[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / abdl / acme / agatha2 / animu / chemo / sonyeon / tacos / vg ]

/doctorwho/ - Doctor Who

A place to talk about the more than 50 years of Doctor Who and its extended universe.
Winner of the 83rd Attention-Hungry Games
/strek/ - Remove Hasperat

May 2019 - 8chan Transparency Report
Comment *
Password (Randomized for file and post deletion; you may also set your own.)
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Show oekaki applet
(replaces files and can be used instead)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf
Max filesize is 16 MB.
Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000.
You may upload 5 per post.

"/who/ Cares?" podcast on Series 11: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCz80wZ00_JjSaS2ZRrno1Pg

File: eec630e77dc6757⋯.jpg (76.82 KB, 712x538, 356:269, sleeping-kitten-TS_1606263….jpg)


Kitty edition

Previously >>136901


File: ea8700385f78106⋯.jpg (26.14 KB, 270x270, 1:1, 4a25b4a398fdb80b804a56456c….jpg)


I'd like to give a certain trip a "big finish" if you know what I mean


File: 38dc087f9ea0c29⋯.jpg (281.61 KB, 1666x724, 833:362, tw.jpg)

TW in 1 or 2 hours?



Tim Shaw had a cue that played twice iirc and I assume will play again in Ritual of the Stenza



it was in the middle-end of the episode


File: 940dfc62a8f63a8⋯.jpg (18.3 KB, 590x331, 590:331, Doctor-Who-season-11-spoil….jpg)


By now the only thing that could redeem this series if if the Daleks are introduced in the finale and sweep the floor with the Stenza, showing how much of a real threat they are compared to the Stenza.



I don't think that would redeem the series.


YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.



mmm… hnnnng ummm unnfffffff



>we made our series arc villain shit on purpose!


File: 43948659be30d6f⋯.png (493.28 KB, 463x401, 463:401, c4dae5f894f198f7b08fdb1fc6….png)

Say something positive





nice wig



One day you'll die.


Graham will be fatally wounded sacrificing himself for Ryan, Ryan will finally call him granddad and give him a fistbump as he dies.

Does anyone see anything other than this happening?




omg the pting death scene the music the special effects the reference to 10 oh no no no ahahahahahaha



>the reference to 10




The pting didn't die though.



10 better plots



The Pting died by absorbing a lethal amount of radiation! It's the clearest reference since 13 saying Deep Breath in the premiere


I haven't finished the ep yhetyet



at least you're better than moffat



>The Pting died by absorbing a lethal amount of radiation!

he feeds on it

he just has full belly





casting jodie

casting walsh

hiring new writers


hartnellesque feel of everything

no new monsters



I thought the bomb was just a bomb and not radioactive?


It's been five episodes since Graham revealed that he once had cancer and the Doctor still hasn't made an effort to say "Do you want your cancer cured? We can pop to Space Hospital and sort it out right now if you want"



pting didnt die




These Chib plots are too complicated for me to follow



>I haven't finished the ep yhetyet

There isnt a reveal at the end of the ep where it's alive, it just manifestly does not die in the scene you're attributing its death to.



Ritual of the Stenza will feature Tim Shaw | Epzo | Krasko | Robertson | the Pting


I'm not sure if it's even possible to kill a Pting


Mate, that is epic.


Pting my dingaling


>Light in dark times.

>People prevail. Hope prevails.

I fucking hate this show.



I would like to try

t. Master


>One massive, massive hit.

13 basically gave it the equivalent of drugs.





Print is a metaphor for mobile phones and our SOCIETY, he devours metal (brain cells), he cannot die (like modern mans NEED for phones) and he causes death (of human interaction). And finally, his namesake is the sound that draws us to these WRETCHED devices.





Imagine if the android dude had sacrificed himself somehow to keep the general's heart going. That might have justified his presence in the episode



Android: They will kill me

Doctor: Okay


>that next time trailer

Vinay be like: im bring kino back, them other writers dont know how to act


Imagine if anybody ever touched the skin of the pting to justify the fact that it's mentioned its skin is toxic



The water from Ghost Monument is more toxic than his skin


File: de2e01eb8896726⋯.jpg (188.28 KB, 1250x1250, 1:1, vinaysgift.jpg)



>touch the Pting

>they dissolve rapidly


Vinay Patel - The Man Who Saved Doctor Who


>Demons on the Punjab is shit



what would happen if you put a pting in the water from the ghost monument?


File: fff8f08ff8320a0⋯.png (1.98 MB, 1920x1080, 16:9, umbreen.png)

I like Yaz's expression there.



I'll drop the show.



I'll drop the show too.


>another fucking historical



with demons


File: 19b67a77ebf5272⋯.png (107.33 KB, 238x305, 238:305, chibhappy.png)

>It's got a birth AND a death in it! It's the circle of life! This episode has everything you could ever want in television!




You've already made up your mind because there are brown people in it.


DoP looks unironically good. Even the Next Time trailer was exciting


File: e25b750d2ef33d4⋯.webm (645.55 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, e25b750d2ef33d4f707015647….webm)


>A doctor of medicine?

>Well, medicine… science, engineering, candy floss, lego, philosophy, music, problems, people, hope - mostly hope.

>I’m struggling to see much hope here…

>It doesn’t just offer itself up, you have to use your imagination. Imagine the solution and work to make it a reality. Whole words pivot on acts of imagination!

>Thank you Mabli, I’ll be sure to tell them how brilliant you were

>You all were… Light in Dark Times

>People prevail… Hope prevails!


File: f27c815729dcb8a⋯.png (1.68 MB, 1894x791, 1894:791, curly.png)

Also 13 gets curly


Arachnids in the UK - 8.22m


Demons of the Punjab is the first Doctor Who episode ever where the cast isn't majority white, right?




Imagine if 13 got the can I speak to your manager haircut. That'd be so unepic!



I'm so hype for it.



Wasn't journey to the centre of the tardis mostly nigs?



What was arachnids?



JTTCOTT was 3/5 black wasn't it?



Kill yourself cac


File: de91ff8d7848a2e⋯.png (87.18 KB, 639x476, 639:476, Screen Shot 2018-11-06 at ….png)


It's not gonna be as good as you're hyping it up to be lads



let them hype it up, the disappointment to meet their unrealistic expectations will be funnier


File: 3a69ffb38146f13⋯.png (1.14 MB, 1920x1080, 16:9, treadsoftly.png)





I know, whot ehf cuk caresa


DoJ is the new KTM and you know it



DoP I mean



Uhhhh Storm?

Storm? Are you okay?


Vinay was on the writer's room for episodes 1-5. He's shit.



YFW muslims get upset and it is never aired again



yer on /who/ m8


We should unironically filter the n-slur to "Nicholas Brigger" just to confuse racist siteys



It won't be as good as Kill the Moon



>Vinay was on the writer's room for episodes 1-5.

You mean the episodes where Chibnall shat out every single script and only asked the others for advice like episode titles?



Fuck off.


Depends if you count the Time Zombies or not, arguably fair not to since we don't see their skin at all.


13, Graham, Kevin, Frankie…then Yaz family of 4…then Ryan and Grace….not sure about Jade..interesting, hadn't thought of that ep.


Yeah we know you and Nilso think that.



This is unironically true and a genuine redpill.



Chris is my friend and I'd prefer if you didn't speak of him in that manner.


File: 5da1bdb5e288416⋯.png (1.27 MB, 1000x1230, 100:123, s11Bing.png)


>airing an anti-colony episode on remembrance sunday




The writer's room is still fucking unconfirmed, at best we know some of the writers have a WhatsApp group together, Chib is beyond evasive about a writer's room, he completely dodges the question whenever asked about it.



Grace is a recurring character now



Forgot my flag!



Unintentionally based as fuck



I literally only think it's going to be bad because of the writers room, even malories bits in Rosa, while much better than China scenes still suffered from the same awkwardness as every other episode, I see no reason for demons to be ant different.

Regardless, I think demons has the most interesting premise out of every episode so I hope it's genuinely good

Also the acting and soundtrack already give it a low kino ceiling by default


kindas phoneposting from bed









>not laptopposting from bed


kerblam is the most interesting episode premise of the series



>Also the acting and soundtrack already give it a low kino ceiling by default

Don't forget, same director as episode 1.



>Regardless, I think demons has the most interesting premise out of every episode so I hope it's genuinely good

What is the premise?


>it's sunday

>you start Demons of the Punjabi with high hopes and excitement

>intro ends

>written by Vinay Patel and Chris Chibnall appears



Wait, the witchfinders is episode 8 now, not episode 9?



Yaz travels back in time to uncover a mystery about her grandmother during the Partition in India, where demonic figures based on Hindu folklore are causing havoc.


File: bcb7cc523169ff7⋯.gif (35.65 KB, 450x449, 450:449, doc4c.gif)


Reminder: that thing Nilso keeps setting up about how Neo/etc. will "pretend Punjab is good to save face" is pre-emptively laying the ground for the episode being good, Nilso hating it anyway, and needing an excuse to undermine people's praise for it. Thanks for reading



remove grandmother and you get Eaters of Light


So what excuses will Nilso make for disliking it?


