Anonymous 10/05/14 (Sun) 12:41:04 No. 1057 [View All]
Morrowind vs Oblivion vs Skyrim Go.
67 posts and 9 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.
Anonymous 02/23/15 (Mon) 19:36:42 No. 5585
File: 1424720202499.png (244.77 KB, 1398x2005, 1398:2005, FireShot Screen Capture #0….png )
These are probably the most subjective arguments there are
Anonymous 02/23/15 (Mon) 19:37:40 No. 5586
File: 1424720260254.png (70.01 KB, 1407x608, 1407:608, FireShot Screen Capture #0….png )
Bumping for visibility
Anonymous 02/23/15 (Mon) 19:39:37 No. 5587
File: 1424720377227.png (120.45 KB, 1404x976, 351:244, FireShot Screen Capture #0….png )
Anonymous 02/23/15 (Mon) 19:41:28 No. 5588
File: 1424720487436.png (54.68 KB, 1406x524, 703:262, FireShot Screen Capture #0….png )
>>5585 OBJECIVE, I meant OBJECTIVE dammit
Anonymous 02/23/15 (Mon) 19:43:07 No. 5589
forgot all about multiple file uploads
Anonymous 02/23/15 (Mon) 19:44:54 No. 5590
Anonymous 02/23/15 (Mon) 19:46:18 No. 5591
Anonymous 02/28/15 (Sat) 05:56:32 No. 5695
>>4896 >Just mod your problems away I didn't know I spent money to finish the game for the devs. The reason why Skyrim feels "more finished hurr durr" than Oblivion is because Skyrim is a much smaller and more featureless game. PC Master Race eh? More like taking in the ass and saying "it's okay, we'll do your shit for you! master race.
If Bethesda continues this route TES will be dead. Bethesda should just merge with Obsidian and name the company "In Memoriam" for they are shadows of what they were.
Anonymous 02/28/15 (Sat) 06:09:38 No. 5696
>>5695 Todd Howard and his gang of n'wah jews couldn't even make a functional menu for the PC. With TES 6 we'll finally get the perfect game of unfinished, buggy, and featureless content with five perk trees, 30 dungeons, 3 towns, one guild that just combines everything, and the only way you can functionally play it is on the Ouya and the PC version is just a modkit for 75 dollars. Be 12/10 game of the year all years since people like to eat that shit up so much apparently.
Anonymous 02/28/15 (Sat) 10:58:31 No. 5697
>>5696 >couldn't even make a functional menu for the PC Also walking doesn't work properly, and no mod could fix that.
Anonymous 02/28/15 (Sat) 11:03:14 No. 5698
>>5695 This.
I've played Skyrim and this is the Exact core reason why in such a short time it has morer mods than Oblvion, next to the cancerous incorporation of nexus and Steam content.
It's because the community has no sense of direction, not because no one knows what to do to "fix" it, but because there isn't even a hint at whatever idea was to go into the creation of Skyrim as a functional game in the first place, no one has any idea how to mod it to make it feel like vanilla yet as envisioned up to scratch and quality.
Oblivion for example has almost everything fixed save for combat and performance fixes, it's pretty much got most of it's shit snuffed out by the community.
Skyrim's a fucking mess because it was made post fallout modding community when for some reason, the great will of the universe decided all monster mods and overhauls shalt become shit irredeemable pieces of crap only casuals with no understanding or care for the game use.
Anonymous 02/28/15 (Sat) 13:48:24 No. 5700
>>5698 It's been 20 years since Arena, and 12(?) years since Morrowind. You'd think by now Bethesda would have their shit together, but instead of making a feature packed game with shit people liked, they stripped out most of the features.
N'wah think they're fucking geniuses for buying a game that should be an improvement but instead adding shit that should have already been there. There's a few good things to like in Skyrim, I won't disagree, but compared to the last four games it's a step backwards and will always be that.
