[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/starwars/ - Star Wars

I find your lack of faith disturbing

Catalog

See 8chan's new software in development (discuss) (help out)
Please read: important information about failed Infinity Next migration
Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, swf, pdf
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


File: 1426459846282.jpg (100.15 KB, 512x704, 8:11, Mace_Windu.jpg)

 No.1056

What do you think of Mace, /starwars/?

People say Samuel L. Jackson was a bad choice for this character, and I guess I can see where the criticism comes from. But I think he managed to breathe some life into a character who otherwise would have been completely flat.

Apparently having Mace die confronting Palpatine rather than "like some punk" (i.e. all the other Jedi sans Yoda and Kenobi) was Jackson's idea, based BMF

 No.1057

original scripts for E3 had windu survive the fall and get killed by boba fett

and slj was a great pick, it's not like we needed idris elba for the role or anything.

 No.1061

>I think he managed to breathe some life into a character who otherwise would have been completely flat.

I agree. He seemed like a his script was written as a filler character, but jackson made Mace feel relevant as an active leader in the council. Yoda would sit back and chill, but Mace took on the onus of conducting meetings

 No.1063

I didn't mind the character. I think a lot of the criticism of him comes from just a watching of Episode 1 where he doesn't do much, but it pays off in Episode 3. He was so hard on Anakin throughout the prequels that when it came to the confrontation with Palpatine he was probably the only Jedi that Anakin would have been okay with killing.

 No.1065

>>1057
>original scripts for E3 had windu survive the fall and get killed by boba fett
Really? Shit. Wasn't Boba still a little kid at that time?

 No.1067

>>1065

he would be somewhere around 15-17 years old, having already donned jango's armor and started doing bounty hunting on his own

 No.1069

File: 1426488164378.jpg (165.23 KB, 716x1000, 179:250, star_wars_rebels___old_man….jpg)

>>1056
You mean the character that should have fallen but caught on to come taxi or something, then got a robot arm and became a badass space pirate? The wasted potential of a character? Yeah he's ok

 No.1070

>>1069
Wait. What now?

 No.1073

>>1070

dunno if this is official or fan-made but i remember reading some fun fan theories about mace surviving and becoming a hermit basically.

dunno about space pirate but if this does happen in rebels that would be legit.

 No.1081

>>1070
>>1073
This is a fan made image. Ever since I was a young lad I always theorized that Mace actually survived, then I saw this image and freaked out. Turns out it's fake though. I'm just upset they didn't make him a badass Order 66 survivor

 No.1104

>>1069
>>1081
When you think about it the way Obi Wan and Anakin handled falling through Coruscant Mace should have been able to survive.

Since Maul survived death in Star Wars needs to be more than falling some great distance.

 No.1108

File: 1426616238374.png (333.78 KB, 411x551, 411:551, brav0nolan.PNG)

>>1104
Anakin and Obi-Wan have George Lucas Plot Armor, and were able to conveniently land on those flying cars in Coruscant through the will of the Force.

Mace was temporarily possessed by Palpatine's mind control powers into falling to his doom.

 No.1112

>>1108
This makes sense and I hate it

 No.1165

>>1057
ROTS came out in 2005. Idris Elba probably wasn't even an actor then.

 No.1167

>>1165

no but he did start around the time ep 1 came out

so he missed the casting call by like like a year and a half

 No.2511

Clone Wars Mace Windu was the shit

Actually made me give a fuck.about his character in.the movies


 No.2512

>People say Samuel L. Jackson was a bad choice for this character, and I guess I can see where the criticism comes from.

The character was written FOR Jackson, what the fuck are you talking about? The reason he even had a purple lightsaber was because the actor demanded it so he could stand apart.


 No.2523

>>1056

Never liked him until I saw 2D Clone Wars. Although he was too OP for me there, but still wicked.


 No.8253

Was never all that crazy about him.


 No.8300

>>1057

Would have made sense, shame they didn't do it.


 No.8408

>>1104

Mace probably close to dying after Palpatine's shock


 No.8409

>>2523

Everyone was OP as shit in 2D Clone Wars

> tfw General Grevious kills 4-5 jedis at the same time despite not being force sensitive

Wut


 No.8416

His character had no development, he was just bland Jedi.

If he wasn't played by Samuel L Jackson he'd be totally forgettable, but as it was the character has no personality. SLJ didn't do bad with the acting - you never cringe like you do with some lf the younger actors - but there's nothing for him to really do.

Yeah, he does some action scenes, but he never gets to show any emotion or personality, and that's a character design issue.


 No.8417

File: 1448557557581.jpg (34.99 KB, 360x203, 360:203, the Muunlist Ten.jpg)

>>8409

red smoke OP, pls nerf herd


 No.8419

>>8409

to be fair he has them tired, worn down, cornered and seriously freaked the fuck out. He levels the playing field quite a bit by getting in their heads which is something that no other incarnation of the character does unfortunately.


 No.8425

>>1056

Mace's death still confuses me to this day.

When he flew out of the window, I did not understood what happened, did Anakin force pushed him ? Did Palpatine has a secondary effect with his force lightning ? Palpatine doesn't seem to move much more to push Mace, it's like he's getting pulled in a strong gust of wind.

Plus considering all the cwazy vidya ninjuh shit the jedi do in the Prequel, I would have expected mace to survive that little fall.

>But bacta, you excrement eating tripfag, it was a big fall

Well shit, what about Anakin dropping free on Zam's speeder ? That couldn't have been too good for his ribcage

>b-b-but he's the choosen one

Midichlorians and prophecy aside, Mace and Yoda were the 2 most powerful jedi in all aspects (I insist on Jedi, not sith) in the Prequels. Anakin was shit in clones and barely on par with Obi-Wan in Sith. Yoda sent Obi-Wan to fight Anakin, remember ? And all those fodder jedi (and Kit Fisto) just died instantly, Mace held up and would have Vapaad'd Sheev into oblivion, if it wasn't for Mister CRAAAWWWLIIING going across the street on Mace.

TL:DR: what the fuck happened in that scene, what or who made Mace go full Wily E. Coyote because i'm too dumb to get it.


 No.8430

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

>>8425

Yeah, it honestly looks fucking retarded.


 No.8434

>>8425

>>8430

only thing i can guess is that when sheev goes "UNLIMITED MEMES" he sort of does a build-up force of lightning and that pushes mace dindu out the windu.


 No.8435

>>8425

Force lightning also pushes things in games like Jedi Academy.


 No.8439

>>8425

I believe Mace died from the force lighting just after is hand being cut, in the end be throw out by the force lighting

Rip Vaapad creator

Also Sidious was consider to be one of the greatest lightsaber fighter along side Yoda, wWindu and Dooku


 No.8441

>>8425

> Did Palpatine has a secondary effect with his force lightning ?

This was extremely obvious.

> Plus considering all the cwazy vidya ninjuh shit the jedi do in the Prequel, I would have expected mace to survive that little fall.

He was either extremely damaged (arm cut + body ravaged by the lightning) or already dead.


 No.8453

File: 1448823792701.webm (2.88 MB, 640x362, 320:181, 1396892590925.webm)


 No.8468

>>8453

So OP


 No.8479

>>8453

when he unbolt the droid and then make the parts rain on the others droid to shred them to explosion hnnng


 No.9926

File: 1451261866783.png (293.1 KB, 455x435, 91:87, wutas.png)

..




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]