>>115630
You did it wrong you fuck
You have to be yourself from the start.
Not from a random point in a relationship. You obviously started acting differently, aka as "yourself" with that girl AFTER she already knew you.
Girls will catalog you by how you act in the beginning, that's why first impressions are so important. You can't change the first impression you left on a girl, they're the most important and will mark how your relationship dynamics work with her.
Don't give up on the "be yourself" just yet. Next time try applying it to new people (not just girls) and see what happens. A person who's just getting to know you is not going to judge you for changing your personality because that's the only personality she knew. So go ahead, and if she doesn't like, there are plenty more people around.