Skyrim being better than Oblivion? What fucking horseshit are fetchers smoking. I have to do far less tweaking to Oblivion, usually just install the unofficial patches, and I'll be fine. With 11/10 GOAT Skyrim I have to fix the menu, tweak the ini files, install mods that doesn't work that well just to get classes and birthsigns, redo the perk tree with PerMa or something similar, install patches to fix at least a handful of bugs, open the console menu when quests break like the Companians radial quests, and more. And I still don't have a product even remotely close to what I actually want in comparison to the other games.
I can judge a game based on how much I have to add to it to be satisfied, and Skyrim is a shit game for that reason. The majority of the quests are downright boring, the combat doesn't punish you like it should, your race pretty much doesn't matter, and you end up being a jack of all trades but a master of none. And you, as a player, in a world that is supposed to give you a power fantasy and a sense of escapism, are powerless.
Rather play Oblivion any day of the week.
Anonymous 03/02/15 (Mon) 13:52:57 No. 5729
>>1059 ye mayn skyrim was way better than oblivion completely kool and original
Anonymous 03/02/15 (Mon) 17:33:39 No. 5731
>>4807 >FOOLISH GIRL THAT VAMPIRE HUNTER DOESN'T LIKE YOU>YOU BASTARD ASS VAMPIRE HUNTER I KNOW YOU DON'T REALLY LIKE US HOW COULD YOU YOU COULDN'T THAT'S HOW >NO MOM HE LOVES US RIGHT VAMPIRE HUNTER >F U C K N O >SEE MOM SEEEE >ALRIGHT WELL IF YOU REALLY LIKE US SO DAMN MUCH GO DO X TASK >I DON'T BUT I HAVE NO CHOICE >I DID IT >HOLY SHIT HE DOES LIKE US >NO I DON'T >GOD DAMN IT I DON'T >SEEEEEEEEEE MOMMMMMMMMMM
Anonymous 03/02/15 (Mon) 19:01:26 No. 5732
>>5695 >I didn't know I spent money to finish the game for the devs.A-FUCKING-MEN, amen!
>>5698 >Its because the community has no sense of directionThe mod-shit involved with Elder Scrolls at this point is a bloody clusterfuck. Everyone and their mother is frantically throwing shit into the mod pile with no sense of purpose, and completely forget about the fact that we're paying 60 bucks, for what?!?
Bethesda, I'm not saying I didn't have fun with Skyrim, but get your fucking shit together, you know what we're talking about.
Anonymous 03/04/15 (Wed) 13:44:00 No. 5756
Anonymous 03/04/15 (Wed) 15:26:57 No. 5758
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play. this needs to be spread when people say Skyrim isn't mainstreamed / dumbed down /casualized.
Anonymous 03/04/15 (Wed) 23:03:07 No. 5762
>>5695 you fetcher, we all get the same game in end whether on PC or console. The only difference is that on PC you can mod it, and nobody spends money on that. The other difference is that when people find that a game is devoid of content due to console fags and casuals people on the PC have the ability to make the game better. Not to mention some people just plain like modding.
Ultimately you're just a butthurt console fag who doesn't understand that he is the problem.
Anonymous 03/04/15 (Wed) 23:08:02 No. 5764
>>5729 Oblivion did have better quests than Skyrim but Skyrim had better gameplay. That doesn't make up for the fact that Skyrim is repetitive though. I feel like TES is going from RPG to dungeon crawler,
Anonymous 03/06/15 (Fri) 06:30:18 No. 5801
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play. >>5758 thoroughly debunked
Anonymous 03/06/15 (Fri) 11:45:22 No. 5803
>>5764 Gameplay means nothing when it is so dull I do not wish to play it.
Anonymous 03/06/15 (Fri) 11:48:11 No. 5804
>>5801 while dave in this video corrects the other dudes points there is still no doubt that skyrim was extremely dumbed-down. Good vid tho
Anonymous 03/06/15 (Fri) 15:18:34 No. 5809
>>2854 Morrowind was amazing because it gave you the capacity to use your imagination to give significance to events, it was also a struggle at times because it necessitated you doing that to get over the clunky mechanics. The fact that lines weren't voiced allowed for a great quantity and quality of writing, and the story blows the more recent TES stories out of the water.
