during world war one. Except lots of puns and dark humor. References a ton of primary sources.

>THIÉROT, J-L, François-Ferdinand d'Autriche, Éditions de Fallois, 2005

French

A biography of Franz Ferdinand of Austria, from his birth, to his assassination. Takes time covering his plans for the United States of Greater Austria.

>MAGENSCHAB, H, Der Grosse Krieg, Verlagsanstalt Tyrolia, 2013

German

A very elaborate book covering the role and actions of Austria-Hungary in the first world war. Supplemented with snips from relevant memoirs.

SIMONIT, G, Storie di uomini dal fronte di San Martino del Carso 1916, Gruppo Speleologico carsico di San Martino del Carso, 2014

Italian

As I don't speak italian very well, all I can tell you is that it's a book about the fighting that took place in the vicinty of San Martino del Carso in 1916, which featured italian and hungarian men.

I can scan any of those, if asked. I also have some good books on ww1 in slovene, ut the chances of finding another slovene here are so minimal I can't be bothered to type them out.


636166 No.20047

Can anyone recommend good books about the history of the MENA region? I'm specifically interested in Egypt and Persia / Iran.

I'm looking for something accessible but also scholarly and comprehensive.

Thanks friends.


ec655c No.20182

File: 1431811382093.jpg (15.52 KB, 223x300, 223:300, 511jufWemjL._SY300_.jpg)

Classical Greece by Bower is a great book: ranges through the Peloponnesian Wars to Alexander the Great's campaigns, as well as giving insights into lives of women and children. Also a small section on the Olympic Games is included


d1f55d No.20542

File: 1432446618443.jpg (4.13 KB, 126x126, 1:1, 1423718383393.jpg)

Alright /his/, let's settle this once and for all.

http://strawpoll.me/4438465

Please suggest a superior book and scholar if you can, I've already got "Russia's War" by Richard Overy on my must-read list.

Also, favorite/most respected/most trustworthy scholars?

Best scholars/works on World War I and II? I picked up Shirer's "The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich" today and recall superior suggestions floating around.

Further, what about this?

http://strawpoll.me/4438479


1a713b No.20549

File: 1432456193521.png (106.46 KB, 240x240, 1:1, even zhuge liang can't wor….png)

>>20542

>going to the effort of making a poll, rather than just asking about those titles in the thread

>on a board where you'll get ten replies, max


d1f55d No.20607

File: 1432586216367.png (28.84 KB, 480x480, 1:1, 1427442357560.png)

Oops.

Well then: are Antony Beevor's "Stalingrad" and Orlando Figes' "Revolutionary Russia, 1891-1991: A History" worth my time? Are there better books that cover the subjects in a greater scope, more comprehensively, such as Overy's "Russia's War"? What are others on this caliber?


136c9d No.20722

File: 1432817680251.jpg (70.42 KB, 634x451, 634:451, 2.jpg)


41ea7a No.21286

Hello there. In case you are interested in, pre-islam middle east history, I recomend very strongly anything from Sabatino Moscati. He was an Italian archeologist and wrote some really good books. So far, Ive read his "Phoenicians" and "Ancient semitic civilizations (which is about Babylonians, Assyrians, Akkadians and other old semitic nations)."

the books are very readable, yet very detailed. They are not only about general history but also deal with everyday life of the period, culture, economy etc. Also there some interesting stories from historical records or other writings of that period, which helps you understand those times even better, and keep the book genuinely interesting and fun.

I dont really know if you can find pdf of these books on the internets. If found them randomly in a secondhand bookstore.

But I really find this author to be so good, that I just had to pay homage to him in some way. Hopefully somebody here will get to read this and later will share my enthusiasm


c70a57 No.21765

File: 1434204980525.jpg (199.94 KB, 650x650, 1:1, JudeaDeclaresWarOnGermany.jpg)


e1d9a2 No.21810

>>21765

Something about the changes in font quality, poor typesetting, having the most generic name for a newspaper possible, and little crusader man make me doubt the validity of this image.


aa7d79 No.22502

sanic


f2fd01 No.22559

File: 1435230413205.jpg (44.56 KB, 540x538, 270:269, 1427139331209.jpg)

>>19429

>>19184

What's wrong with what he posted?

