[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/politics/ - News & Politics

Politics, News, Current Events

Catalog

Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
Flag *
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Oekaki
Show oekaki applet
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, swf, pdf, swf, pdf
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


Sister Boards [ Third position ] [ Fascism ] [ National Socialism ] [ Anarchism ] [ Anarcho-capitalism ] [ Libertarianism ] [ Marxism-Leninism ] [ Psychopolitics ] [ Philosophy ] [ int ] [ History ]

[ Board log ] [ ###politics### ]


File: 1446011803641.jpg (18.05 KB, 475x356, 475:356, Katy-student.jpg)

d9ca9e No.3834

SEVENTH GRADER REPORTS TEACHER INSTRUCTED CLASS GOD IS A MYTH

A seventh grade student in Katy, Texas says that her reading teacher instructed her class that God is a “myth” and that any student who says God is a “fact” or an “opinion” is wrong.

Jordan Wooley, a straight-A student at the West Memorial Junior High School–part of the Katy Independent School District (ISD)-said she and her classmates were told by their reading teacher that God is not real and that answers to the contrary would warrant their grades being docked.

According to a report in Covering Katy, Jordan and her class were administered a test on the existence of God on Monday.

“We were asked to take a poll to say whether God was fact, opinion or a myth, and she (the teacher) told anyone who said God was a fact or an opinion that they were wrong,” she said.

Jordan’s mother, Chantel Wooley, said the test accounts for about 40 percent of her daughter’s grade in the reading class. Despite this, she said her daughter was not willing to renounce her faith in God.

Wooley continued that the exercise about God did not come from a workbook, as the students do not use workbooks in this class.

According to the report, Jordan’s teacher taught several other classes that day, all of which included the same instructions about God.

At the Katy ISD school board meeting, Jordan spoke during the public comments portion and said, “Another child had asked the teacher if we could try to put what we believe on the paper, and she [the teacher] said you can if you want to get it wrong.”

“It appears the teacher was not following Katy ISD’s curriculum, because Memorial Junior High students who have a different reading teacher said God was never mentioned in their class, according to Wooley,” says the report.

Superintendent Alton Frailey responded to Jordan, “I’m truly sorry that you feel that your faith was questioned.”

“What’s going on is that the principal was made aware of this today and is going to have a chance to work on that as per district policies and procedures,” he added. “We definitely will look into that. Thank you very much. It was very brave of you. Thank you, honey. Good job.”

Wooley said her daughter was called to speak to the school principal on Tuesday morning. She added that she was not invited to be present during the meeting.

d9ca9e No.3836


123632 No.3868

" My position is that agnosticism is the default position, the position that merely says, "I don't know" (which can probably best be described as soft-agnosticism). ANYONE WHO LEAVES THE DEFAULT POSITION HAS THE BURDEN OF PROOF, whether it's a theist or an atheist."


d9ca9e No.3872

File: 1446020073152.gif (25.3 KB, 712x956, 178:239, agnostic.gif)

>>3868

>agnosticism


123632 No.3889

>>3872

Invalid (and dumb) analogy. There are two possibilities for the universe, it was created by an outside entity or it created itself.

If you pick one, burden of proof is on you. There's no proof for either one yet. We could be a computer simulation. There could be 10 levels of creators. Humans could have become so advanced and created a sub universe.

God doesn't necessarily mean to the Abraham god, it can mean to the "creator"


1352e2 No.3913

>>3889

>it created itself

If someone can truly rationalize this as a possibility while dismissing God, then they are quite possibly the dumbest humans on the planet.

Christ is Lord tbh fam


c585c0 No.3915

>>3913

not necessarily "created itself", it could have "always existed", like you argue for God. Any argument theists can make for God, can also be made for the universe. That's why both atheists and theists are equal in the sense they both make claims without proof.


1352e2 No.3916

>>3915

>it could have "always existed"

But it hasn't. We have evidence of that.


c585c0 No.3917

>>3916

It could be changing form, or in a loop, expanding and collapsing forever.


b2f6f8 No.3918

>>3889

>there is no proof for either side yet

They are premises. They will change when proof against them comes up...

Atheists don't want to admit this, though..

>>3917

So long as there is the possibility of it stopping (ie, staying in singularity, not collapsing etc.) this one is razored by Occam.


b2f6f8 No.3934

>>3868

Theism is the default position though.


b33c5f No.3935

>>3872

can prove he exists*


bd1d0e No.3936

So what if this question was about Zeus instead of Jahweh?


1457f5 No.3937

The point of atheism/agnosticism is that its pretty obvious that religions are a man-made invention and its also pretty obvious that spooky tampering by a being outside the laws of physics is infrequent or non-existent. We could very well have been created as in the universe is a simulation, but it doesn't seem that the creators if there are any can do anything to us so nothing matters in that regard.


000000 No.3993

>>3936

Then the teacher would have been able to provide proof for his claims. In this case, he can't.


1352e2 No.4005


b45886 No.4534

Whether or not God exists is not the matter here.

A publicly funded school should not deal with religion and belief, even if the instructor's position from the lack of one.

Would this incident count as encroachment on America's separation of religion and state?


bead6e No.4562

>>3834

Why are all you idiots arguing about wheather theism or atheism is the defualt by occam's razo


bead6e No.4563

>>4562

hit enter by mistake

The point is that the Government can't promote this one way or another.


000000 No.7546

>>3834

Teacher shouldn't instruct people about what is and isn't a myth, but how to properly use logic and evidence.

Jesus has worked miracles in my life, I feel only sadness for atheists who have been brainwashed.


35cbca No.7547

i'm an agnostic atheist. this teacher is fucking retarded, and should be fired, but won't be fired because of the unions.


4fa16d No.7551

>>7546

>Teacher shouldn't instruct people about what is and isn't a myth, but how to properly use logic and evidence.

>Jesus has worked miracles in my life, I feel only sadness for atheists who have been brainwashed.

I agree, but unless you can provide evidence of the existence of a supernatural deity, counter the mounds of evidence that disprove many of the things in religious texts, and figure out how all the inconsistencies and double think are some how logical then I'd say you're relying on faith. Believe what you want, but calling atheists brainwashed is comical.

>>7547

This. Religion has no place in schools.


a870d4 No.8312

Thread about freedom of belief is now another tips fedora echo chamber.

That teacher can believe in what she wants, but she cant force that into kids.

Dump her into the trash is the only real solution.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
[]
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]