File: cd6f731def83dae⋯.jpg (22.56 KB, 460x288, 115:72, coffin_1549003c.jpg)

File: f4021a8850d5809⋯.png (5.09 KB, 1280x640, 2:1, 1280px-Flag_of_the_United_….png)

A jab at our fallen heroes on Remembrance Day? Seriously, Chibnall? These people died for our country's safety and you have nothing but hatred for them. I am disgusted at the politics you have introduced to this show. Doctor Who has gone from a show about a hero to a show that mocks heroes. Never watching again. Brexit means brexit.


It will be deeply personal episode and it will be just as divisive as the rest of s11



You cannot remove The Indian Element.



It will be more divisive than eps 2, 4, 5 and we both know why.


File: 607df81b761a421⋯.jpg (50.43 KB, 739x415, 739:415, IMG_1050.JPG)

I'm not singing for the future

I'm not dreaming of the past

I'm not talking of the first time

I never think about the last

Now the song is nearly over

We may never find out what it means

Still there's a light I hold before me

You're the measure of my dreams

The measure of my dreams


File: fce82209222e3f1⋯.jpg (9.2 KB, 188x255, 188:255, 89353ca13a4b48bab3ee9b5720….jpg)

>every guest writer episode is co-written with Chibnall


Is the episode likely to deliver any hot takes on the partition of india? Even say whether it was a good or bad thing?



>tfw 'chibfuck' just means to write an episode that is thoroughly underwhelming




It's going to be a story about people who were alive during the crisis, I'm not sure how many "hot takes" you can really get out of that.


YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

This is the first trailer which is almost as long and as revealing as S1-10 next times.



I don't know shite about the partition, so whatever they say will be gospel


File: c720c550544e1a6⋯.jpg (27.29 KB, 551x77, 551:77, and chris chibnall.jpg)



Not kidding, if the intro ends and I see an "and CHRIS CHIBNALL" on the screen, I may just turn it off. I'm not sure I can support a show that conitnually evil.


They didn't teach us about the partition in school, is it generally considered a good thing or a bad thing that some people are still salty over?


The lass who plays yaz's nan is hot. On an unrelated note, this new doctor seems to act a lot like David tenant. I like that because it keeps the flow of the doctors personality but it does also seem like she's just copying him. What are your thoughts?


CHURCHILL bad because of INDIA

t. Claudia


>11.46 million have now watched Jodie Whittaker's launch episode of Doctor Who across all devices mobile, tablets etc according to 28 day consolidated BARB ratings



fuck gayvid tenarse



>The partition displaced over 14 million people along religious lines, creating overwhelming refugee crises in the newly constituted dominions; there was large-scale violence, with estimates of loss of life accompanying or preceding the partition disputed and varying between several hundred thousand and two million.[1][c] The violent nature of the partition created an atmosphere of hostility and suspicion between India and Pakistan that plagues their relationship to the present.

Take a wild guess.



She's right.



oh dear



What caused it if it fucked over so many people? I tried skim reading the article and it sounded like it was part of india declaring independence from britain but causing so much civil unrest suggests there's more to it than that




forgot my non-flag!



half of the characters who appeared in that guest star list have been in episodes now, and I don't remember seeing them from that list first


File: 9fb174a3dbecc2c⋯.jpg (68.36 KB, 700x646, 350:323, 1518654189899.jpg)


>tfw also wasn't taught about the Indian Partition

Kinda excited for an educational episode that will actually educate me



POC good






Don't you have some children to be stalking?



This but unironically. White people are pests.


YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

Was it kino?



If I'm understanding right, pakistan exists because indian muslims wanted a religious "ethno"state, and when they got it the drawing of the border fucked people over?




>3 series planned in advance



Is the Paternoster series BF's first audio with a lesbian lead?


There's no evidence to dispute the theory that every show/movie/book/etc. in existence actually all take place in the Doctor Who universe. Either on different planets, or in alternate timelines.








>This article came out roughly around the same time chibnall would have been coming up with names for companions


need a youtube video made by a right winger to explain the partition to me



holy shit



Oh my god









Yaz to her friends!


it is a very common name

it comes from Disney's Alladin


isnt yasmin khan just a common name



Yes. In fact it's a racial stereotype and Chibnall is a racist.


Can this writer take legal action? In America there has to be at least a certain amount of people sharing the exact name for you to use it



It just suggests he's a hack fraud who can only come up with generic names for people from other cultures


The Minute of the Master


File: 0acdce02c6b73a1⋯.png (35.5 KB, 833x405, 833:405, Screenshot_2018-11-05 How ….png)



TOS and GIG I'm just kind of waiting an hour to see if the sloth shows up/is interested tonight







Sloath is in the stream right now!!!



Sloath here I can attend the stream since I caught up yesterday


DWE of the new Spicks and Specks comeback episode being the highest rated thing on tv?



omg omg



The Woman Who Fell to Earth being the highest rated thing on TV


About to start Torchwood stuff in stream



Torchwood? The Chris Chibnall show? Eugh.



That isn't what's happening here, and you know it. Lifelong fans of the show (i.e. NOT just Moffat fans) are upset that it's been placed in the hands of someone who isn't an imaginative sci-fi writer or an engaging character writer, whose work consistently suffers from severe pacing issues, crap dialogue, shallow characterisation, questionable casting decisions, rushed endings, ham-fisted political posturing, incoherent moral messages, plotholes and unanswered questions. There are many competent writers out there substantially different to Moffat who would have been accepted with open arms because they aren't guilty of any of the above, so please, cut out this pathetic "you just can't accept change" nonsense. It's so transparently disingenuous that I'm embarrassed for you.


File: 8b8c5fa4839c72e⋯.jpg (149.07 KB, 1200x952, 150:119, DrLSoSvW4AA8xw1[1].jpg)


File: 9ca4da7d29f80c6⋯.jpg (134.67 KB, 1200x1200, 1:1, DrFgCf0WsAAFVxd[1].jpg)


File: 156aaf207175f16⋯.jpg (68.1 KB, 800x450, 16:9, DrFSoWWXQAQiOPT[1].jpg)



ahahahahahahahahahahhaahahahahahahahahahahaha oh no no no no no no no





"printing error"



The man never read a Senor 105 in his life



>Senor 105

not BF



It’s a manlet joke, nothing to do with quality of writing



It's legit what happened, Lidster tweeted it


People who say the episode was boring are just ADHD kiddies who can’t handle a story that doesn’t move to a new location every 2 minutes


>ep 5 is almost redpilling the norms on S11

>Vinay comes along and puts out a kino episode

>norms forgive S11 everything

Damn…so this is the price of kino



Element and Witchfinders being the only dope eps would make something pretty clear



the people who say that prefer BF that has no locations



>Normies leave forever

>Capal returns

> profit



boring is the new alt-right codeword for I hate women


What /who/re is 'boring'?



Are you not excited for the late-stage capitalism setting of kerpow?



I don't know anything about that ep, redpill, especially on who wrote it


>pting wasn’t scary looking so I couldn’t take him seriously as a threat!



I’m phoneoosting si can’t link it but the synopsis was put in the previous thread or two


reminder TIM PRICE created PTing



PT + ing




Tim Shaw?


Big Finish does not have the rights to PTing


Ideas for other monsters named after onomatopoeia?



Woosh woosh pee poo



The Poof






>The Screee


>The Wham


File: 294264afb134a4e⋯.jpg (333.55 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, PointLesueur_ROW8573501103….jpg)





Was waiting for this one


The eLeventh seRIes iS borinG And cHris cHIbnall is a bad WriTER


alt-right codeword cracked


Anyone else think the music in the recent ep sounded a bit like Plague Inc music?



If the Plague Inc music is shit then yeah.






I wanna see Ryan hit on Yaz's nan.


File: 90a097105e41341⋯.png (68.39 KB, 1169x573, 1169:573, ClipboardImage.png)



The Vroom



I'm pretty lame.


I'm pting myself having committed myself to watch this evening.


It's Yaz's sister who was flirting with him though, right? How the fuck was she more interesting and showed more character in 10 seconds than 4 episodes of Yas?


I'd genuinely love for anyone from Yaz's family to be a companion instead of Yaz



moffat did the show a solid, and wrote one more extra episode (twice upon a time) because chibnall didn't want his first episode to be a christmas special and moffat didn't want the show to lose the slot.

but now they go ahead and lose it anyway and make a new years special instead?

FUCK THIS GUY. literally shat on moffats hard work.



>How the fuck was she more interesting and showed more character in 10 seconds than 4 episodes of Yas?

Yasmin kino incoming this week.




Been away a few days, is the christmas special moving to new years, or is that a meme? this reads like a copypasta, but idk enough about whether it's actually moving. It would be a shame if they did, I like the little ritual of watching doctor who on christmas day.



I'm skeptical, but I'll give you, anon the benefit of the doubt. If it turns out to be a continuation of the previous buffoonery I will be quite cross and you WILL pay for misleading me.



It's a meme. The Christmas special is still a thing.



not anymore.


Doctor Who will not have a Christmas Day outing this year for the first time since the reboot in 2005.

