>>1754
Your thumbnails are screwed up. It doesn't generate a full-size thumbnail comparable to 8chan, but it looks like it is trying to, because it adds a strange blank space on the right side of the thumbnail, and stranger still when you click to expand the image, the blank space changes into a different color than what the box surrounding it is. Please fix this, I like 8chan's large thumbnails.
I notice that the "Anonymous - date - time - ID - post number" is rendered at a smaller size, instead of the same size as the post text like it normally is. I'm not crazy about this change, but I could probably live with it.
Will there be an option to not have colored IDs? I don't like the way it looks, but I understand others may find it useful, so I think there should be an option for those who like it and those who don't.
I like that the reply box is sort of stuck in place on the right hand side, though it has some really strange rendering behaviors that need sorting out. I don't understand what the point of the + sign is, as all it does is blank out the page I am on, and stick the box in the upper-left corner of the screen. Not really useful. If I click and drag the bottom left corner to expand the window size, and then click the X button to minimize the window, it shinks the red bar down to the default width, and leaves behind a darker colored box that isn't there if I didn't expand the window and clicked X. Very strange looking. See attachment.
I like that the text is wrapping to about 75% of my screen width on a large screen, I'm guessing you saw my old /operate/ thread requesting a feature for this on 8chan. Right now on 8chan I have it customized in CSS to 55%, so it would be nice if I could get this customization on Infinity as well, but I don't feel it's very critical right now.
I'm not crazy about the design for the multi-file uploads. I do like the idea of spoilering only select files if you like, but the visual design to demonstrate the option looks strange. The big check marks aren't pleasing either. Attached is a simple mockup based on the existing design that might work better.
To cut down on this wall of text, here is a quick list of other features I noticed are missing:
-No back-linking to show how many replies a post got.
-No hover preview of a quoted post to see that post before clicking the link to go to it.
-No clicking an ID to highlight each post in the thread that ID made.
-Formatting is all kinds of screwed up: Spoiler tag makes text bold. Italic tag does nothing. Bold tag does nothing. Underline tag makes text bold. Code tag does nothing. Strike-through tag is functional though. Red-text tag doesn't work, but there is some kind of alternative way to make giant red text.
-No hotkeys for any of the tag functions listed above.
-Also no tag wrap button available, which is a hugely useful function for people posting on a phone.
-The date doesn't mention the day of week, a minor but helpful feature.
There might be other things missing that I'm not aware of yet, but honestly I don't feel this is ready for prime time at all.
Oh, and one more thing, captcha for each post is a bad idea. Once per day I can live with though. Alternatively, if I can drop down some cash once per year to buy an 8chan pass that skips captcha, like like 4chan has, I will absolutely buy it.