The game is annoying as fuck though, I mean its great to actually feel like you are the deserving hero of the land; but the fucking cliff racers don't know that.
Anonymous 03/07/15 (Sat) 07:52:36 No. 5820
>>5804 Oh certainly but I still think skyrim had a lot of depth to offer. My main issue with samuyl is his tinfoil tier argument about 'duh filth'y casuls' its that kind of crap that makes elder scrolls fans look like fetchers. I grew up on daggerfall and thought morrowind was dumbed down. I realized its not that they're being dumbed down its just a generational gap and as features get streamlined they cut the fat. For instance I don't think I ever used swimming my entire play though and I thought acrobatics was stupid aside from easy leveling. the problem is forcing morrowind down peoples throats is off putting for most of them.
The best way to get them to play is to simply say "you liked skyrim? If you want a challenge check out morrowind if you can get past the age issue" instead of "urg filthy casuls take away muh elder scrouls! you play morrowind now!"
I know samuyl and his fans are a little more verbose than that but to the average player that's all they hear.
Anonymous 03/07/15 (Sat) 11:46:44 No. 5822
I haven't played morrowind or oblivion. Mainly because I'm a sucker for mods and graphics and waifus, but I still enjoy TES lore. Skyrim has probably the least interesting story of the three games. Look at morrowind. There's vivec and co, the numidium, and all of this cool new innovative shit. Oblivion had oblivion gates and you meet the emperor first thing, and he tells you that you're fucking special, and there's all the oblivion gate portals and shit. Skyrim? The main story is that a dragon is going to destroy the world and you gotta stop him. Its a cliche that has been done to fucking death in every medium. Blah blah blah dragons. Where the fuck is the cool shit like the tribunal? The different dimensions of the daedric princes? Hell your character feels like a normal fetcher whose only talent is to easily shout and everyone else can shout too, but they just have to try harder. Dragonborn was so much better than the original game because it felt unique. The black books were cool as shit. Solstheim was just fucking cool. I mean, skyrim is superior in gameplay and graphics, but story and lore wise I think its worse than the previous two games.
Anonymous 03/07/15 (Sat) 16:24:04 No. 5824
>>5822 >implying oblivion's story wasn't even more cliche than Skyrim's Oh no, armies from hell! We've never seen that before!
Literally the only thing interesting about the Oblivion Story was Mankar Camoran.
Anonymous 03/07/15 (Sat) 17:55:27 No. 5825
>>5820 good comment about the generational gap.
I grew up on Morrowind and so am old enough to get what you're saying.
I still think there is too much nostalgia going on though. Skyrim had its problems, like debased magicka, but it was still fun.
Anonymous 03/07/15 (Sat) 18:01:19 No. 5826
>>5822 You're wrong about dragons. Maybe they are hackneyed in fantasy books, and now with all the GOT shit, but in videogames they haven't had a big presence since I started playing at the turn of this century
about the stories, some things work while others don't, I don't think its so clear-cut as simply saying Oblivion is better. Oblivion's hell army is kinda bland but its narrative is pretty good. I find Skyrim's Dragon gods and civil war far more appealing in the abstract, though the actual execution was a little wanting.
Anonymous 03/08/15 (Sun) 06:09:07 No. 5832
>>5824 But damn if dat game werent the greatest
Anonymous 03/10/15 (Tue) 15:54:37 No. 5896
>>5824 And wow wasn't he interesting. It's disappointing at the lack of implementation of mythic dawn, we sorta just see these guys as crazy cultists but they're very embedded before they go allah ackbar on the CoC. I'm surprised nobody from the Elder Council was part of it.