Don't like looking at that part of history, Chaim?


ea6b36 No.22568

>>22559

Fuck off retard


83edca No.22569

File: 1435249372931.jpg (79.35 KB, 424x540, 106:135, Daily_Express_2009-01-10.jpg)

>>21810

http://www.h-ref.de/feindbilder/juedische-kriegserklaerungen/daily-express.php

morning paper

http://www.h-ref.de/feindbilder/juedische-kriegserklaerungen/daily-express-abend.php

evening paper

Sorry for the site in german, but it's a site "against holocaust deniers".

Other example:

http://www.holocaust-history.org/questions/jew-war.shtml

And regarding the "most generic name for a newspaper possible, and little crusader man"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daily_Express

Pic related. How eerily fitting.


e1d9a2 No.22825

File: 1435716824761.jpg (41.62 KB, 450x450, 1:1, neato.jpg)

>>22569

So it's real but it's a tabloid.


c57aa4 No.22873

File: 1435797882974-0.png (135.72 KB, 1000x606, 500:303, 1000px-Blank_map_of_Russia….png)

File: 1435797882975-1.jpg (65.95 KB, 600x410, 60:41, american_nations-map.jpg)

File: 1435797882975-2.jpg (479.68 KB, 350x350, 1:1, 1433869599259-0.jpg)

BIG RELEVANT IMAGES TO GET YOUR ATTENTION

>Russian Rulers History Podcast by Mark Schauss

An incredibly detailed and in-depth telling of the lives of each Russian ruler. After reaching Vladimir Putin, the host has decided to continue the podcast in his free time by examining other important Russian people and events (I think he became a CEO of his company, so his dedication to the podcast is incredible). Highly recommended.

iTunes for hassle-free downloading: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/russian-rulers-history-podcast/id370995272?mt=2

Main site, full of extra goodies: http://russianrulers.podhoster.com/

>American Nations: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America by Colin Woodard

An interesting try to look at distinct cultures of North America and their histories, in the vein of previous attempts such as Albion's Seed to get at the cultural differences of the United States. It's a page turner for anyone interested in American history, even if the premise is a bit too far-fetched at times.

>Norman Centuries podcast by Lars Brownworth

A whirlwind tour of the Normans - their origins, their spectacular rise and adventures across Europe, and their impact on the regions they only briefly ruled. Amazing podcast, partly because the history of the Normans reads like an adventure novel in and of itself.

iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/norman-centuries-norman-history/id333142230?mt=2

Main site: http://normancenturies.com/

>Internet Archive

Find tons of archived stuff, including historical documents, some of which are scans of old books.

https://archive.org/

>Online Library of Liberty

Hi from /liberty/. An online library of tons of free books and writings on subjects like politics and political philosophy.

http://oll.libertyfund.org/

>History of Byzantium

Meant to pick up where a popular Roman history podcast left off. I haven't had time to dig into it yet, but check it out if you're a fellow Byzaboo.

iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/the-history-of-byzantium/id527579475?mt=2

Main site: http://thehistoryofbyzantium.com/

I may be able to add more later. Good luck /his/.


2289ce No.22887

File: 1435828347363.png (30.21 KB, 96x120, 4:5, the shit dong zhou puts up….png)

>>22873

>not archiving the itunes things

>linking to Apple at all

You're lucky this stuff is rad as all get out.

The Norman one looks uncharacteristically approachable, but detailed: great find.

>American Nations

>even if the premise is a bit too far-fetched at times.

What is the central premise?


c57aa4 No.22930

>>22887

Sorry, iTunes just makes it simple to download them all with a few clicks.

American Nations' central premise is that there are really 11 distinct cultural nations in North America, and that the USA has been shaped by the competition between these cultures. New England's Yankeedom vs the Deep South has been the oldest rivalry, with the other nations joining these two to swing power over the federation from one alliance of nations to the other. It's a pretty interesting read, but I'm not sure if his modern approach is sound because of how short it is compared to his colonial and 19th century examinations of the "nations."


