"Anarchism has never worked"

Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File	Select/drop/paste files here
* = required field	[▶ Show post options & limits] Confused? See the FAQ.

File: 1424059473075.png (104.33 KB, 928x2104, 116:263, anarchism never worked.png)

"Anarchism has never worked" Anon 02/16/15 (Mon) 04:04:33 84591b No.7534

Let me know if there is something more we should add. I'm thinking Rojava.
Also, any resources that can be referenced as a sort of "infographic" would help.
I'm talking about, say, texts about the history and theories of depicted movements (Arshinov's history of the Makhnovshchina comes to mind, as well as Kropotkin's analysis of the Paris Commune).

Anon 02/16/15 (Mon) 15:13:40 1bc560 No.7540

It looks good. Rojava would be a good addition I think.

Anon 02/16/15 (Mon) 17:53:58 84240f No.7542

File: 1424109238560.png (142.35 KB, 928x2672, 58:167, anarchism has never worked.png)

TO DO:
Find a suitable source for Rojava (YPG), research other anarchist movements (e.g. Argentina and Italy), add more suitable sources for the represented movements, if there are (a third party analysis of EZLN would be good).

Anon 02/17/15 (Tue) 01:24:22 2e3041 No.7554

File: 1424136262037.png (25.16 KB, 928x344, 116:43, ok.png)

Anon 02/17/15 (Tue) 01:30:35 0202ae No.7555

File: 1424136635847.png (17.53 KB, 793x358, 793:358, 1424061464310[1].png)

>>7554
>implying any ammo acquired by the Black Army wasn't spoils of war from declared enemies
>implying Makhno paid wages instead of letting workers self-manage through soviets
>implying soviets weren't crushed by Lenin and the Red Army in Russia
>implying Makhno wasn't at war with the kulaks who had assembled their own Green Army
>implying Makhno's Revolutionary Army wasn't the sole force preventing the Whites from winning the Ukraine and later Russia
AIDF pls go

Anon 03/20/15 (Fri) 16:38:37 8215f1 No.8217

File: 1426869516924.png (71.46 KB, 793x2758, 793:2758, Edited.png)

>>7534
What about Christiania?

Anon SAGE! 03/20/15 (Fri) 18:08:08 1bc560 No.8218

>>8217
fuck off

Anon 03/21/15 (Sat) 16:58:28 8215f1 No.8232

>>8218
y so rude

Anon 03/24/15 (Tue) 12:48:49 859b91 No.8281

>>8217
A little commune within a state capitalist system isn't that impressive.

Anon 03/28/15 (Sat) 08:45:13 81edcf No.8346

>>7534

Who is "Kim" in this pic?

Anon 03/28/15 (Sat) 09:45:21 1bc560 No.8347

>>8346
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Chwa-chin

Anon 03/29/15 (Sun) 14:58:38 8215f1 No.8368

What about Somalia?

sage sage SAGE! 03/30/15 (Mon) 11:45:09 700a1a No.8397

>>8368
0.1/10 for getting me to reply.

Anon 03/31/15 (Tue) 16:34:30 4b3067 No.8424

>>8368
https://anarchism.orain.org/wiki/Misconceptions

Already added Somalia.

Anon 03/31/15 (Tue) 18:52:18 9be89d No.8432

>>8346
>>8347
http://zabalaza.net/2014/01/22/the-story-of-the-korean-anarchists-and-the-anarchist-revolution-in-manchuria-1929-1931/

Anon 04/21/15 (Tue) 07:11:52 8215f1 No.8567

>>8397

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xeer

Anon 04/21/15 (Tue) 07:51:04 c64e2c No.8568

>>8567

>gerontological kritarchy

It could potentially become anarchism when Somalia develops enough to grant enough cultural, educational and rational capabilities for everyone (if that happens before capitalism is forcefully introduced into Somalia, which is doubtful). Still, is isn't legitimate anarchist as the ruling caste of the elder judges is the actual ruling class.

It's an interesting system that may hold some promise for the future, I'll give you that.