Instead, 13th Time Lord Jodie Whittaker will have an hour-long special which runs at New Year – with a storyline that relates to the arrival of 2019.

The move comes after bosses claimed they had “run out” of Yuletide storylines following 13 years of making them.



Isn't it well known that RT takes payment for ratings?



Fake news. There are cinema screenings of the special listed before New Years.



cinema screenings were a moffat era thing, when the show was still popular.

they scrapped the christmas special probably because they knew no one would watch it.



ah good. New Years special doesn't quite have the same charm to me.



who is Judith Grimes?



le mary sue little kid





File: 1db0639b4b9f648⋯.png (39.16 KB, 1437x508, 1437:508, Screenshot_2018-11-05 How ….png)


nilso the brexit boy


Lets go to spice girls concert


File: 7b306b9d36b999a⋯.jpg (198.52 KB, 2048x1365, 2048:1365, DmP-AZmXcAAxi4C.jpg)

Remember when the show was Saturday and we would have material to discuss for the whole week?

If you do, you hate women


Guys Fawkes Night

What stories are best for consuming to celebrate Guy Fawkes' death? Besides the obvious ones like The Plotters?



V for Vendetta?


You want to get a little yum yum, kitty kitty

Just a little somethin something, itty bitty

Do you wanna get triple x groovy

Give you, givyou, that kind of movie

You wanna spin "someone" like a record, wicky wicky

You get "them" butt naked, licky licky

There you go yo heres the scenario

Gonna strip "em" down like a car* in the barrio


Richard E Grant turned in a better performance in spice world than in any of his DW offerings. Prove me wrong.

If you wanna be my lover you got to get with muh /who/ friends. Make it last forever, friendship never ends.


He soon meets Shade, who warns him that there will be one death each night until Guy Fawkes’



This is going to be a long week



Doesn't that just shift "discussion" by a day? I have a reputation for hating women btw. I fail to see how that would come into play or why it would matter what day it was on?



a small correlation that the show got worse the same moment it was moved to sunday


File: cfd412c9269a323⋯.png (85.84 KB, 1358x776, 7:4, ClipboardImage.png)



My name is unique aswell and I have a very common second name so it's not that great imo



I think the day of it's air is the least of it's problem and the shift to sunday was probably one of the smarter things chibnall has done. It's probably made it loads more accessible.



chib be like fun fun, think about fun






Friday was in Gatiss' episode.


Have you been watching Who correctly everyone?



Yes, Jodie is bonkers, Graham is a laughing factory, Ryan is a well of energy, Yaz wit is par to no one


Do you call 13th in your mind as Jodie?


File: 90ac986d900f03e⋯.png (13.42 KB, 582x124, 291:62, dw.png)




Chibnall said he would quit the show if Brexit happens.

You know what to do /who/.



>Real characters. Real dialog.




I call her Jodie because she's a friend.





What the fuck is "real dialogue"



like IRL banter of frenlos



Real dialogue? In a sci-fi show about time and space travel?


Wish we'd had a different person doing each episodes music.



That would have been cool.


s11 needs a Boomtown right now

a bottle episode that they just sit in a pub and talk

and then they BOND

could add some flashbacks of each one

maybe with McGann



How exactly do you envision McGann fitting into this?


s11 needs an EPIC episode rn like daleks destroying the universe or something becaus shes had none and crapoldie had none either



They are in the pub talking

then one says: one time that happened:

then get 1 flashback from each Ryan, Graham, Yaz

in the 13th's turn of flashback, we get one featuring PM since 13th does not have a life without the gang



The canon adventure game version


they should just get paul mcgann back to singlehandedly save the show



t. McGanon.



unironically this



File: 1951973f2235d09⋯.png (160.05 KB, 294x350, 21:25, jamiewot.png)



it's only nazis criticizing it



This series is so bad that Star Trek is looking good



STD > S11



I've already accepted that the Chibnall era will continue to be dogshit, my new pipe dream is that he okays a spin-off of some kind (a McGann spin-off is complete reaching but good I wish it was true) and is completely hands off with it so it has the potential to be kino with a brand new showrunner



So, is it cancelled or not?


>Five years in the making, Foreman is Blackveil Entertainment's highly ambitious 'unauthorised reboot' of the BBC's venerable Doctor Who property. With an all-new cast of characters - and many familiar ones - Foreman aims to bring an unique socially-conscious angle to its own 'Whoniverse'.



>Foreman begins on a warm summer night in London - on a high roof. Nick Pettifer (nobody calls her 'Nicola') stands on the brink when a stranger from very far away appears out of nowhere and changes everything. But how do you handle strange new worlds and the scope of history when you can barely handle yourself?



don't go too far



So…am I to gather that Nirvi has been ERASED from Foreman?


File: 14b768df5678d28⋯.gif (955.97 KB, 260x167, 260:167, wave.gif)


Meanwhile, in Jillian's other project.


How does she hope to pay seven actors if she can't even find a flat to rent for herself?



Could there be another failed Kickstarter in the future?



I can't find any mention of Nirvi on her site.




more gofunds


File: 9e8b9bbb829f39c⋯.jpg (78.73 KB, 778x1000, 389:500, MV5BMTE0NDMwMDkwNzJeQTJeQW….jpg)



HAVING FUN, steve?


I'm so desperate for more Capaldi that I'm willing to try these fan audios starring a half-baked Capaldi impersonator. https://twelfthdoctoradventures.wordpress.com/episodes/



Wanna go new world

But Chib only bring pastel

Magic equals crime


Mediocre Scripts

Words arise from his deep bum

Worst Season ensues


Yaz cop young women

Backstory is nil but none

Hammer Windshield crack


I made it through the darkest part of the night (Chibnall)

Now I can see the sunlight (Vinay)


Graham man widow

Cannot teach bike to kiddo

Granpa play denied




>>Nick Pettifer (nobody calls her 'Nicola')

>copying Bill


Ryan stairs cannot go

Impaired driving skills ahoy

Stenza allowed oi


I made it through the darkest part of the night (Chibnall/Vinay)

Now I can see the sunlight (McTighe)



Wow, looks like the original scripts have been completely scrapped. Our Foreman audios are technically bringing Lost Media to light. It's basically our duty to get the rest of them finished.


Jodie want to be

Fist female doc remembered

not by script ever



Foreman is completely based on copying stuff, remember when the series bible leaked and literally everything in it was nicked from the EU in some way?


YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

That time Grace Holloway ate at a Klingon Restaurant.


File: 036e0a2df546f67⋯.jpg (326.28 KB, 1080x1978, 540:989, foremane.jpg)

>Heaven Sent reference

>in a press release for Moffat haters


Chib history book

Learnt Nothing by prior pal

Showrunner ez not


>MrTARDIS 'Trilbee' Reviews has not disliked any episode in Series 11

>hated every single episode in Series 8-10

Fucking cuck.



Miles once claimed Heaven Sent is the only good Capaldi episode, despite still being bad.



Why did she think it was bad?


Ode to my old shirt

Green smooth pocket present is

when dreams are not here


Heaven Sent cannot

by million years diamond

wall cracked heart plop out


File: 02347eb0fa1d329⋯.png (942.18 KB, 742x1443, 742:1443, 1415205934658.png)


Stop accepting poor storytelling.


>An alien bounty-hunter. A creature which wears people as masks. A chase through the streets of an ordinary coastal town. And lots of flirting.

>It’s just another Saturday for Laurel Nox. For the Doctor, it’s a nightmare come true.

>Especially the flirting.



File: 3e567ad8516b1c9⋯.jpg (29.33 KB, 599x141, 599:141, 5.jpg)



Hell Bent Clara got

No heartbeat inside lil chest

Pancake love all mine


Twice Upon a Time

Six Lines had Triggered much Pain

Smacked Bottoms Remain


Chibnall is a hack.

Series Eleven is shit.

Doctor Who is dead.


Oh Erino Oh

Fuck Off Erino Fuck Go

Fuck Erino Off



Jesus Christ, it's terrible.


File: 0278e281973e839⋯.png (131.61 KB, 632x560, 79:70, ClipboardImage.png)


holy shit






Fear her

Sleep No More



My thoughts on tsurunga are that it was better than the ghost monument. It was mediocre, but Ghost Monument was a complete non-episode to me. I think the only reason the normies are reacting worse to this one is because the novelty has worn off, and because earlier in the season, people were willing it to be good so hard. Now that we're half way through, people are finally seeing it. But I'm still convinced GM was worse



We can't judge before, uh, six episodes now!!!!!!!


File: 3818553fbcb275c⋯.jpg (81.91 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, doctor_who_2005.2013_chris….jpg)





how to vote?


File: 25fb6ae65a398fd⋯.jpeg (58.24 KB, 696x392, 87:49, theJoker.jpeg)





File: fce82209222e3f1⋯.jpg (9.2 KB, 188x255, 188:255, 89353ca13a4b48bab3ee9b5720….jpg)


>THREE series 11 episodes in the worst 10 episodes of New Who



>sleep no more

>love and monsters

IMDB is cool guys!






