If you're interested in trying something that may help your experiences all around, the next time this happens don't think about it and just do what feels the most organic.
Your mind, when you let it run along with what you're hearing, will more easily accept suggestions when you accept that you trust yourself to simply accept suggestions.
The only "wrong" way to experience a recording is to not enjoy yourself as you do so, after all this is your fantasy, your time, and your experience.
Hope this helps.