7fd455 No.22966

>>22930

Without reading it, I wonder how much he's defining and applying those cultures retroactively to fit the narrative. But it does sound an interesting read, so I'll probably check it out soon.


a69a2f No.23954

Not sure if it was mentioned in the thread, but any thoughts on William Manchester's A World Lit Only by Fire? Just started reading it and it seems reasonably well researched. author even admits to using mostly secondary sources right off the bat.


5f1124 No.23963

>>12372

Would it be okay for people (as in I) asked some questions requesting books to read on certain subjects?

I'm very interested in any kind of book or resource that could dwelve into Julius Caesar's life and general aspirations. Or even just a book about Caesar in general. A biography/autobiography.

I'm also really interested in an "idiots guide to Roman History" or anything along those lines. I've always had an interest in the Roman Empire and i'd love a place to start on it.

Because fuck man, Caesar and the Roman Empire are like the coolest things in history.

Barring Attila the Hun because that dood fucked bitches and got whatever the fuck he wanted all day erry day.


a69a2f No.24013

>>23963

Theres always the Gallic War, Caesar's own autobiography about fighting the celts. keep in mind he may have some inflated descriptions of events and false accounts that shine a better spotlight on his own achievements, due to the fact that it was a piece meant to make him look good in the eyes of learned Romans


94fbda No.24015

>>24013

>I'm very interested in any kind of book or resource that could dwelve into Julius Caesar's life and general aspirations. Or even just a book about Caesar in general. A biography/autobiography.

Have you read Plutarch's Life of Caesar? It's one of the main sources about him.

https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/14140


a69a2f No.24023

>>24015

not the guy who asked but thanks for adding in more stuff


8f4d8f No.24445

File: 1437766530054.jpg (31.33 KB, 231x346, 231:346, rand van de wereld.jpg)


64759f No.24462

>Hitler - Ian Kershaw

Best biography of the insufferable bastard ever written.

>The Prince - Niccolo Macchiavelli

Need I say more?

>Paris 1919 (titled Peacemakers outside NA) - Margaret MacMillan

Explains how pointless WWI actually was, and how the Versailles treaty fucked everything up.

>The Green Flag - Michael Kee

Helps unpick the whole issue of "Ireland"

>Dear Leader - Jang Ji Sung

Autobiography of a North Korean defector who worked for NK's Ministry of Propaganda. This book is particularly good as it gives first-hand insight not only of life in North Korea, but how it devises government policy.

>The Ohio Gang - Charles J. Mee

While it isn't a scholarly work (and has been out of print since the '80's), it's an interesting read about America's second stupidest President, Warren Harding.


7c8829 No.24482

>>12463

where can i find free eBooks about Japan?


23b8b0 No.25089

>>23963

thehistoryofrome.typepad.com

Awesome podcast about Roman history from the very beginning of Rome to the fall of the Roman empire, it is about 70 hours long.


90c8a9 No.25090

Documentaries

End of Empire

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKbAOjR-oTwoajWr8yHkseywJjG4oTSqz

A British series from the 80s, goes through British decolonisation colony by colony. Includes lesser talked-about places like Cyprus and the Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasaland. Dodgy quality at times.

The Last Governor

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLFZGTzpHBOZ0kZAiSuAIppyCOi8JoASvs

BBC series, documenting Chris Patten's entire time as the last governor of Hong Kong. Great interviews, great behind the scenes look at what went on at Government House and LegCo. Again, dodgy quality.

Hong Kong Beat

(Individual episodes can be found on youtube)

Another British documentary about Hong Kong, this one from the 70s following the Royal Hong Kong Police in their day-to-day duties.

Armchair Voyage: Hellenic Cruise

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLlZqaTY0DhFwgArg9iipLumO-9WiwlM_d

View in the geographic West to East order, from Venice to Istanbul. A documentary from the 50s, presented by the colourful archeologist Sir Mortimer Wheeler. Includes segments of lectures on how Greek dramas might have sounded and a rather tipsy conversation about the Mask of Agamemnon. As much a time capsule of the 50s as an introduction to the Hellenic world.