I listened to the first episode, and the companion's actress sounds like she's reading the script for the first time. Worse part was she's the main focus of the premiere, so I had to hear her droning on and struggling to read her lines instead of the Capaldi impersonator.


>Twice Upon A Time is still rated better than any Series 11 episode so far


YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

This is the best thing I have seen in my life.



I like it



I love it, Nilso likes it, N8 loves it, gig likes it, etc etc


Remember when episodes like Heaven Sent or World Enough and Time seemed like a future possibility, rather than a past tense thing? the kino was truly kicked away :(




Then you all have shit taste, but that's not surprising since you're tripfags.


File: 974213f7df5e8d6⋯.gif (3.68 MB, 500x288, 125:72, UnacceptableElderlyGiantsc….gif)



Did you miss the memo? Hating Love & Monsters is so 2012, these days we recognise it as the only Series 2 episode that approaches the charm of Series 1.





File: a77b4953c130d57⋯.png (393.53 KB, 800x450, 16:9, 800px-Freem.png)



Morgan Freeman Agyeman.


Shit taste > no taste


File: 4248da4c64ee08e⋯.jpg (245.37 KB, 960x1280, 3:4, tinycat.jpg)

doctor who is the gayest shit ever of all time



That's what normies are saying when they're cornered about Series 11 too, kiddo ;)


File: c2ec4a178ad0a83⋯.jpg (110.18 KB, 888x785, 888:785, 6iW6GY4.jpg)

Star Wars fanboys did Matt dirty with this hahaha


File: 0932c22f493f2cc⋯.jpg (921.58 KB, 2500x1407, 2500:1407, tfwabouttoreunitewiththema….jpg)



Series 5 > Series 8 > Series 4 > Series 6 > Series 9 > Series 10 > Series 7 > Series 3 > Series 1 > Series 2 > TV Movie > Series 11


File: 03d05196766e776⋯.png (174.94 KB, 640x757, 640:757, ClipboardImage.png)



File: 8946b341d03ae72⋯.jpg (51.69 KB, 1199x589, 1199:589, DqxV0LgWsAA7lkH.jpg)


>TVM that low


File: cd3d032b656b8b2⋯.jpg (2.36 MB, 1238x2012, 619:1006, legacy 2point3.jpg)

Before Andy Frankham-Allen took over the rights for the Lethbridge-Stewart family … Before he started the most depressingly trad Doctor Who prose spinoff of the century … He ran a fanfic series called "Doctor Who: The Legacy".

>In The Legacy universe … the Master succeeds in “killing” the new Doctor (as played by Jon Pertwee), who regenerates once more into the form of his premature 4th persona (as depicted by Brian Blessed). This massive change to the universe’s timeline meant that a alternative universe was formed – The Legacy universe; one in which causal reality was in a state of temporal flux. Knowing that he was missing something, the Doctor left Earth and UNIT to deal with it’s own problems, and returned to his travels in an attempt to seek out the one responsible for his premature regeneration.

Time Amulets. Paradoxical companions secretly possessed by eldritch horrors. A clone of the Doctor. The death of the Master. The destruction of Gallifrey. The TARDIS … as played by Joanna Lumley. What more could one want?


File: 152ca6e83485ce0⋯.jpg (78.8 KB, 720x960, 3:4, 45542412_10155862040987157….jpg)

Reminder that toys


File: 0cf6e5ffee0a571⋯.jpg (78.85 KB, 607x644, 607:644, doctor_who_2005.10x12.720p….jpg)




>What more could one want?

You don't know what anyone wants, Chris.



Forgot my flag!







Christopher Eccleston



Opinions on Pertwee?




File: f2038754c1c1da6⋯.mp4 (2.34 MB, 720x720, 1:1, qdlkTES3_E1LiCW4UT2BVsBJLk….mp4)


I'm a boss man like Birdie I'm a badman like Shirley Big man like me with a beard Look, how am I scared? God's wrath is the only power man fear

Couple skengman then showerman here Shower man down in my shower man gear Yeah, yeah, yeah Talk about me you better hashtag problem Hashtag problem

Adidas creps, don't ask where I got them Don't ask what they are Don't ask if I copped them I go hard for my team I go hard for my squadron…



5 > 2013 Specials > 9 > 8 > 6 > 1 > 3 > 7 > 10 > 4 > 2 > 2009 Specials > 11



Terror of the Autons


Where do you know me from? Out here like the Roll Deep song Man, I'm tryna put my Co-Ds on I do not know this don Where do you know me from? Where do you know me from? Where do you know me from? Where do you know me from?



Eccleston would put Series 1 dead last, also he likes Jodie


YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

>this actually played on Doctor Who in 2018




fite me


how come we never saw Kate Stewart after the Zygon two-parter?



>assuming he even watched his own series



Series 9>Series 10>Series 8>Series 5>Series 7>Series 6>Series 1>Series 3>Series 4>Series 2




why are people ranking the TV Movie as part of nuWho?




File: 537774e598becc5⋯.jpg (293.9 KB, 750x1064, 375:532, anom.jpg)


Anon, I…



he watched it for the same reason we're watching Series 11


why was series 4 so awful? it's like RTD completely gave up after series 3. moffat was the only one who contributed anything good that series.



Counting 2013 specials as a series is cheating, it's 2 episodes and one minisode and collectively far too kino for other series to compete.


YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

>this is a scene in Doctor Who in 2018



why is Sophie Aldred wearing Tennant's old man makeup from Series 3



One of the only good bits in the episode.


Where do you know him from?



She's an old man now









Why does this mindfuck you so much that you're trying to force it as a meme?



people do that? I always group it as part of classic who, even though that might not quite make sense. But I think it makes more sense than grouping it with new who, however you slice it



Doctor Who truly is dead.



3 specials including Adventure in Space and Time. Technically the same amount of specials as in 2009 since The Next Doctor and End of Time Part 2 aired in 2008 and 2010



Replace the song with another, if this episode was in Moffat's era.



2 > 1 > 3 > 4 + Specials > 8 > 5 > 6 > 7B > 9 > 10 > 7A > 2013 Specials



Little Mix



It's always been an extension of Classic Who, idk why people are suddenly including it as part of nuWho.



anon your drunk


YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.



Moffat would have Anarchy in the UK play



I've seen a couple of people group it with spin off content. Usually older people who didnt like the tv movie when it came out though


farting aliens

literal farting aliens




Moffat would never have written such dreck in the first place.



Know me from

Where do you know me from




Great actor. His era is peak comfy for me. Even if his Doctor is a bit atypical, I like him better than Baker.



someone else look at this reddit thread so I know I'm not imagining it.



>Music by a black man? In Doctor Who? Is this some kind of joke?!



haha same XD XD XD


Me was better than Jack.


File: ff7d16bbafa59d7⋯.webm (8.06 MB, 1920x1080, 16:9, UpTown Spot.webm)

The best thing I have seen in my life.



The problem is rap, m80. I would say the same if it had been Eminem.





Then you clearly haven't seen Doctor Who - 11x03 Rosa



the new k9 movie looks based


File: b8d6f8253030f8c⋯.jpg (143.31 KB, 1354x774, 677:387, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

File: 76d30e6e1721ce6⋯.png (195.67 KB, 570x383, 570:383, 76d30e6e1721ce68456079123b….png)



Are you me



I also like him better than Colin



I dont understand the weird thing that op thinks Jack wouldn't want to flirt with 13… does he think ianto turned jack 100% gay?



Jack is a one dimensional character, I hope he NEVER returns to the show in any capacity.




jack hark is fun sexe

he make gay with yan


Nilso is a one dimensional character, I hope he NEVER returns to the board in any capacity.



>Jack is a one dimensional character

You know I wasn't sure he would come back under Chibnall, but that statement has suddenly given me this feeling he's returning


Will Cloister live to see the 100th anniversary?


river song is the amy daughter OMG ;)



>Chibnall brings Jack back and absolutely fucking ruins him by regressing his character to bad-S1-Torchwood-episodes levels


File: c58cf42d48ac3cb⋯.jpg (191.87 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

File: 6b79745935d729e⋯.jpg (188.29 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

File: 087ff39fbba0f83⋯.jpg (269.87 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

File: 1a1a84d1ab22a3a⋯.jpg (324.58 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

File: af32c487937f887⋯.jpg (432.98 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

absolute kinography




I read that in River's voice and pictured her winking. Help me.


Jack would never have worked in the Smith-era but I can picture him playing off Twelve and Clara really well now that I think about it


File: dfdc82efd5f1017⋯.jpg (26.79 KB, 534x401, 534:401, dfdc82efd5f101731a9ec9581c….jpg)

My dear Moffat. The show has never seemed more slow, and yet I fear I am nearing its end. Reason tells me that you are unlikely to write Doctor Who again, but I think I shall not listen to reason. I have seen the world inside your head, and know that all things are possible. Hurry though, my love. Its days grow shorter now, and it is so very weak. Godspeed, my lonely angel.




When Russell and Moffat unify,

the kino reaches an all time high.



>this was Tennant's 5th episode

>this was his Tsuranga Conundrum



my first thought looking at that was "oh, natural lighting! Must be behind the scenes"



The music sounds like a sad Final Fantasy OST.




