[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / b4 / choroy / dempart / doomer / freeb / lain / marxism / yuri ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

A collective of people engaged in pretty much what the name suggests
Winner of the 83rd Attention-Hungry Games
/strek/ - Remove Hasperat

May 2019 - 8chan Transparency Report
Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
Password (Randomized for file and post deletion; you may also set your own.)
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Flag
Options
dicesidesmodifier

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf
Max filesize is 16 MB.
Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000.
You may upload 5 per post.


File: 18179cedbe0d080⋯.jpeg (740.41 KB, 1443x1234, 1443:1234, 0B5FD28E-F9AA-44BE-AE02-3….jpeg)

 No.2938639

Honestly, I can’t tell, I’ll be honest I use Reddit about as much as I’m on here, and pretty much all the anarchists on Reddit are total fucking psychopaths and nutjobs, the vast majority think that Leninists are their greatest enemies bar fascists and they all hyperfocus on idpol and individualist bullshit than communism or anarchism. And I notice a lot of outspoken anarchists are like this to a large degree.

As far as theory goes, idk what’s really behind anarchism at this point; the first workers’ movements were more similar to anarchist formations than state socialist ones, and they were all slaughtered by the state very quickly, as was just about every attempt at anarchism committed to, I’m pretty sure Marx even came up with his theories about state control because of anarchists’ utter inability to deal with counterrevolutions.

So, yea, is it just Reddit, or anarchists in general?

 No.2938643

File: be06fec8b1f5033⋯.jpg (45.96 KB, 550x700, 11:14, 1415064432895.jpg)

>sympathy with Leninism will not be tolerated


 No.2938646

>>2938639

>leninists are reactionaries/counter-revolutionaries

<Anarchists actively flipped between supporting the Bolsheviks to supporting the White Guard and back again throughout the Russian Revolution

People who unironically support shit like Kronstdat are fucking rad-libs who are oblivious to the reactionary origins of such movements, and thus get their panties in a twist over the need to crush them.

>Leninists aren't socialists

Golly what an informative statement!

Anarchists can be level headed but generally my experience has been negative, however this is one of the worser experiences


 No.2938647

Holy shit what sub is this? Do anarchists unironically think this?


 No.2938648

>>2938643

>Tfw Leninists form the vast majority of and longest enduring socialist states and vastly improve the qualities of life for their people as well as industry and technology, to the point that the USSR survives the invasion of the Nazis, yet lEnINitS aREnT sOcIAliSts

They’re a genuine autocratic retard

They pinned their explanation for banning every single person that ever defended the USSR and called them all “Nazbols” and reactionaries


 No.2938649

>>2938647

It’s COMPLETEANARCHY

I think a top mod got triggered over Leninists having better arguments than she did and lost her shit and went on a banning spree and pinned up a shit ton of rants against Leninists

She stated originally that all Leninists are Nazbols and the person she’s replying to is calling that idea retarded


 No.2938652

>>2938639

Everything on Reddit is shit.

It is a trash can.

That is it.


 No.2938655

Fuck off, who cares, this isn't your blog for airing your reddit grievances faggot.


 No.2938658

I've heard far more reasonable and intelligent anarchists than this, and it's easy to pin this on Reddit, but the foundation for this kind of thinking is the idealist anarchist ideology. Reddit is just a great place for shitty theory to coalesce, that's all.


 No.2938665

>>2938655

Eat a dick nigga, obviously you cared enough to reply to some bullshit that’s easily ignored


 No.2938670

>>2938652

>Everything on Reddit is shit.

Nah, FULLCOMMUNISM is fun and there are non-political subs that are useful to peruse.


 No.2938770

All you people are retarded. Social Democracy is the only way to bring emancipation to the working individual. Are you tankies and leninists are low Autism Level leftists, nigga


 No.2938773

>>2938770

>to the working individual

<individual

breaking news: rose niggas are really fucking bad at trolling


 No.2938866

File: 5bbd7f28c702c8a⋯.png (48.03 KB, 894x773, 894:773, unamused 2.png)

>Leninists are counter-revolutionaries! So they need to be suppressed forcefully on our platforms!

<Why are Leninists counter-revolutionary?

>Because they suppressed a bajillion anarchists for being counter-revolutionaries a century ago!


 No.2938876

>>2938639

>Are most anarchists this retarded/autocratic, or is it just Reddit idpol types?

Anarchists range from highly intelligent with robust theory to total retards. Most people who call themselves "anarchists" have put close to zero thought into it, regardless of intelligence level. It's a popular word and poorly understood political movement, so it's a lot harder to gatekeep the fuckwits, unlike with Marxism of various types because there is a degree of orthodoxy there. That doesn't say anything about the quality of actual anarchist theory, though. It's a result of people picking up the label to seem cool, without understanding any of the history or political thought behind it. Socialism in general is going through the same process right now, and there are plenty of MLs who are as retarded as the most retarded anarchists.