Books

The Decline & Fall of the British Empire, Piers Brendon

What it says. Starting from the loss of the 13 Colonies to the hand-over of Hong Kong. Written in a rather journalistic style, so appropriate for casuals too.

Anything by Roger Griffin. Just shilling my old professor. Especially 'Modernism & Fascism'. The language can get a bit technical, but if you power through, it's a very interesting take on the rise and popularity of fascism, and other extreme political movements.


6da830 No.25408

>>18392

I've been watching a lot of this guys videos and a lot of his claims seem like total bullshit. I watched his rebuttal to John Green.

He claims that the Crusades were necessary because Islam was going to completely take over Europe if they did not happen. He provides no evidence for this and honestly I do not think it is true. The reconquista is the only thing that could be considered a true defense of Europe from Muslim invaders (different muslims than the ones the Crusaders were fighting in the Holy Land mind you)

Also the claim that the Crusades saved America is fucking ridiculous. America might not have existed in it's current form and might not have been colonized at the same time as it was if the Crusades had not happened, but that does not mean it would not exist.


9b4fdc No.25539

>>18392

>Highly recommended for any one with an interest in the period who wants to avoid liberal white guilt propaganda or anti-Muslim rhetoric. Objective and neutral presenting the history through the use of sources from all sides.

>to avoid(…) anti-Muslim rhetoric

What? I've seen some of his videos and the guy is trying so hard to debunk the modern anti-crusade myths (which is a noble endeavor, mind you) that he swings the pendulum way to the other side, coming of as anti-muslim as you can get without sounding like a complete /pol/tard. He is biased as fuck (which I think he admit in one of his videos), and besides, he publicizes himself as using only "first hand sources" which is a double edged sword, because without the appropiate hermeneutic treatment, a first hand source could easily create more fake history and myths; he doesnt apply any critical analysis to chrisitan sources, taking them completely at face value.

Mind you I've saw some of his videos way back, maybe he changed now, but its a shame because the task he's suppossedly doing (to divulge an unbiased history of the crusades) is a good one


532476 No.25682

Does anyone know of any good books or documentaries about Alexander the Great that are accurate?


8ee3ac No.25822

>>25682

Much interest in this


dd8333 No.26026

>>25682

>>25822

I've read 'The Persian boy' by Mary Renault and the 'Alexandros' trilogy by Manfredi. But these are novels, though accurate in the political and personal sides, they are not the kind of detailed scholar essay you may be looking for. But they are worthy a read any time.


0f1d4b No.26040

>>25539

>Mind you I've saw some of his videos way back, maybe he changed now

He's gotten worse, really. Over the years he's dug in his heels and found his niche pandering to Youtube's anti-Muslim crowd for donations (because why the fuck would actual history students have the money to donate in the first place).


1ab059 No.26096

>>24462

Another good North Korea defector book is Nothing to Envy by Barbara Demick.


6becb1 No.26149

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

>>12372

To any french-speaking /His/torian who's interested in various subjects of the french history, Henri Guillemin is a great person, who made many presentations on TV and radio about various subjects.


c46912 No.26583

File: 1440156576478.png (694.62 KB, 1074x1600, 537:800, cleo-art-1.png)

The Decline and Fall of Practically Everybody by the late Will Cuppy is not exactly a serious book but still very nicely summarizes the history of several notable individuals from history, ranging from the Egyptian Cheops to Alexander the Great, to Queen Godiva, to Louis the Sun King.

There's some outdated stuff here and there (mind you that the book was written in the 40s/50s and only properly published after Cuppy's death by one of his friends), but given that you should not give the book as a whole completely seriously, I still can warmly recommend it.

http://ir.nmu.org.ua/bitstream/handle/123456789/126002/051b3536f3bdea2fe5d2b7eede365705.pdf?sequence=1


0db6bd No.26704

>>24462

>Hitler - Ian Kershaw

I agree with this faggot from a month ago. I read this book about 4 months ago. Let me tell you, reading a book with Hitler on the cover while on the bus has never felt so good.

Especially since the first book was so great in detailing just how much of a loser faggot Hitler was for most of his life, without even being overtly biased.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]