File: 7962b6084a95e50⋯.jpg (705.16 KB, 3280x1440, 41:18, Orford Is Around.jpg)

Post your face when you realize 42 was better than The Tsuranga Conundrum.







it was better than The Ghost Monument as well



Holy shit this is the best timeline


File: d998ac074b31c7c⋯.jpg (472.63 KB, 768x864, 8:9, needsmorefilters.jpg)


kek yeah


Swept through the winds of time, the Doctor and Clara find themselves hurled into a race through space only to realize the only winner is the one that survives. Every other candidate is either left to rot on a planet or dies in flight. Risk to life: absolute. And when the prize is revealed to be none other than a stolen familiar blue box, the Doctor is sure to never back down - and so is Clara.


DW only:

Pond Life > Hungry Earth / Cold Blood > Rosa > 42 > Dinosaurs on a Spaceship > Arachnids in the UK > The Power of Three > TWWFTE > Tsuranga Conundrum > Ghost Monument



>That box is mine and I will do whatever it takes to stop your little game show, hear my words now. I am the Doctor. And I'm coming for you.



Meanwhile, in Series 11

>Makes sense to me. Oh, thank you. Thank you so much. That'll do.


File: 02509b5f61e5244⋯.jpeg (31.25 KB, 620x374, 310:187, 42626850-7946-4619-A682-5….jpeg)


Stop reminding me of Kino I’ll never experience!



>Clara taking risks through the race to finish 1st

>12 being hostile to the race hosts throughout the episode




Doc tor WHO?



>12 and Clara steal someone's ship to enter the race

Fuck I picture it now, glorious.


>tfw Jenna will never stick around for Series 10 and have Moffat write Heaven Sent/Hell Bent with elements of WEAT/TDF as Twelve and Clara's last episode

would be too kino



>Are we gonna steal this ship?

>We're not stealing anything, he's dead. We'll make a better use of it than he will ever do now.




This is better dialogue than anything in Series 11.



this kind of audience-hostile nihilism is what killed the show for normies.



this would be incredible, i can definitely see him doing the voice perfectly



>audience-hostile nihilism

What, how is that audience hostile nihilism?



But it's absolutely based.



no one wanted to see the doctor be casually rude and heartless to people instead of a PILLAR of HOPE

no wonder 12's era is only popular with 4chan/reddit fans who like rick & morty as well…



But the Doctor is mean and nasty instead of being accessible and happy



I've literally never seen R&M.




I feel like this is bait.



It's bait but it's literally what casuals thought which is why they stopped watching.


File: 432de1583ce9283⋯.jpg (2.59 MB, 3842x4328, 1921:2164, series 11.jpg)


it's very relatable



casuals stopped watching because of a misogynistic head writer



>old man Doctor instead of a pretty young boy

>mean and nasty instead of accessible and happy

It was doomed from the start.


File: bb256360cb68cbc⋯.png (1.68 MB, 2500x1667, 2500:1667, d12.png)


I think it's about time (unironically) to move on from nasty Doctor to a caring Doctor.

the writing is another question



>He's got the charisma of a potato, what does hollywood see in that ayy lmao?



File: 1f5c1437077ed47⋯.jpg (92.96 KB, 1492x1044, 373:261, DrRH0zJWwAI6bnt.jpg)

Nilso and his squad



It fucking wasn't, he should have stayed for another year.



I've literally only seen the 'pickle rick' scene, and that just to see how cringe it was.



We did that from Last Christmas to The Magician's Apptentice.



KEK, nice edit





File: 80a1df15f18ce12⋯.png (42.36 KB, 1144x361, 1144:361, ss (2018-11-05 at 03.20.07….png)



What forum is this?



Moffat hasn't done that for years





Is she young? Anything but young. Oh, I was old!



that's pretty funny considering in the context of the show it's meant to be taking the piss out of rick conjuring up wacky situations out of nowhere



Forgot my flag!


I miss Capaldi.


File: b2dfb1984d5940a⋯.jpg (239.19 KB, 960x1056, 10:11, d14-13k-248.jpg)


I do too.




i don't see how the moffat era didn't have a sense of adventure

moffat did way more than any other writer to deconstruct this heroic notion of the doctor, and it either flew over their heads or they just didn't watch the thing they're complaining about




That's true, but 13 can't start over with a clean slate of being rude and nasty again, otherwise all Capaldi development would be pointless. 13 is a natural progression of Capaldi's Doctor becoming more grounded and more empathic. Not just for Clara, River, Bill and Nardole, but for everyone, to an extent that she may just become very close with literal whos from Sheffield. That's my impression.





I miss Troughton.


It doesn't help that Jodie doesn't have much charisma to begin with, but Chibnall is constantly writing her as someone nobody listens to.

Imagine if nobody had listened to Tennant in Voyage of the Damned or Smith in any of his speeches?



She's at least told every villain so far to "stop right there" and they haven't listened once. Nobody cares about her. She's become a ghost in her own show.



But that's what it feels like to be a woman in a man's world, anon. Chibnall's only showing us reality.



It's not progression from 12. It's terrified backpedalling to save the ratings.



13 is the least authoritative Doctor, and that's including Davison. I feel no sense that she's bigger or better or more special than me or any other average person.

Maybe Chibnall's supposed "incredible lack of hierarchy" is down to the fact that all of the main characters are fucking cretins.



>what is Series 9

>what is Series 10

>what is Twice Upon a Time, an episode so low in stakes that there wasn't even a villain in it




Maybe he should stop showing us reality in a sci-fi show



>an episode so low in stakes that there wasn't even a villain in it

Anon, 13 was in it


instead of the doctor's speech about her old family that came out of nowhere, why couldn't she have spoken about her more recent 'family', bill and nardole?











>I am the Doctor, and you are the Daleks! Stop right now! Recognize me for who I am! I may look different than before but I haven't changed a bit, really, I'm still the Oncoming Storm and I'm gonna stop you!

>*Daleks turn a blind eye to her and exterminate away*


Series 8 and 9 lost the meaning of Doctor Who



Series 11 lost the meaning of Doctor Who.


I don't really mind the fact the Doctor's less authoritative, more powerless, has less presence etc. That could all potentially be interesting. By far the most compelling moment for her character in ep 5 was when she momentarily turned into an arsehole and had to get slapped down by Brett Goldstein. The problem is that it's boring the rest of the time because she hardly ever enters proper conflict with people or gets to be involved in real dramatic situations. It's not a coincidence her other good scene was with Krasko in ep 3.



That wasn't compelling at all. It was utterly retarded. No other Doctor would have thought like that because they were injured. This is just out of character.



It could have been interesting but Chibnall wrote it like shit and the delivery from both actors was terrible.



>It was utterly retarded. No other Doctor would have thought like that because they were injured

The "it was the sonic mine" excuse ruined it and was completely irrelevant, but at the bare minimum at least the Doctor loser her cool and snapping offers SOMETHING to watch (as opposed to the endless streak of nothing during the rest of the series).


Am I the only one that expects 12 to pop up in every episode? Because 13 is just such a ghost in her own show I just keep thinking she's one of the companions.


Chibnall killed Doctor Who. And I killed Ch… never mind.


Chibnall made the Stenza. But who made Chibnall?



I'd say it was absolutely basic behaviour for every single other Doctor, instantly grabbing the leadership and telling everyone what to do. Recognizing this as a bad thing and even apologizing is entirely new. And that's nice imo.

She says it happened because of sonic mine, but I hope it's just an internal excuse for being an ass, not actual mine disrupting her behaviour that much





While I see where you're coming from, I can also see the Doctor getting so distracted by losing the tardis, and stranding her new friends in the future, that she gets focused on that and loses sight, momentarily, of the bigger picture. I found it interesting seeing the guy saying that there are patients on board that need urgent transport, and that she's being selfish,and her finally admitting that she is


>brother could fly the ship from the start

>sister died for nothing





It's just so shit guys… I just want it to stop…


File: 20aadf3329c0be8⋯.png (40.07 KB, 1133x334, 1133:334, sssssgf.png)

What's a good response I can give?


File: cc94af9af0fef64⋯.png (732.79 KB, 1024x576, 16:9, ClipboardImage.png)


the only thing giving me hope is that the next 4 eps are different writers


File: eb91d5f0544f1a1⋯.jpg (850.47 KB, 3600x2783, 3600:2783, 14340349301_015c1c9f61_o (….jpg)

Just listened to the Heaven Sent ost and I thought it'd go really well with The Cabinet of Dr Caligari


How much do you wanna bet the Demons of the Punjab will be the English invaders?

I mean, that would be okay, but we just keep having human villains JUST STOP CHIBNALL



Is this from somewhere?


I still don't know why Moffat decided to introduce the Twelfth Doctor by making him such a cunt to everyone in his first few episodes. It's one thing to have a "darker" or more mature Doctor after 11, and Moffat is obviously capable of writing him that way as seen by how he was written from Last Christmas onwards, but it's like he was trying to make him unlikeable. At least with Nine he had a reason to be angrier/darker. 12 was the first Doctor to start out knowing he had saved Gallifrey, and had just been given a new set of regenerations hours earlier.



