[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/christian/ - Christian Discussion and Fellowship

For all those who understand

Catalog

Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


Alex here, I'm back. I'll make a SAFemail ASAP for those who'd like to contact me. 1-8-16

File: 1457630628737.jpg (10.38 KB, 191x265, 191:265, images.jpg)

655f67 No.259812

Daily Orthobro thread. Get in here, fellow believers.

6900ea No.259813

File: 1457630825329.jpg (299.52 KB, 600x774, 100:129, 1441202087557.jpg)

Reporting in. How's Cheesefare Week going for you?


655f67 No.259814

>>259813

I'm trying to live off of bread, so Great Lent doesnt take me by surprise. I may actually be going to a Monastery retreat during Lent.


630c0f No.259820

File: 1457633120584.jpg (95.55 KB, 564x934, 282:467, romania beaded.jpg)

orthodoxy is good


48ed0e No.259834

File: 1457636959122.jpg (203.46 KB, 600x861, 200:287, 1436835777750.jpg)

>>259814

Living off of bread during Cheesefare Week, or throughout all of Lent?


f873b8 No.259992

Is fasting and prayer relevant to someone who hasn't converted yet?


26bc05 No.259998

File: 1457717394311.jpg (299.43 KB, 450x608, 225:304, 1440724334882.jpg)

>>259992

I assume you mean you haven't been baptized/chrismated yet? You're under no obligation whatsoever to fast, but you should speak with your spiritual father about it. It's a good practice to get into before your baptism.

As for prayer, you should absolutely pray. Again, speak with your spiritual father about setting up a prayer rule for morning and evening prayers. Other than that, be certain to say the Our Father and a short blessing over meals and pray whenever else you can.


ef178c No.260006

>"I'm Orthodox solely because I'm an edgy fuck that's spend too much time playing as the Byzantine Empire in my strategy games and because I'm an assburger history pro"

>MUH BASILEIA TON RHOMAION

>MUH KONSTANTINOPOLIS

LARPer scum, even more cringe-worthy than Protestant idiots and Catholic cucks.


41f0a4 No.260014

File: 1457723135252.jpg (44.56 KB, 320x240, 4:3, 20488-29877.jpg)

>>260006

>orthobrox r gay

>catholics gay

>protestants gay

Messianic Jew?


26bc05 No.260021

File: 1457724026432.jpg (327.57 KB, 426x600, 71:100, 1441260537943.jpg)

>>260006

I suppose you're right in a sense. The ways of God are bound to seem "edgy" to the people of this world. And yeah, learning enough about history is bound to turn you Orthodox.

But no, I don't play video games.


f873b8 No.260051

File: 1457730712924.jpg (131.68 KB, 500x332, 125:83, tumblr_lu6sp6E9u51qkynm4.jpg)

>>260021

Reminds me of pic related


dfd4b0 No.260067

do you guys reckon I have to be a member of the orthodox church to be saved, or can I remain protestant? am I missing out on anything important?


cd812c No.260130

>not returning to the see of Rome that the Patriarch of Constantinople LITERALLY said had primacy in the 16th century.

Come home, to Rome.


b1b6e0 No.260161

>>260067

Communion of the saints, the Eucharist, actual Holy Tradition, holy sacraments, a real part of the Church of Christ,…pretty much christianity as a whole.

t. catholicCome home to Rome still stands, but orthodox are just as valid tbh fam.


26bc05 No.260182

File: 1457800663612.jpg (339.17 KB, 1560x1200, 13:10, ark of salvation.jpg)

>>260067

I would say that converting to Orthodoxy is by far your safest bet. The Church is the Ark of Salvation, typified by the Ark of Noah. And think about it–how many people outside Noah's Ark survived when the flood came?

>>260130

T o p k e k


2d0989 No.260216

File: 1457832015514.jpg (42.65 KB, 500x500, 1:1, 3d6.jpg)

>>260006

>>260006

>"muh larpers" stereotype

>hates catholics

>hates protestants

Ok, so while we're making bullshit up I could say that the evidence you've just proved to us suggests that you're either a PaganLARPER who approves of homosex like many pagans historically did, a fedora-wearing atheist who probably faps to MLP, a messianic jew trying to shill us, or from some other religion- leaving me having to ask- wtf are you even doing with your life if you just take this much effort to shitpost?


1a157a No.260404

File: 1457892150307.jpg (135.74 KB, 1438x1078, 719:539, 1456769171570.jpg)

>>260006

Bruh, the Byzantine Empire is one of my least favorite empires. I'm happy that they got BTFO by based Venice. I turned Ortho because I actually know something about Church history.


499d6c No.260434

>>260161

>orthodox are just as valid tbh fam

Any Catholic who says that another church is just as valid as the one founded by Jesus Christ on the seat of St. Peter for the salvation of all men is a heretic.


49397a No.260435

File: 1457908900435.png (39.56 KB, 184x184, 1:1, 14542144224.png)

Hello Orthobros. Never seen members of your church IRL. A pleasure to be sure.


49397a No.260438

File: 1457909115804.jpg (99.96 KB, 846x478, 423:239, 1449942501468.jpg)

>>260435

>A pleasure to be sure.

To meet you that is.


