The Frivolous Nobel Lawsuit
The lawsuit is very real. It was definitely filed. In fact, two lawsuits were filed, one against the Nobel Assembly and one against Shinya Yamanaka, one of the scientists who won the prize:
http://dockets.justia.com/search?filters=&query=Rongxiang+Xu
Rongxiang Xu, et al v. Shinya Yamanaka
Filed: February 26, 2014 as 14-15359
Plaintiff - Appellant: RONGXIANG XU, an individual, MEBO INTERNATIONAL, INC., a California corporation
Defendant - Appellee: SHINYA YAMANAKA, an individual
Court: Ninth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
Type: Torts - Injury › Assault, Libel, and Slander
Rongxiang Xu v. The Nobel Assembly at Karolin
Filed: December 19, 2013 as 13-57130
Plaintiff - Appellant: RONGXIANG XU, an individual
Defendant - Appellee: THE NOBEL ASSEMBLY AT KAROLINSKA INSTITUTET, a Swedish corporation, AKA Nobelforsamlingen
Court: Ninth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
Type: Torts - Injury › Assault, Libel, and Slander
Xu et al v. Yamanaka We have downloadable decisions or orders for this case
Filed: July 12, 2013 as 3:2013cv03240
Defendant: Shinya Yamanaka
Plaintiff: Mebo International, Inc. , Rongxiang Xu
Cause Of Action: Diversity-Personal Injury
Court: Ninth Circuit › California › California Northern District Court
Type: Torts - Injury › Assault Libel & Slander
Rongxiang Xu v. The Nobel Assembly at Karolinska Institutet et al We have downloadable decisions or orders for this case
Filed: February 22, 2013 as 8:2013cv00320
Defendant: DOES, The Nobel Assembly at Karolinska Institutet
Plaintiff: Rongxiang Xu
Court: Ninth Circuit › California › California Central District Court
Type: Torts - Injury › Assault Libel & Slander
Both cases were dismissed and appealed. In essence Dr. Xu's legal eagles were trying to claim that he had made the discovery a decade earlier and that recognising Dr. Yamanaka for this had caused damage to Dr. Xu's reputation and his income. The case against The Nobel Assembly was dismissed with prejudice as California has no jurisdiction over them and the claims are ridiculous. The Nobel Assemly's official response was LOLWUT?
Nobel Assembly response
http://www.nobelprizemedicine.org/?p=3226%20[http://www.nobelprizemedicine.org/?p=3226
Press release
http://www.nobelprizemedicine.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/Press-release-121207.pdf
PRESS RELEASE FROM THE NOBEL ASSEMBLY
AT KAROLINSKA INSTITUTET
The Nobel Assembly at Karolinska Institutet has been informed by an American
news agency that a lawsuit has been filed against us by a person in Los Angeles. We
have not yet received any such lawsuit and have not, therefore, been able to assess it
in detail. The name of the plaintiff has never been put forward to us previously.
This year´s Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine awards the fundamental
discoveries that demonstrated that mature cells can be reprogrammed to become
pluripotent. The Prize has been very well received and has obtained massive support
by the international scientific community.
They weren't even served, they got it from a news agency. And you can bet that news agency was PRNewswire.
Almost every instance where this story was posted just regurgitated the original press release. That press release originated from Mebo-International of which Dr. Xu was president and founder. And every press release had Ardent Law Group and two names at the bottom as contacts for more information and there were emails and telephone numbers for them. I'll cover that in another post. It isn't clear what the objective was, but publicising the case was probably seen as a way to give it some legitimacy and stop it being thrown out as simply frivolous. It was thrown out as simply frivolous. Because it was.