[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/lit/ - Literature

Discussion of Literature

Catalog

See 8chan's new software in development (discuss) (help out)
Infinity Next Beta period has started, click here for info or go directly to beta.8ch.net
Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 1 per post.


Liberate tuteme ex Excelsior!
The end is nigh! Check out the sticky.

 No.7684

critique thread

http://pastebin.com/PFdFV5CA

So far I have more but for some reason it didnt copy paste 48000 words.

pic unrelated

 No.7688

>The only resort was trade however the only two factions in reach were risky to deal with. One was about two miles southeast and another was about 5 miles west.

>two miles

>5 miles

Standardize that shit, nigger! As far as I know, you usually write the numbers below twelve as a word, everything above that as a number.


 No.7689

>The issue was that 2 miles southeast lay the legion who were known for the aggression they exhibited and militaristic intentions

This sounds like an understatement waiting to happen. I haven't read further, but if they are anything like the legion from New Vegas, then calling them "aggressive" and "militaristic" is pretty damn weak. I'd call the US aggressive and Prussia militaristic. If you have something crazier in mind, use harsher words.


 No.7690

>>7689

Fallout pic was unrelated, I'm planning on revisiting that section. This wasn't meant to have any connection to fallout. This is just some small town type place in the midwest which should probably answer your statement. but I might have to run through that again. It would really just require some rewording.

>>7688

I'm aware of fuckups of that variety and will fix such things in later edits.


 No.7691

>>7689

Also please keep in mind I've never played any fallout games but I might get 4 soon.


 No.7692

>>7689

Have you stopped reading or are you saving all of your criticisms until the end?


 No.7694

>>7692

Just looked over it quickly. I have a lot of stuff to do right now, sorry.


 No.7706

>>7684

While you have a decent grasp on basic grammar, I can tell from your first paragraph, what I assume is a blurb, that you have some issues with style. I'd mark it red a bit if it was in a doc or something. Unfortunately pastebin doesn't exactly give me that option.

From chapter one it looks like you're trying to hard to be literary, and maybe even keeping a thesaurus handy. It makes the read really clunky.

Don't use approximations like "about", "essentially", "approximately" or anything like that. It's weak writing and makes the author sound like they're unsure of their story. If the date is unknown, be vague. Describe it as autumn. Say it's autumn even. Dont, however, say that you don't know the date unless it's in character. If it was first person, that'd be one thing. It looks like, at the very least, it's third limited, which makes you the narrator.

Break up your paragraphs more. The longer they are, the more inclined a reader is to just skim them. As a rule of thumb, try to have paragraphs with 4-6 sentences.

I could probably whip up more if you're interested, but it might get lengthy. I'm seeing a lot of amateurish mistakes peppered through the first couple chapters. Keep in mind all of this is with style, not content.


 No.7709

>>7706

If you want I can let you view the google docs

I started this over a year ago and I was 14, so I don't want people to have the idea that I think it's very good.


 No.7710

>>7709

Wait, so have you not revised it yourself before asking for a second opinion? Because that's like trying to jam your dick in when it's not even hard yet. Trying to get off and it's not even as ready as you can get it.


 No.7711

>>7710

It's still in progress on the first draft, but getting people to spot the major fuck ups plus seeing how I should go about continuing from said fuck ups doesn't hurt. Also, asking for criticism from /lit/ isn't like getting off. If I wanted a bunch of praise and have errors ignored i'd go to reddit.


 No.7712

>>7710

It's still in progress on the first draft, but getting people to spot the major fuck ups plus seeing how I should go about continuing from said fuck ups doesn't hurt. Also, asking for criticism from /lit/ isn't like getting off. If I wanted a bunch of praise and have errors ignored i'd go to reddiT


 No.7713

>>7712

>>7711

Sorry. I tried to post and it said it didnt process, so I refreshed and tried to post again only to have two pop up. Fucking hate when that happens.

>>7712


 No.7714

>>7712

I guess that's a good point. I don't know. I have a lot of writing to do myself, but if I have any spare time I'll at least look over a few chapters for you, maybe try and get a general idea of anything you're doing wrong or lacking.

Don't expect a full line edit, though. Just some suggestions. Especially since it's hard to ignore the fact that you flat out said you were 15 or 16.

Experience is something you actually have to gain by writing more and more. Trust me, once you find your voice it's all down hill. I don't want to call it easy, but it's easier. From looking at this, it seems like you haven't had enough experience for that to happen yet.


 No.7715

>>7714

That's why I'm going to finish it. If nothing else for the experience.

I'm 15, which isn't to get you to hold it to a lower standard and make you less critical, but more to explain alot and make you not expect it to be good. Email gavinismario@gmail.com and you can view the full document seeing as that only pasted part of it. I feel like it atkleast gets progressivley better over time




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]