Now, THIS is clearly from somewhere.


File: 5053231a1eafdb9⋯.mp4 (440.54 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, ratings.mp4)




Nilso's gay


File: 5fef192edbdc09d⋯.jpg (386.18 KB, 2160x1052, 540:263, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

>first 5 episodes are almost entirely written by the showrunner

>mostly range from "okay" to "shit"

>from episode 6 onwards we get four guest writers

dare I ask, is it happening?



idk but I'd be interested to hear someone's take on the almighty stuff. I felt that in Hell Bent and Twice Upon a Time all the "oncoming storm" stuff was being satirised a little, but then at the start of TDF, he comes across as epic, and in Extremis, he uses his mega cool reputation to make people run away



the full cast has actors playing characters with obviously demonic names



Those first few episodes are fucking fantastic compared to the bile in Series 11. Don't try compare the two.



Matt Hunter more like Fat Cunter lmao


Can we talk more about how chibnall got not only his episode idea, but also the name of one of his main characters from a fucking guardian article?


File: 7a9e9ba0c0996d0⋯.jpeg (101.69 KB, 800x652, 200:163, image.jpeg)





>Yas grows up to become a reporter


>Jamie Childs directing Demons of the Punjab

>director of Tsuranga directing Kerblam!

>director of Arachnids directing Witchfinders

>Jamie Childs directing episodes 9 and 10

Chibnall really covered his fucking bases to ensure all of Series 11 is shit didn't he



t. hunter


File: 4b7d830f7d344a7⋯.png (244.14 KB, 512x384, 4:3, 4b7d830f7d344a75e04d296ef1….png)

Haven't watch the Tstustsnaranga Condom yet. I kinda gave up hope with the last episode, I wanna watch it but only so I can join in on here but…its gonna be crap, isn't it?






Chibnall is an inhuman monster.


So happy with the reaction to Chris' era. Highest ratings of the new series, people calling it a return to form. I'm so proud to call him a friend.


File: bdccb763fbd6443⋯.png (307.12 KB, 383x423, 383:423, y i k e s.PNG)


File: 2177c375b75a0d7⋯.jpg (888.73 KB, 1002x1206, 167:201, whatmorecouldyouwant.jpg)


>year 1: 10 episodes

>year 2: rest

>year 3: Jodie leaves the role because her son is now starting school and she doesn't want to be away from him for 9 months out of the year or force him to go to school in Cardiff, show goes on indefinite hiatus

what more could you want?



They get better later on. "Erasure" has a really good script, and there are some good twists later.


File: f9d7b938dda95c7⋯.png (352.13 KB, 714x720, 119:120, mattdespair.png)


too real


File: ee75a9195a3291d⋯.png (1.11 MB, 1366x768, 683:384, Screenshot (268).png)



File: 78b3d3bc5119dae⋯.jpg (2.08 MB, 2000x2000, 1:1, IMG_20181106_090345.jpg)

Something you guys might find interesting, a bunch of British nationalist meme accounts ranging from leaning to far right have all had a BUNCH of takes on the series, they're all basically RTDbads and despise moff but they're also obsessed with jenna. They also hate series 11 just as much as us but for absolutely NONE of the same reasons.




Sylvester is cancelled



>They also hate series 11 just as much as us but for absolutely NONE of the same reasons.

care to share?



I'd really like some context for this



Sylvester McCoy unconsensually grabbed Sophie Aldred's breasts on the set of Ghost Light in an act of sexual harassment.



File: f54c09d72ca5bab⋯.png (305.25 KB, 614x803, 614:803, ClipboardImage.png)



>right wing


>love /ourjenna/

Sounds based



>JonTron reaction face


they all seem to still watch every single week so i guess chibnall did something right?



JonTron is a white supremacist icon



its tardisposting you talking about right?



nope, right wing twitter brits


12x01 The Fourteenth Hour by Frank Cottrell-Boyce



2oda made a wiki page on JonTron one time



>five chibnall episodes

>three literally who diversity picks

>Cottrell-Boyce and Gatiss write an episode each

I can actually see it now aaaaaaaaAa


im excited for kerblam! and you can't change my mind




Me too. It sounds great.



When Kerblaam! turns out to be irredeemably shit you’ll have to pretend to like it.




It's not written by Chibnall so it's bound to be better than every episode so far bar Rosa


File: cbb02768e8d61f7⋯.jpg (61.41 KB, 643x551, 643:551, 13.jpg)

It's shit. It's all shit.


If Chibs really wants to be the new RTD, then that means the BBC and ITV will start making kitschy sci-fi/fantasy adventure shows again like Robin Hood, Merlin, and Primeval.



Merlin and Primeval were great


File: 327529f06331c30⋯.png (1.59 MB, 1920x1080, 16:9, roars.png)



Merlin and Primeval were really good



Primeval and Robin Hood were fucking brilliant. I know it's not really a thing to have nostalgia for something so recent but goddamn do they remind me of a more comfy time.



they were all shit


Primeval felt like watered down Torchwood. Robin Hood was fun up until it shit the bed in Series 3.



chibnall has lowered our standards



Primeval was both GOAT and comfy.



Primeval had that problem from series 4 onwards but S1-3 were great


I've got Series 1 and 2 of Primeval behind me, I'm gonna have to watch them again now.



Primeval was worse than Series 11



Series 2 and 3 were my favourites.



Primeval was just OK



Arachnids was mostly really well directed, I'm not concerned about Witchfinders in that regard.


Which was better: All the Brit SF/Fantasy shows that came out during the RTD era, or the ones that came out during the Moff era?


File: df5800da9ada371⋯.png (25.22 KB, 1142x294, 571:147, ss (2018-11-05 at 05.39.38….png)


File: 568ad420bd4ccce⋯.png (38.68 KB, 1156x410, 578:205, ss (2018-10-30 at 11.29.44….png)


File: 49253aaf67636ff⋯.png (78.31 KB, 1138x474, 569:237, ss (2018-10-30 at 11.29.58….png)





I'm feeling fucking verged.




Why do fans care about what the general public think of the show?



because they don't like being bullied by normies :(


File: bd1c5b7f5454b42⋯.jpg (52.78 KB, 968x726, 4:3, steven-moffat.jpg)

Was he a martyr?



These are also Trekkies who praise JJ Abrams for making Star Trek more "accessible" and not "bogged down" in lore.


Top 3 eras for soul




Top 3 eras for soulless





I can only like something if the general public likes it too!



I think those guys praise Abrams more for bringing Star Trek back from the dead after Enterprise killed it. Because unlike us, Trekkies don't have a Big Finish or a hundred book spinoffs like Faction or Iris. All they have during the off-season are some books and an MMORPG game.



But then we got super normie-pandering JewJew Trek and then STD.





Found the boardie.


I hope an episode airs where 13 Americans should get fucked because they're a nation of immigrants






Foreman begins on a warm summer night in London - on a high roof. Nick Pettifer (nobody calls her 'Nicola') stands on the brink when a stranger from very far away appears out of nowhere and changes everything. But how do you handle strange new worlds and the scope of history when you can barely handle yourself?

Did nirvi get scrapped so jillian could write a character with mental health issues instead?



>Did nirvi get scrapped so jillian could write a character with mental health issues instead?

But Moff already did that. Amy had several psychologists and bit one of them.



Amy certainly had mental health issues but it's not like Moff went out of his way to depict what that's actually like. The psychiatrists line is literally a gag. It was more a symbolic thing with Amy and the Doctor.



Star Trek '09 is a great fucking movie though. Granted I've never been a big fan of Star Trek so any "lore-breaking" shit that fans get upset over in that movie means nothing to me since no matter how many times I rewatch it I still find it totally engaging and fun. It's like The Eleventh Hour in that regard.

Into Darkness is shit tho



Weren't the psychologists just about trying to cure amy of her "imagining" of the raggedy man - which we know was actually real, and not actually indicative of any mental illness?


Tsuranga is a pleb filter

anyone that includes the pting in their list of reasons for why the episode was shit, particularly its appearance or the fact it wasn't scary, is a complete and utter pleb

It's one of the better episodes this series



>Nick Pettifer (nobody calls her 'Nicola')

So Foreman will have a trans Doctor and a trans companion? Did Jillian look at Series 11, see that 13 was technically trans and had a companion of Middle Eastern descent, realize her Foreman would look like a copycat if it came out, and doubled down?



>It's one of the better episodes this series

(not a high bar btw)



That's also true, but IMDB ratings having it in the bottom 10 of nuwho suggests that something's wrong



remember when Amy's newborn baby turned into a pile of goo in her arms, she found out that said baby grows up to be River Song, and the Doctor just abandons her and Rory on a space station in who knows what year for no reason at all (where is he going that he needs to leave Vastra and Jenny in charge of getting them home? he couldn't drop them off first?) and also Amy can never have kids again and all of this has 0 effect on her mental health whatsoever?



I made that assumption too at first, but from the "nobody calls her Nicola" phrasing, it's more likely the companion is just Bill-esque and prefers a masculine name despite being female.



