I have an odd and kinda specific fetish for canon used goods, or more specifically, cute second hand girls. Let me explain.
The girl should
>Be canonically non-virgin, either explicitly told or heavily implied
>The relationship in which she lost her virginity must be already over (or be a one night stand). If the girl is still dating her first boy, it doesn't count
>Rape doesn't count. To make it easier to understand, losing "virginity" as stated in the above rules only counts if the girl was willing (ie. if she got her hymen broken to rape, her "virginity" would be intact until she had consensual sex). Likewise, being raped while dating her first boyfriend doesn't count.
>The girl doesn't necessarily have to have dated more than one boy, or even having had sex with more than one boy although if she has some sexual experience, then it would be even better. What's necessary is that whoever she lost her virginity to, is no longer dating her. Bonus points if they have already moved on or if it's been a long time since then (mainly to avoid a drama-centered plot).
>If it's a hentai, it must be explicitly acknowledged that the first time she has sex on screen, she's not a virgin. Just not bleeding doesn't count, as sometimes authors decide to remove the blood but keep the character virgin
>It's preferable if the girl is already non-virgin from the moment the plot starts, but she may lose her virginity during the anime if the above conditions are met
>Bonus points if they are cute and not skanks
>They may be as fuck-happy as you want as long as they aren't skanks. They may be sluts, but classy sluts, as in being sex hungry beasts but acting like a normal woman when not in the bed. It is important to keep that cute and somewhat innocent façade towards the rest of the world, although they don't have to necessarily hide the fact that they aren't virgins
I am asking because it is really fucking hard to find something like this in the Japanese anime industry and nobody seems to have taken the time to make a list of characters like this. There are some resources as to which characters had sex at some point of their animes, but all characters who had sex seem to have done so to their current boyfriends, and they will probably end up getting married in the future
Pic unrelated. It is loosely implied in the light novels that Haruhi may not be a virgin depending on how you interpret some of her words, but it isn't heavily implied. Unrelated to her seiyuu Aya Hirano too, since she seems to be kind of a skank.