>>23
>Amagi
Haven't seen it yet but heard good things
>Chaika
Aside from the characters, this show is actually pretty average-tier
>FMA: Brotherhood
obligatory series is obligatory
>GitS S2
Stand Alone Complex, Second Raid, or that new one?
>Noragami
My favorite anime of that year other than Non Non Biyori. Went under the radar because everyone was too busy jerking off Space Dandy that season
>Psycho Pass
It's not at all actually "good", but its entertaining if you can manage to laugh at a bad anime. You would have been best off watching as it aired with /a/ [insert pie.gif here]
>Legend of the Galactic Heroes
Another obligatory series and probably one of the most highly rated shows among people that know about it. If you like Star Trek and other deliberately slow shows then you'll like it, but if the idea of watching ships very slowly move across a starscape while classical music plays bores you to death then I'd avoid it
>Kaiji
One of my favorite anime and one of the greatest examples of how you don't need stupidly high stakes like death to build a lot of tension.
I'd say you should go for Kaiji first, followed by Noragami, followed by FMA.