>also Amy can never have kids again and all of this has 0 effect on her mental health whatsoever?

That most certainly did have a deleterious effect on her mental health and it even had disastrous consequences which were shown in an episode. People just ignored it and called her a badly written bitch.




Amy actually was a good display of someone with abandonment issues, including the way she pushed away Rory in Asylum Of Daleks out of fear of getting rejected.



I think Series 11 has been lame too, but IMDB ratings aren't a useful indicator. How do we know it's not a bunch of boardies spamming 1-star ratings?


It's really interesting to think that a pleb-pandering series like S11 might have actually upset plebs just by doing something as innocuous as the Pting. They truly are a difficult beast to tame.


File: 2bb9a12e651119b⋯.png (102.61 KB, 638x1042, 319:521, Screen Shot 2018-11-06 at ….png)


IMDB ratings are always pretty biased and a lot of people improperly abuse the 1-star rating when they don't give a fuck about a qualitative analysis, but the fact that it's biased into the negative range more than usual suggests that the episode upset enough people to provoke a negative rating


Dear Chris Chibnal, you have lost me.

dave-stewart335 November 2018

Hi Chris,

This is not about The Doctor being a woman (Jodie is great!), but about story.

Last week's Faux Trump effort notwithstanding, this week's episode was just as bad.

Issue 1: The companions just aren't sympathetic. I don't feel any compassion towards them. Issue 2: Zero humor. Even Capaldi had some touches of humor. Issue 3: Ancillary characters we just don't care about.

It's all about the writing. This season is missing the fun. Any fun would be good.

A fan going away.



Amy's all about maintaining a brave face while under stress, and that brave face fools even audiences. Asylum Of The Daleks' divorce subplot was key to showing how badly she got effected.


I can't believe it what has happened to my who

xphantom-190994 November 2018

Boring, too much talking. This is Doctor Who not a soap opera.


The 5 Stages

lisacalhoun-263685 November 2018

Episode 1 - DENIAL Episode 2 - ANGER Episode 3 - BARGAINING Episode 4 - DEPRESSION Episode 5 - ACCEPTANCE

After 15 minutes I turned the episode off and removed Doctor Who from my scheduled DVR. I've ACCEPTED this show can no longer provide the excitement, happiness and escape that prior iterations have done for me time and time again. Do you own Doctor Who TARDIS pajamas? Well I do and I'm wearing them right now. They now make me sad.

If you feel other reviewers/commenters are just haters or fanboys - please forgive them - they have just not made it to stage 5 yet.


When was the earliest point in a companion's tenure that you felt bad for them and wanted them to have a better life? Mine was during The Pilot where Bill was begging the Doctor not to mindwipe her, and she talked about how her first trip through time and space was the only exciting thing to happen in her life.



>No Iris

Trekcucks win this time



>still verged about Iris

Without referencing Rick and Morty, are you gonna explain why Iris verges you so much?


I don't think chib realized that the 5 million people who stuck with capaldi would really hate if you just did the exact opposite of what they liked


I mean, we can focus on all the people validly realising S11 isn't very good, but it's not like the viewing figures are taking anything resembling a serious hit yet.



The Pilot when they showed that bill was closeted to her guardian

Wish they used her more, there was more that could have been done



He fell for the "ratings are down! Doctor Who's gonna die!" fearmongering, and decided to do the opposite.



First 5 minutes of kid Amy.



I still don't get her relationship with her foster mother. She didn't know that Bill was gay and didn't seem to care much about her test scores or her birthmother, but she still gave her advice and was okay with her living in her flat long after she reached adulthood.


The episodes aren’t good enough to counterbalance the boardies giving 1 star reviews. At best they’re just mediocre which combined with the boardies puts them into the bottom 10 on imdb.


File: d45af270292ee5a⋯.jpg (273.15 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

kek I forgot about this joke



>that forced smile on Capaldi


File: 6ed0e0f10452970⋯.jpg (282.26 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)


he was genuinely happy for her when he thought she'd been dating the history teacher who looked like Eleven



And then annoyed when he found out she was getting BLACKED




Now I think about it this is why Matt Smith had to show up in Series 8 somewhere, so you could understand the contrast without needing to have seen past series.



I think he just had a problem with her dating a soldier who was also a fucking retard in his eyes



Probably meant the above for >>138273

But yeah, the foster mom seemed like maybe she cared for Bill? Probably regretted when Bill disappeared.


Akinola will put the entire S11 OST out on his soundcloud.


File: b42557c338d86ef⋯.jpg (212.72 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)


Clara treating him like a fucking idiot didn't help her case. Danny sees the Doctor and Clara dealing with an alien robot and then talking about how they're going to deal with the alien robot coming back and when Danny is like "what the fuck" she tries to convince him they're rehearsing for a play


Steven Moffat oversaw Samuel Anderson's audition and quipped "is that wooden sound you or the desk?" Then he thought "hey, that's a good line, I'll put that in" but he had to cast Samuel Anderson for it to make sense so here we are



The S10 OST will still be in limbo.



top kek



What did you think of ep 5?


man Clara and Danny's relationship was just not believable in the slightest. I don't get what she saw in him, she treats him like a fucking idiot for all of Series 8, and I don't see what he sees in her considering almost every scene with him consists of him getting upset because of how Clara is treating him



maybe there were good times that we didn't see



Ah, well then maybe Moffat should show, and not tell.



I've talked about it before but he was kinda fucked no matter what when it came to Danny. His character exists in order to die, and so I assume Moffat didn't want to get him too involved like Rory or Mickey if he planned to kill him off in such an unceremonious manner in the first minute of the finale, but at the same time he has to include him enough to make his death feel somewhat important when it happens.


File: 6e652159d877a59⋯.jpg (132.67 KB, 1200x675, 16:9, DrPF3XAX0AURbUs.jpg)

>They’re screening a mini episode of the Wheel in Space part 1 at their next missing believed wiped event


File: e9b41a2207b8dd6⋯.jpg (271.46 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

>enter the TARDIS for the first time

>experience invisibility for the first time

>act like a massive prick to the Doctor as soon as you reveal yourself to him

no wonder 12 hated him


File: 3161a0582e17c84⋯.jpg (58.97 KB, 996x224, 249:56, DrQDR3xWsAc0qVz.jpg)



>Probably the best Doctor ever! I miss these old Docs.

Since when is Matt Smith an old doctor?


I love how 12's bantz reached critical levels in The Caretaker.



5 years ago is old if you're a total zoomer.


File: da066ba9cb3ea93⋯.jpg (408.26 KB, 1427x1128, 1427:1128, bernie sanders shills his ….jpg)




DOCTOR: How does that work? What if the kids have questions?

DANNY: About what?

DOCTOR: Maths.

DANNY: I answer them. I'm a maths teacher.

DOCTOR: But he said you were a soldier.

DANNY: Yeah. I was a soldier, now I'm a maths teacher.

DOCTOR: But what about all the PE?

DANNY: I don't teach PE. I'm not a PE teacher.

DOCTOR: Sorry, that seems very unlikely.

CLARA: Er, excuse me. Mister Pink, I think class 9M4 are waiting.

DOCTOR: Yes, you better run along, Sergeant. That ball isn't going to kick itself, is it?

DANNY: I, I'm not a PE teacher, I'm a maths teacher.

DOCTOR: Nope, sorry. No, I can't retain that. I've tried. It's just not going in.



This was very audience-hostile and uncomfortable.



This is incidentally the only scene where I liked Anderson's acting. His delivery is pretty solid when he's treating the Doctor like a general


YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

>that reprisal of Man Man With A Box

>we will literally never hear any of Marigold's godtier themes from Series 1-10 again




I think that's because he's trying to be unlikeable in that scene so it plays into his strengths. Whenever he's trying to be likeable it always falls flat



Good. I got tired of Murray Gold telling us how we should be feeling during Moffat's shitty scripts.


File: 84609e9fbf1dab0⋯.jpg (212.69 KB, 1921x1081, 1921:1081, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

how did they get away with this



that's gareth!


Whelan's freaking out on Twitter



>this account's tweets are protected

he already blocked me and now incognito mode won't work either

you're gonna have to screencap now



He's calling out the guy who helped design Jodie's outfit who'd said he'd blocked Whelan years ago for being a toerag



Forgot my trip!


File: 81872eff2260bb7⋯.jpg (54.51 KB, 407x769, 407:769, Dp5r1LbU4AA1Bga.jpg)



series 10 feels so much warmer



Can you screencap it?



Red's a true fan even if he doesn't know it




courtney was based though


File: 4122206a261c1e6⋯.png (9.97 KB, 433x118, 433:118, b3728f1e28571543142b391116….png)

File: a61059540105f71⋯.png (31.13 KB, 459x394, 459:394, 6b02bbd7f54e44c4d6d2c411cb….png)

File: 32aa1f2ab6f8bf6⋯.png (64.56 KB, 469x817, 469:817, b658abcadf98198bb438f9db77….png)



best thing about chib is that he's making me appreciate series 10 to a new degree


11 rewatch at some point soon? If not I'll do it myself



I don't even understand what's going on

why is whelan mad at the costume designer? who started it?



