/arda/ - Tolkien's Legendarium

>>66

>>65

Daily reminder that they both faggots and best Valar is Ulmo

>>70

You're 100% right. Ulmo is absolutely based.

>>74

>>70

I don't know, Mandos is pretty cool

>>100

Mandos is a little bitch who couldn't handle Fëanor's most metal rebellion.

>>101

>couldn't handle Fëanor's most metal rebellion

He doomed them for their entire existence. I'd say he handled it.

>>105

In the end Fëanor's gonna come back and they're going to have to beg him to release the light in the Silmarils

In the end, Fëanor's gonna get to rub his superiority in their faces.

>>108

>In the end, Fëanor's gonna get to rub his superiority in their faces.

Pfft, no he won't. Ilúvatar will remove them all for defiling his music with their imperfections

>>111

>implying

Fëanor was made the mightiest of the Children.

And all that happens within Ëa is part of Eru's design. There is greatness and goodness within all Morgoth did.

Fëanor's rebellion may have left Valinor without the trees, but it lead to the great tales of the First Age.

>>112

And it led to the loss of magic in the world, the removal of the other species, and the loss of long life of men. Yeah, real great

>>114

>loss of magic in the world

Would have happened regardless. The marring of Arda was before Fëanor's was even born.

>the removal of the other species

He only indirectly caused the death of the Noldor and Sindar of Beleriand. And the Sindar would have been fucked regardless since Morgoth was going to do as he will with or without Fëanor's rebellion. In fact were it not for the Noldor they'd have been even more fucked.

>the the loss of long life for Men

That was no fault of Fëanor or even Morgoth. We started with hundred year lifespans that got bumped to several hundred years by the Valar, and the Númenórians lost that through their own pride.

SAURON DID NOTHING WRONG!

It was all a wizard conspiracy to tarnish Sauron's name.

Watch the Documentary "Sauron: The Greatest Story Never Told".

Fucking Wizards.

>>121

>implying Sauron wasn't a kike.

>>122

Wizard Internet Defense Force, please leave.

>>121

>>122

You're both wrong and probably kike wizards as well shilling your bullshit on Arda. How much per post, Radagast? We all know that:

MELKOR DID NOTHING WRONG

And his is the greatest story never told. Sauron was a plant by Ulmo to try and undermine him.

>>128

>Melkor

>nothing wrong

Check your elf privilege you shitlord of the west!

>>128

> How much per post, Radagast

about 3 rabbits and 3 pints of shire ale

No Wizard Merchant edit pic yet?

>>114

without Morgoth, the Silmarils would have been devoured by Ungoliant

it may have been out of greed, but he protected them

>>210

But then again he GUIDED Ungoliant to them and then made a half-assed promise that implied she would get to eat them. So it's not like exactly he was innocent on all of this.

More like he backed away like a faget.