0f3811 No.260439

File: 1457910108799.jpg (8.72 KB, 188x200, 47:50, Implies he posted vlad the….jpg)

>>260434

>Implying the Orthodox was not founded by Jesus.

Why are you so sure YOU got the real popr in the schism?


79020a No.260457

>>260404

what's wrong with the Byz emp? they held back the flood gates for as long as they could didn't they?


1646dc No.260460

>>260404

You mean cherrypicked statements of the church fathers


499d6c No.260471

>>260439

Even the Orthodox church acknowledges that the Roman pontiff is the successor to St. Peter


1646dc No.260476

>>260471

Well plenty Anglican bishops and some Lutherans are 'successors' to Peter.


499d6c No.260478

>>260476

Not one of them is the successor to the office of St. Peter no. None of them are successors to any apostles since their ordination formulas are invalid.


1646dc No.260481

>>260478

How so? And why does it matter? You can have apostolic succession in terms of bishops but if your beliefs aren't apostolic like the Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholics than it's pointless.


26bc05 No.260507

File: 1457926135542.png (1.47 MB, 680x510, 4:3, 1440464019903.png)

>>260434

>yfw Vatican 2 confirmed ecumenist heresy in the Roman Church

>>260460

ayy


70b86d No.260633

>>26013

And was by and large rejected by the faithful. See, that's the glorious thing about Orthodoxy. If the laity think something is heretical, they just don't accept it. You're not bound to the magesterium.


b1b6e0 No.260637

>>260434

They're still part of the Church founded by Christ, they're just in schism.


26bc05 No.260638

>>260637

Did you think about that sentence before you typed it?


2a0090 No.260704

>>259812

Baptised Orthobro trying to get rid of my fedora phase. I literally don't know anything, where do I start?


1f9c19 No.260709

>>260478

Orthodox here:

I don't believe this to be true of Anglicans. Many of the criticisms found in the apostolicae curae are criticisms of the undeniably, by Catholic measure, Orthodox orders and many of the changes to the new ordination are things that the apostolicae curae specifically used as evidence of the invalidity of the Anglican ordination. For example, the NO ordination ordains without the prayer "for the living and dead", which was stated by Leo XIII as evidence for the invalidity of Anglican orders.

If you read the letter in light of Orthodox and NO ordination, the forms which all Catholics are bound to accept as valid, then the logic of the apostolicae curae go completely out of the window.

Please see the saepius officio which responds to the criticism:

http://anglicanhistory.org/orders/saepius.pdf

>>260633

This is not a very good way to phrase it. But the Orthodox laity have defended the Orthodox faith in the past, such as against the schismatics during the Council of Ferrara-Florence. The gates of hell cannot prevail, and it doesn't need a Bishop to ensure that!

>>260434

"valid", referring to the effaciousness of the sacraments.

If you say that a schismatic cannot deliver fully valid sacraments, you are anathema from Orthodox and Catholics.


6dfbf6 No.260794

File: 1458053793977.jpg (1.64 MB, 1074x1273, 1074:1273, tumblr_mnkmlqdmlP1s1whfuo1….jpg)

>>260709

>If you say that a schismatic cannot deliver fully valid sacraments, you are anathema from Orthodox

This is not true for Orthodox. It's a valid theologoumena.


087b43 No.260796

>>260794

Yeah, I was a little hesitant as I typed it because of the imperfect Catholic eucharist under a single species. But I do not believe that the imperfection effects the effaciousness of it personally - even if it follows a broken form.


6dfbf6 No.260801

File: 1458057643045.jpg (150.2 KB, 757x944, 757:944, 1441086536153-2.jpg)

>>260796

I hold that the sacraments of Latins aren't valid on the basis that they are schismatics from the Church; the form of the sacrament is irrelevant. The Eucharist of Western Rite Orthodox churches, for example, is just as valid as an Eastern Rite Eucharist, despite (mostly) following the form of the Latins.


70b86d No.260804

>>260704

Contact your local parish and the priest there. He'll take it from there.


70b86d No.260805

>>260709

It depends on the mystery. Schismatics can, for instance, do legitimate baptisms in the eyes of the Orthodox, but cannot however, have a valid Eucharist.


499d6c No.260811

File: 1458063253344.jpg (80.62 KB, 680x680, 1:1, opinion-discarded.jpg)

>>260709

>Orthodox here:


981f05 No.260823

File: 1458068199958.png (222.95 KB, 519x543, 173:181, 1439864821932.png)

>>260811

>Comes to Orthodox thread

>Discards Orthodox opinions


d263e0 No.260891

>>260823

That painting always gets me in the mood for a glass of Sauternes, but if I open a bottle I won't be able to finish it and it will be ruined.


39dfb2 No.260894

>>260891

Sorry for becoming a stumbling block, my brother. Forgive me, a sinner.


38939b No.260995

Reporting in, Antiochian here.

How's your Greater Lent going along?


346493 No.261157

>>260051

This was such a great zine. I wish they had made more.


d263e0 No.261508

>>260894

>Sorry for becoming a stumbling block, my brother.

Not at all. All my Sauternes is still safe and sealed in my cellar.

Maybe Easter would be a good occasion to bring up a bottle, if I have company.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]