No.6
Shiki can kill servants. Discuss.
No.7
Can he/she though?
No.8
>>7Shiki yes, but would die in the process
Ryougi yes and wouldn't die
Of course this is assuming they can get a drop on a servant, since they would only be able to against assassin in a straight up combat situation
No.17
>>7Servants are huge amounts of magical energy, so vast that normal attacks don't even register, and magical attacks are like poking an elephant with a small stick.
However, Tohno Shiki has been shown killing ==magic itself==, so the only reason why he couldn't kill a Servant would be because he couldn't get close enough in the first place/he's outmatched in pure technique and speed.
No.23
Let's look at it this way, he was able to "kill" Arcueid who later appeared as a servant in Fate/Extra. Had Arcueid not been a true ancestor she may have actually died. So yes, Shiki can kill servants.
No.24
>>23Arcueid was at her 30% when he killed her and it was during the day of all things
After he killed her she was reduced to her 10% percent
It is stupid to base anything on him killing arcueid when she was weakened as fuck and had all the disadvantages
Killing Nero and Roa was a more impressive action on his part
No.28
Arcueid power level is 5 times that of an average servant, so if she was at 30% she was still 1.5 times stronger than a servant.
Shiki killing servants is akin to Batman killing superman. It can happend, but it would require a ridiculous amount of plot to make it happend. I agree on Shiki dying on the process though (due to strain when trying to understand the concept of servant), unless there were some kind of external force acting (like counting as a counter guardian on tsukihime complex).
And no, "Nasu said" doesn't work anymore, at least not until he launches Tsukihime 2 :P