/starwars/ - Star Wars

>uncle Owen barely knew anakin

Don't recall him ever making a claim about that.

>he wasnt trained by Yoda

He was, all Jedi train with Yoda from the time they arrive at the Temple as children to when they are adopted as a Padawan by another master. He might have actually spent more time training under Yoda than he did Qui-Gon.

>Darth Vader was his father

He never said Vader wasn't his father, and it has been established that falling to the Dark Side essentially ends the original person. Anakin effectively died and was replaced by Vader. As he said, he was right from a certain point of view.

>he never wanted luke to have his light sabre

He was full of shit on that count.

>>4736

>>4736

>uncle Owen barely knew anakin

>Don't recall him ever making a claim about that.

Its implied by the whole idealistic crusade thing and their relationship that they were close

I accept your refutal on the other claims, well played sir

>>4736

> essentially ends the original person.

haven't something like half the new Jedi fallen to the DS at one point? Luke, Kyle, Jade… I mean, it's like a fucking Rumspringa at this point, not a "life-ending" event

>>4739

Luke falling and becoming clone Palpatine's apprentice was pretty much the most retarded thing the EU ever did. How they handled the New Jedi Order in general was also pretty bad.

>>4739

becoming a sith lord is the life ending event , that why they get new names

>>4740

The new Jedi Order wasnt so bad considering it was founded by a guy that only got the basic Jedi training , some training by a crazy dark jedi clone and basic sith lord training

>>4742

I would have let it slide if he didn't have access to the Old Order's archives, but he did. So the mismanagement of his New Order was a pretty big failing.

>>4739

>rumspringa

10 points to gryffindor for that kek

also what >>4741 said, they adopt new identities when they become sith.

>>4735

He lied about Anakin's mother and a shitload of other things. So yes.