Anonymous 03/10/15 (Tue) 15:57:57 No. 5897
>>5822 The basic outline for Oblivion was basically DOOM. Skyrim took from Norse myth, like the world serpent, and ragnarok. Alduin should have been much bigger, like with wings that cast a shadow over villages. He should have been Grigori-tier.
Morrowind, again, is best. Dagoth Ur, alongside Miraak was probably the greatest threat to all life. Dagon was pretty bad, but you could recover from it, Alduin was pretty bad, but again, everything would just start over. Dagoth would have been worse than anything.
Anonymous 03/10/15 (Tue) 16:11:48 No. 5898
>>4972 They killed this stuff for Tolkien-level.
They really need to do a reboot and make all of the outer lore canon.
Anonymous 03/10/15 (Tue) 16:14:52 No. 5899
>>2854 The Nords really needed to have some crazy shit involving the Thu'um. Greybeards should have been levitating rocks or something. Ropes made of tongues.
Anonymous 03/14/15 (Sat) 14:49:47 No. 5960
Anonymous 03/16/15 (Mon) 17:48:29 No. 5996
>>5391 THIS RIGHT THE FUCK HERE.
Hopefully, in a few years all the fetchers who played Morrowind in childhood will grow out of being immature luddites and go back to playing games for fun and not hipster cred. Morrowind's melee combat was flat out broken, magic was bland and cumbersome at best, and archery was almost as bad as melee. Difficulty was like a lightswitch from moderately challenging to cakewalk at level 15, give or take a few levels depending on your play style. The environment was a bland spectrum ranging from pale green to dark gray. The dungeons were puny and loot was rarely even worth the trip.
>Inb4 muh fast travelNo one forces you to use it in the later games, or the earlier ones for that matter. In fact, not only are you free to walk anywhere and everywhere, you can do it on horseback in II, IV, and V. Hell, you can even take carriages and boats in V if you're that desperate to pay for travel.
>Inb4 muh mushroom housesA few building designs of varying degrees of originality don't make the environment as a whole any less bland. The environment was probably pretty nice as a concept, but the execution was terrible.
Morrowind's only edge over Oblivion and Skyrim is its main story, and even then, it's not by much. Being forced to do the bidding of a bunch of malevolent false idols and clean up their mess for them is almost as bad the cliches of IV and V.
Honestly, I would even rate Daggerfall higher than Morrowind. Morrowind reduced Daggerfall's scope and didn't do much to make the game any deeper or more immersive. In fact, they did a lot to damage DF's immersion. For example, they stripped down character creation, removed mounts, made dungeons small and pointless, and removed quest time limits. Apart from graphical and mechanical improvements, MW doesn't really have much to offer compared to its predecessor. It seems like it was an awkward transition phase between quantity and quality, and it didn't do either very well compared to II and IV.
Anonymous 03/16/15 (Mon) 21:06:44 No. 5999
>>5996 >Being forced to do the bidding of a bunch of malevolent false idols and clean up their mess for them is almost as bad the cliches of IV and V. Well, you're not doing their bidding, you're just trying to save the world. Vivec realizes that the jig is up, and says 'alright I've had my fun, you win Azura'.
And even then you can still just say 'fuck you Vivec' and kill him (or xim, whatever the fuck they call him on reddit), which is arguably the greatest thing about TES: III.
>inb4 bu duh tribunal just sat on their ass The Tribunal had to keep the Ghostgate up, and they had already tried to kill Dagoth Ur, with no luck.
Sermon 11, only Nerevar could fight Dagoth and win.
>Honestly, I would even rate Daggerfall higher than Morrowind >implying most of us don't already know this The greatest thing Morrowind offered to TES was its lore.
Anonymous 03/16/15 (Mon) 21:14:55 No. 6000
>>5999 >That guy who uses these as reaction images tooYou're alright.
Anonymous 03/16/15 (Mon) 23:59:42 No. 6001
>>5999 >>6000 meanwhile, trips
Anonymous 03/17/15 (Tue) 02:25:44 No. 6002
File: 1426559144814.jpg (244.52 KB, 736x801, 736:801, 70f94c243e7cc4d4383ce51a1b….jpg )
>>5996 amen son.