 No.2938879

>>2938639

>Are most anarchists this retarded/autocratic

Depends on if your talking about Anarchy historically or currently. The FAI/CNT had pretty good praxis.

>>2938647

It’s reddit, so your going to get the worse of the worse.

>>2938670

You have to go back.


 No.2938880

Anarchism is when you don't like being told what to do, and the less you like it, the more anarchist you are.


 No.2938881

File: f2215c476b70108⋯.gif (1.24 MB, 353x300, 353:300, 1426461460730.gif)

>>2938639

>At this point, queer liberation is so inextricably tied to socialism


 No.2938883

File: e3e2dfeaf8a0e24⋯.png (352.07 KB, 595x649, 595:649, e3e2dfeaf8a0e2421136152492….png)

>>2938879

>The FAI/CNT had pretty good praxis.

Ehh…


 No.2938889

File: 5973fe611e9c571⋯.jpg (217.57 KB, 1080x572, 270:143, local man is fed up.jpg)

File: c47e55f27e1de53⋯.png (156.29 KB, 642x430, 321:215, socdem.png)

>>2938773

As a Social Democrat you Leninists and tankies make me sick. Your kind should not be tolerated at all. I see you people post and Im just tired of it. You guys are on the same level ancaps really. Unlike yours socdems ideas are actually practical.

No wonder you people get demolished in debates against socdems.


 No.2938893

>>2938889

Are…are you trolling?

Socdem is literally wHy dOnT wE pArTIcIpAte iN bOuRGeOiS pOliTiCs

It’s fucking retarded

You won’t get socialism by begging the bourgeoisie to let you have it

And I’m pretty sure we settled that social democrats are counterrevolutionary traitors over a century ago


 No.2938894

>>2938881

They’re LGBT I think so they’re trying to shove in idpol as the center of anticapitalism lmao


 No.2938896

>>2938883

Not an anarchist, but the United Front policy was pretty dismal in my personal opinion. The dichotomy shouldn't be between full communism and uniting with the "progressive" bourgeoisie.


 No.2938897

>>2938889

>local man is fed up

more like local man is a fed


 No.2938900

>>2938896

Yeah, but it's not like anybody in Europe would allow Soviet Union to invade Spain. You have to work with what you have, and no, Spain wasn't full of communists.


 No.2938904

>>2938883

>alienated the bourgeois and middle class to being forth revolution and empower workers

What’s wrong with this. Their is practically no diffrence between fascism and liberal democracy because at the end of the day your laboring for a parasite most of the day.


 No.2938905

File: e89661ad4402a8b⋯.png (107.92 KB, 273x252, 13:12, e89661ad4402a8bb3ad53fe79d….png)

>>2938670

>Reddit

>useful

>unironically name dropping r/FULLCOMMUNISM on /leftypol/

kill it with fire


 No.2938906

>>2938900

The worker’s struggle is against all forms of capitalism, not just fascism.


 No.2938910

File: 01daed088770c5a⋯.jpg (15.13 KB, 335x315, 67:63, 1531346840029.jpg)

>>2938906

>dude just declare war on the whole world lmao

>>2938904

Nothing. Except most of the military (and equipment) went to the Nationalists. Do the math.

>cathocucks


 No.2938916

>>2938910

>Except most of the military (and equipment) went to the Nationalists.

This is because Franco was a general. Not because of bourgeois “support.”


 No.2938919

>>2938916

Okay, and most of the military going to the Nazis? And the Blackshirts?

Western militaries are inherently fascistic in nature, so soldiers are drawn to fascist movements most readily.


 No.2938921

>>2938900

The Soviets should've aided the Republican government with the anarchists (even if anarchists are retarded) against the bourgeoisie, instead of potentially alienating very radical swaths of the population in favor of most likely little material support from the bourgeoisie who supported Franco anyway. Lenin never once said power to the workers and bourgeois government (which was the Menshivik position).


 No.2938928

>>2938921

>The Soviets should've aided the Republican government with the anarchists

<should've

The Soviet Union were the main suppliers of military aid to the Republican Army. This included 1,000 aircraft, 900 tanks, 1,500 artillery pieces, 300 armoured cars, 15,000 machine-guns, 30,000 automatic firearms, 30,000 mortars, 500,000 riles and 30,000 tons of ammunition.


 No.2938932

>>2938921

>Soviets should've aided the bourgeoisie government against the bourgeoisie

>potentially alienating very radical swaths of the population

>most likely little material support

>when you try to be materialist, but all your info is wrong


 No.2938935

>>2938639

https://twitter.com/HumanityFirstX/status/1147994316234792960

Anarchy isn't going to work in America because pigs are militarized.

Sad truth 🤷🏿‍♂️


 No.2938937


 No.2938940

>>2938935

Anarchism won’t work in America because it never worked anywhere, ever


 No.2938942

File: 8782b40135b895d⋯.jpg (58.24 KB, 720x720, 1:1, ok.jpg)




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Nerve Center][Cancer][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / b4 / choroy / dempart / doomer / freeb / lain / marxism / yuri ]