Only had a cursory glance, none too sure myself. Holman was talking about not being sure as to what job to go for because he had 3 options in front of him and he could only go with one. He gave reasons for each one and said that Who fans were "for the most part really nice but many armchair critics and psuedo-professional reviewers marred the rest of the fans". I guess Whelan took this personally and had a petty spat before protecting his tweets and getting Holman to block him.



>don't watch or use my digital rainbows to make money

What in the fuck does Ray mean by this



i'd be down



He designed Jodie's rainbow shirt and thus has the rights to all rainbows



Should we wait for the whole series to be done? Or do it in 2 sets of 5?



Uh, mate, I think you've misunderstood Nilso's post quite severely.



teehee silly me



I meant 11th Doctor you silly sausage. Saying that, however, if people can bring themselves to binge Series 11 at the end of the series then maybe we can do that too.




Post when you do. I mean I probably won't show up, but I might. I'd like to be more social.



I'd defy anyone to stay awake past the halfway point.


File: 11a4772ab2679b7⋯.jpg (16.29 KB, 506x512, 253:256, 1277315024502.jpg)


I'd love that and I'm sure others would too.




Do it at an aus friendly time onegai



t h i s



BASED fucking cloyman


File: da0dab9a3fe66f9⋯.jpg (62.82 KB, 1024x576, 16:9, ANTI-PLASTIC.jpg)

Can ANTI-PLASTIC anon come back? I miss replying to him every thread.


File: 8f27836195834c4⋯.jpg (55.14 KB, 1065x587, 1065:587, ANTI PLASTIC!.JPG)



How pathetic.



We lost a lot of good /who/res in the /who/locaust


lets say hypothetically BBC tells Chibnall to fuck off when he says he needs a gap year for 2019 and replace him with you as showrunner.

>Are there any recurring monsters (ie: Daleks, Cybermen, etc.) that you'd bring back?

>Would you keep their designs or would you redesign them in any way? How?

I'd bring the Daleks back considering their last proper appearance was in 2015, and I'd probably keep the RTD-era design but change the coloring to be gunmetal grey with hints of dark green rather than bronze and gold just to make them more tank-like



id bring back pting


the way they all say "pting?" in unison to reinforce to the audience that it's a funny name



Chibnall ensured any future writer would have to pay the Price price if they wanted to bring him back



If a good enough story was thought up I'd bring The Mara back.


File: 8334d17e9cefe31⋯.png (15.31 KB, 20x16, 5:4, chibchad.png)

Chibchad flag when?


File: 8d219a94192f4a5⋯.jpg (154.74 KB, 1920x960, 2:1, doctor.who.2005.s11e05.108….jpg)

File: c6dafdb685e5e0e⋯.jpg (102.99 KB, 449x593, 449:593, ptinggenesis.jpg)


Alien and alien name originally created by Tim Price!


why did Moffat take a year off in 2016 again? I can't remember


I was rewatching The Doctor Falls today, and while I was nearing the end I started to cry as I realised… I really miss this era of the show. Murray Gold's soundtrack is just fantastic, Peter Capaldi is amazing, Steven Moffat's dialogue and style of storytelling is really engaging for me. Even the worst episodes of the show had great acting from the main cast and a brilliant soundtrack to just get lost in - episodes were always either enjoyable as they were or bad because they were stupid, but never boring. Has anyone else had a moment of realisation of believing their favourite era of the show has passed similar to this?



He was expecting to leave at husbands but ended up staying on until chib was done with broadchurch, by the time that was sorted out it was probably too late to do a series for 2016



just like how they all get spooked by it in unison to tell us it's spooky


File: 1870157401af2d8⋯.jpg (160.76 KB, 1920x960, 2:1, mpv-shot0035.jpg)

they added in the sonic light in post so it could pulsate, rather than having a prop with a pulsating light

imagine if capaldi's sonic had the rotatey lights done in post



plus, there was Sherlock


File: 62bca1549e50938⋯.jpg (468.58 KB, 1046x1200, 523:600, two men and a chibby.jpg)


>stay on an extra 18 months to accomidate Chibnall

>stay on another 6 months after that to accomidate Chibnall again

>Chibnall tired out after 1 series and needs to take a gap year as well as lose the Christmas time slot Moffat stayed an extra 6 months on the job just to keep

for fucks sake



yeah but look at the aspect ratio!!!



dwe of americans screaming "VOTE!!!!!!" on social media like they've been cursed to repeat it for all eternity?



Remember to get out and vote! [for the candidate I like]

It's so important that people are politically engaged and vote! [as long as they're on my side]



The bit in the opening of Asylum of the Daleks where the entire room of them are chanting SAVE THE DALEKS.



Those don't exist



File: c758d705b7b5481⋯.png (138.55 KB, 441x459, 49:51, 1539543704168.png)


>Cletus gets offended at something as mundane as reminding people to exercise their right to vote, no matter the candidate

bootlickers leave



I get voting's important, and Trump controlling all three branches of the American government is complete and utter bullshit, but hearing people scream at me to vote nonstop is getting really annoying.



Literally me while watching this video




voting is literally the same thing as bootlicking, violent uprising when


File: cc1ae139f71c738⋯.jpg (265.02 KB, 2142x380, 1071:190, Screen Shot 2018-11-05 at ….jpg)

wtf Chibnall retroactively forcing his political agenda into RTD-era episodes where I was too young to notice any of it the first time round



well in 24 hours you won't have to hear it for another 2 years



Violent uprisings, while enticing, are often impractical and require countless people to forsake the safety of themselves and their loved ones for a revolution they're not sure will fully work.


File: cf7739efbc45bdc⋯.png (698.34 KB, 1264x720, 79:45, 1519840239070.png)


b-but I thought those episodes were KINO???



it just hilarious seeing "influencers" and "celebrities" preaching it to absolutely no end despite the fact that all of these people screaming about it will still be rich cunts who think they need to talk down to the plebs and tell them how oh so important voting is the next time around.



Because much as I hate celebrities telling people to vote too, they're right. Lots of young adults don't vote, and that leads to American politics becoming more stagnant if there's no new blood.



I get that, but I think the intent is flawed, they aren't getting young adults to vote for the sake of a more diverse voting block, they're doing it specifically because the majority of people who would receive this message, regardless of age, would vote for the neo-libs.

I think the message of "get out and vote!1!!1!" is a stupid one unless coupled with a similar message about voting against the 2 major parties.



> a similar message about voting against the 2 major parties.

Because voting against the 2 major parties has often been viewed as throwing your vote away. The electoral college and gerrymandering mean any chances of a third party, even one with major backers, are almost nil. And people are still bitter at the third-party candidate from 2000 taking away Gore's votes and allowing Bush to become President.


File: f7359db51c4cb00⋯.jpg (25.38 KB, 2344x428, 586:107, RTDcolor.jpg)

imported the RTDkino, Moffkino, and Chibbkino cinegrids into Adobe Color to find the general color pallete of each

>RTDkino color pallete


File: 6017754ccdb13cb⋯.jpg (25.51 KB, 2344x430, 1172:215, Moffcolor.jpg)


>Moffkino color pallete


File: fd80ac4286dfeb8⋯.jpg (26.62 KB, 2344x434, 1172:217, Chibcolor.jpg)



>Chibkino color pallete



how do you fix it then? more voting clearly wont help break that dynamic, so what's the point?



oh nononono



sounding awfully like a political nihilist there



>how do you fix it then?

That's been a question people have been asking for over a century. And after a century, nobody knows the answer.



Did you use that Moffat one which has a screencap from Evangelion inserted in the middle for le meme reasons, because I worry that may influence it



blame seppoland, I think voting in normal parliamentary democracies is very valuable.


Your vote only matters if you adhere to a collective. Anyone with non-mainstream opinions will always be outnumbered, so your vote makes no impact and does not matter.



t. political nihilism


Democracy is the least worst form of government


The safer platform from which to fight capital is one where you aren't actively handing it excuses to seize more and more power over you.



t. if i vote green party long enough they will somehow come into power


lol dumb seppos not having compulsory voting



Politicians don't want people to vote, so they do voter suppression and absurd voter id laws.


File: 23904d2f5542dbc⋯.jpg (59.18 KB, 976x549, 16:9, p03b0bfw.jpg)

tfw you're kicked out of your dream role to make way for the chibnall era



Most people aren't politically informed enough to deserve a say in the direction of the country



lol but you are right?



t. Mitch McConnell



If someone isn't invested enough in politics to want to vote, it's good that they don't vote.


skellys here




Political corruption thrives from inaction.



only US election related live stream i'll be watching is the chapo one



donald drumpf go on chapo



shut up you don't even know what chapo is



fight me


File: fc27458f859733e⋯.jpg (44.03 KB, 640x480, 4:3, med_1450568090_image.jpg)


where the video games?



Corruption can just as easily manifest by manipulating people who are forced to vote



i know a certain trip OC who would like to get on top of you and "fight" you, if you know what he means.





New thread is over here.

[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Nerve Center][Cancer][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / abdl / acme / agatha2 / animu / chemo / sonyeon / tacos / vg ]