Morrowind is nostalgia shit. Oblivion and Skyrim are the best, hell I'd say Skyrim is the best, get fucked.
Anonymous 03/17/15 (Tue) 02:27:44 No. 6003
>>5999 you have no power here
Anonymous 03/18/15 (Wed) 08:16:19 No. 6024
Anonymous 03/18/15 (Wed) 23:13:25 No. 6044
>>5764 >skyrim had better gameplay than oblivion Oh yes, I just love moving at a snail's pace unless I sprint, having all the magic spells feel like gimmicks, and having the shield feel like it's not even there because half the time there's no impact sound.
Anonymous 03/20/15 (Fri) 02:25:40 No. 6068
>Morrowind: 9.5/10. The only flaws I can think of are the dice-rolling combat and the outdated graphics (Which can be upgraded with mods) so while it's not perfect, it's damn close to it. For beginners, it's tough as shit, but once you figure it all out, it's still one of the best RPGs ever made. >Oblivion: 6/10. Fun at first, then you'll start to notice its flaws. The world feels bland and uninspired, the characters start to feel cookie-cutter, and they got rid of a lot of Morrowind's customization and game-breaking options (Armor, weapons, magic, etc). Not to mention, it completely butchers Daedra and turns them from scary as fuck 11/10 OP enemies into generic agents of Hell. The story was okay, and the combat was an improvement over Morrowind's, but overall it was a step down for the series. >Skyrim: 3/10 as an RPG, 8/10 as an adventure game. Skyrim's exploration was some of the best I've seen in a while. With snowy mountains, frozen lakes, and ice caves, there was a bunch you could explore and find, not to mention the atmosphere was top-notch. Too bad the RPG mechanics were pretty much removed entirely and the story didn't give you any lasting effects with your choices. It's best when played through only once with all the DLC, but when you do play it, it's awesome.
Anonymous 04/11/15 (Sat) 01:23:30 No. 6405
>>5696 Actually here is how I think it will go:
Announce TES6 at E3.
Say that everything about it will be mod friendly including the engine code!
People buy game.
Read EULA and this is what it contains:
"Hey there! Um yeah we ran out of time when the game was being developed and so we had to compile what we had finished so far into a stable release. But because the series has a great modding community todd said screw it and let the modders finish the rest. Oh and we had no time to beta test so this software is PROVIDED AS IS with no warranties for any damage this game does to your computer or your data. HAPPY DEBUGGING SUCKERS!"
Release construction set with a ton of "cut content" (Which was stuff that they had no time to add.) and "Addon Scripts" (Lines and sections of unfinished code that still needs to be added.)
Release the unofficial patches as "Free DLC" while taking credit for it all.
???
PROFIT?
Anonymous 04/13/15 (Mon) 10:51:27 No. 6435
>>5996 Such buttflustery
I still fire up Morrowind once a year and binge-play it for weeks at a time.
And what's more, I
genuinely enjoy myself You angry, n'wah?
Anonymous 04/14/15 (Tue) 20:24:59 No. 6452
>>6435 >I still fire up Morrowind So do I. And I
genuinely enjoy myself , too. I just don't enjoy it as much as the rest of the series (excl. Arena because it's basically a shittier version of DF) or pretend it isn't outdated and overrated. With the exception of MW, every main tes game has been an improvement over the last.
And you have to be pretty mad to resort to calling people butthurt :^)
Anonymous 08/02/15 (Sun) 13:58:48 No. 7956
>>4760
>black brother hood
Anonymous 08/04/15 (Tue) 19:06:08 No. 7975
>>2956
Why the fuck did they remove unarmed skills
Anonymous 08/05/15 (Wed) 04:42:26 No. 7978
>>7975
Casuals. I don't know how, or even why, but I can assure you that it was the fucking casuals who ruined it.