I guess that depends on what you want, OP. Do you just want to toy around a bit, or do you want to get fucked?
If you want to get fucked, then get a pack of condoms and a Mag-Lite. The 3-Cell variety. It has a bit of a textured outside half-way down the shaft, which you may like, or it may irritate you. In either case, you'll want to toss a condom over the top to take care of any seams or rough patches - as well as keep it clean.
And it's a Mag-Lite. Keep it clean, and nobody is going to give it a second thought.
They're a bit daunting to work up to at first, but they have a hell of a lot of heft for their size and have the girth and length to give you a good hard fucking that actually leaves you feeling satisfied every time.
Plus, at least for me, the rounded edge at the top always clips my prostate, and it's hard to fuck up an orgasm.