[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/starwars/ - Star Wars

I find your lack of faith disturbing

Catalog

8chan Bitcoin address: 1NpQaXqmCBji6gfX8UgaQEmEstvVY7U32C
The next generation of Infinity is here (discussion) (contribute)
Google blocks 8ch.net with obscure message.
If you know any community sites of similar size to 8chan blocked with this message, please email their URLs to admin@8chan.co. I feel like we've a glitch in the matrix.
Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, swf, pdf
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


File: 1429492946925.jpg (49.26 KB, 288x573, 96:191, YV_warrior.JPG)

 No.2542

what were your thoughts on what i think to be one of the dumbest things to happen to the EU?

>inb4 non-canon herp derp

 No.2545

They felt like sci fi villains.

I think the writers didn't understand that Star Wars is fantasy not science fiction.


 No.2546

File: 1429493617017.jpg (713.5 KB, 750x1112, 375:556, SW_Invasion_art.jpg)

BDSM aliens


 No.2547

This is the primary reason I'm so glad that most of the EU, the entire Vong Invasion arc was so poorly handled. They weren't exactly a bad concept or anything, but going and devastating the entire galaxy and having the New Republic collapse was really fucking dumb.


 No.2548

>>2547

most of the EU is getting thrown out**


 No.2549

The part where that douchebag jedi was cutting a whole army of them solo was pretty bad ass.


 No.2550

>>2542

I think the most shitty thing to come out of EU was the constant change in OT character motivation.

I'm unsure whether it was the Vong invasion or some other alien species but I recall reading that Sheev's reason for creating the Empire was so he could defend the galaxy against this massive alien attack.

It just ruins his character completely,

literally "evil bad guy was actually good all along guise"


 No.2553

>>2550

mike is that you

because i literally just had this conversation irl maybe 3 hours ago


 No.2555

>>2547

>having the New Republic collapse was really fucking dumb.

I liked it, in its own way. It's better that than having the "good" guys so ensconced in power that nothing can ever threaten them again…


 No.2557

>>2555

My problem with it is it sort of makes everyone's efforts on the Original Trilogy pretty meaningless. In the end the Galaxy wound up MUCH worse off as a result of their toppling of the Empire.


 No.2558

and somehow Admiral Daala? became the leader of the New Republic.


 No.2559

>>2542

One of the few things I hated about the EU which I normally love. They were Hellraiser in space and they destroyed Dac and many other of my favorite planets. Also they caused Chewie's death. Fuck these guys, fuck this storyline.


 No.2560

>>2557

Which I don't see as a problem.

It's more like a greek tragedy, heavy overtones of "you could have prevented this"

>>2558

Well, she had decent qualifications for the position…


 No.2562

>>2558

When the New Republic collapsed what remained merged with the Imperial Remnant to form the Galactic Alliance, which went on to win the Vong War and reestablished control of most of the galaxy. During the Legacy of the Force series set ~40 years after the OT Daala returns and gets elected to Chief of State of that.


 No.2566

>>2553

Who's Mike?


 No.2570

>>2566

not you apparently lol

but he brought up that exact same topic today while we were chatting about star wars

>>2562

and isn't that what sparks the second galactic civil war?


 No.2571

>>2570

Not sure, I really started to lose all interest in post-OT EU after the Yuuzhan Vong mess.


 No.2721

Thats funny actually, it was mentioned in Kotor by Canderous Ordo who claimed when they fled into the outer rim they encountered a small ship which fits the description of a yuazan vong scout ship and destroyed it. He encountered the species thousands of years before luke and the new republic


 No.2722

The New Jedi Order book line was still going at that time, was probably just an easter egg/reference for attentive fans.


 No.2733

File: 1429660304175.jpg (36.71 KB, 221x478, 221:478, Nom_anor1.jpg)


 No.2821

>>2733

They really made the Rebels' victory seem truly pointless… If they had let the Empire rule for just a bit longer, they could've destroyed them with one blast from the Death Star.


 No.2848

>>2821

>They really made the Rebels' victory seem truly pointless…

SHEEV DID NOTHING WRONG


 No.2849

>>2848

Should have kept all the super weapons in hiding instead of waving them around like a big dick, Sheevies.


 No.2851

>>2821

You need escalation to keep the audience interested.

Where can you escalate to after ROTJ?


 No.2872

File: 1429894073941.jpg (864.31 KB, 1000x631, 1000:631, Gavrisompellaeon.jpg)

>>2851

Should have allowed post ROTJ to have a happy ending with the end of the GCW, and then moved on to develop the Old Republic era where they had pretty much total freedom to do whatever they wanted.


 No.5144

>>2550

This was the only thing I liked about the bullshit Vong story arc. It suggested more depth and complexity of character in Sidious. Also, he had went on to create his empire before he had even heard rumors of any extra-galactic invasion.


 No.5145

>>2851

Not every starwars story needs to be about galatic conflict.


 No.5146

>>5144

That is to say, he had already initiated his plan to create that empire prior to learning about the possible vong invasion.


 No.5189

>>2542

I could've sworn I made a post discussing my opinion on these jerks…

Anyway, I love a lot of stuff in the EU but I just couldn't stand their presence. They basically made the rebel victory seem pointless. They ruined countless planets, messed up coruscant, caused Chewbacca's death and indirectly fucked up Dac and many other planets and species beyond recognition. Its probably the only EU story I cant enjoy because those damn aliens literally caused too many changes and damage to the entire lore.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]