[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/atheism/ - Atheism

The rejection of belief in the existence of deities

Catalog

See 8chan's new software in development (discuss) (help out)
Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


File: 1445730675626.jpg (4.31 KB, 275x183, 275:183, SJW.jpg)

c57f4e No.12060

Many Christians point to miracles such as incorruptible saints, Eucharistic miracles, and Blood Miracles to argue for the existence of God.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Januarius#Blood

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorruptibility#Saints

What say you /atheism/?

34850a No.12062

File: 1445733597047.jpg (13.63 KB, 300x225, 4:3, mary guadalupe.jpg)

>>12060

Kind of weak.. considering their supposed to be proof an all powerful super being.

Stage Magicians in Vegas put on a more impressive show,, and they don't ask me to worship and obey them.

All the miracles are rather weak.. the Virgin Mary appears to handful of school children during WW1.

If she really wanted to be taken seriously she could appeared over a battlefield in France, made all the guns jam, or something.


34850a No.12063

>>12060

The Hindus have statues that drink milk.. does that make them right?


73caaf No.12068

File: 1445744817647.jpg (16.42 KB, 385x368, 385:368, zeitun.jpg)

They won't let anybody study the blood and the incorruptible saints decompose quickly after they're taken out of the very specific tomb environments. The kind you see displayed in churches are usually reconstructions or receive maintenance to keep them looking clean. Not impressed, the miracle record is spotty at best. Very similar to the supposed "100% accurate prophecies" in the bible.

The one miracle I do find interesting is the marian apparition in Zeitoun. The only real rebuttal I can find is that it might be a case of mass hysteria. And those happen. But the pictures left behind are fairly convincing. Not a whole lot of info on where these came from though. I've read that it's unlikely they would be doctored given how many pictures were taken from all different sources.


8d80d9 No.12069

>"i swear it be true"

seems legit


b98730 No.12074

https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/8205/does-st-januarius-blood-congeal-and-liquefy

http://www.orderofthegooddeath.com/really-whats-incorrupt-corpses

Statuefag, is that you? We've already debunked your arguments.

> ____ happened to someone so they're a special snowflake. It had to be something done by an entity we can't see, touch, hear, feel or see because it was so special and makes me feel good when I believe that reason. There's now way it's an agenda perpetuated by Jew-worshippers looking to promote their religion and politics. Nor is there any way there's a rational explanation. It has to be my magical sky fairy that I believe in.

Next…


3252a3 No.12088

File: 1445799613032-0.jpg (332.94 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799613109-1.jpg (321.17 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799613114-2.jpg (295.99 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799613114-3.jpg (326.3 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

What if there were famous levitating Atheist monks who did so by knowing the secret, that there was no God?


3252a3 No.12089

File: 1445799644475-0.jpg (320.52 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799644744-1.jpg (330.7 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799644744-2.jpg (335.38 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799644744-3.jpg (326.84 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)


3252a3 No.12090

File: 1445799691376-0.jpg (304.46 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799691436-1.jpg (306.99 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799691436-2.jpg (315.14 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799691474-3.jpg (311.37 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

File: 1445799691476-4.jpg (283.07 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)


3252a3 No.12091

File: 1445799899610.jpg (279.97 KB, 2048x1536, 4:3, image.jpg)

If you choose the right path he practically has a spiritual experience with the Levitating Atheists.


0fe20a No.12092

>>12090

>>12091

>>12089

>>12088

You don't expect us to read this wall of text?


40c754 No.12093

>>12088

Thanks for spoiling it faggot.


be51e7 No.12099

>>12088

Wtf? If you can't cohesively argue without posting a wall of photos, just stop. Don't know what they say nor do I care. Post your own arguments, not someone else's.


37dd18 No.12209

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

At least in the movies you get to experience miracles or supernatural stuff like Indiana Jones and the invisible bridge or Yoda raising the x-wing from the swamp.

But none of that is ever demonstrate irl


7c5976 No.12246

File: 1446076529252-0.jpg (257.22 KB, 1020x1024, 255:256, 1020px-Michelangelo-_Tondo….jpg)

File: 1446076529253-1.jpg (2.21 MB, 2689x3598, 2689:3598, Michelango_Portrait_by_Vol….jpg)

File: 1446076529254-2.jpg (227.46 KB, 1179x857, 1179:857, Peter_Paul_Ruben's_copy_of….jpg)

>>12060

with miracles people refer to 2 things:

unlikely yet natural events that then get attributed to god for no reason other than their unlikelihood. Even if some or all of them were real, by definition these are indistinguishable from chance, so one should not count them as valid evidence to believe in a god. It's like their believers think events with small probabilities never happen (their probability is zero rather than low) unless they are caused by a god. Another interesting point is that these things are only god's authorship if you like them. When they cause suffering it's either nature, or god's mysterious plan working for something greater, or if you want to attribute it to active agency yet don't want to blame god there's always the devil.

Secondly, people call about desirable events that are claimed to be completely impossible (i.e. supernatural). The arguments in favour of their impossibility are tantamount to a fallacy from ignorance, and thus allegedly require attribution to a god. Suspecting a natural explanation or a hoax is completely unthinkable, like >>12062's virgin of Guadalupe which looks exactly like a rather mediocre Renaissance painting compared to what mere mortal painters in Europe were doing at the time.

>CAN YOU PROVE IT WASN'T MADE BY GOD?? NO?? THEREFORE IT WAS MADE BY GOD

Among other things, god is how fucktards deal with randomness and the unknown.

There's actually a third case. Phenomena that is fully understood and known for not being caused by gods but people keep calling it a miracle.


645287 No.12247

tldr

>rare event occurs, if linked to ____ religion, see a), if not, see b).

>a) miracle, commence drama queen.

>b) just another day of letting people know they're going to hell for not believing in gods I believe in and their "miracles".


7c5976 No.12248

File: 1446077395650-0.jpg (82.06 KB, 940x627, 940:627, 4560016-3x2-940x627.jpg)

File: 1446077395659-1.jpg (38.26 KB, 682x400, 341:200, SNF1438C---_1437492a.jpg)

>>12068

>incorruptible saints

like Lenin and Tutankamon

>I've read that it's unlikely they would be doctored given how many pictures were taken from all different sources.

isn't it interesting that god always procure the poor and uneducated? miracles don't happen to intellectuals or scientists or historians or broadcasters




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]