No.81
Post your arguments here.
Have fun I guess?
No.138
Alright, I will take the first bite.
Kenny endings have a much better feel to them, and Clementine is probably in much more capable and loving hands in either of Kenny's endings. I don't believe Kenny would ever hurt to Clementine as some Janefags like to believe.
No.218
>>138plus there's the possibility of having kenny's hat in S3
No.356
>Lee killed a man who fucked his wife
>No one doubts his ability to parent
>Kenny started to beat a woman who got his babby killed after having it in her care for less than two minutes
>He killed her after she stabbed him and gouged his eye
>Not only do people question his ability to parent, but think he needs to be "put down"like he's a sick animal or something.
I just can't comprehend that.
No.438
>>81Kenny endings are better in every sense, in my opinion.
They feel more hopeful, wholesome. They're pure emotion and Kenny's selflessness made me cry like I did during season's 1 finale. I also feel like Kenny and Clementine are the best duo to take care of AJ, they really DO love him. They find common ground in that and are more relatable, that and I think their bond, after all what's happened, has strengthened quite a lot. Kenny's endings feel more natural and make more sense with the story for me.
Jane's endings, in the other hand, feel half-baked. The last scene with chocolate Duck saying "nice hat" made me incredibly uneasy. And if you don't let the family in, Clementine's coldness made me feel sad, she's definitely not the same girl. They end in a bad note, that's much is clear.
#MyClementine is hopeful and happy when she's with Kenny.
I believe Clementine is lost and gone forever is she's with Jane.
No.443
>>438I agree with this. Though I will say the Jane endings feel more true to the walking dead universe. Personally I don't give a fuck about keeping true to the universe - I just want #MyClementine to be happy and safe, and I feel that was a safer bet with Kenny than with Jane, or Alone.
No.524
>>356>Lee killed a man who fucked his wife>No one doubts his ability to parentYou just blew my mind
No.552
>>438Clem taking AJ to Wellington was the right ending for me completely. Twice they've tried to survive in groups day to day, twice it failed and with a noisy baby and Kenny so unhinged it's a matter of time before it falls apart again. Kenny begging Clem to stay was heartbreaking but now AJ has a chance and Kenny's sacrifices weren't for nothing, he can walk away to whatever future knowing he did something right and Clem has a chance for stability and community that's not really in him to offer anymore.
It was amazing. Perfect ending.
No.565
>>356Because there's really nothing to comprehend, anon.
It's practically like Janefags arguing that letting her die and going with Kenny is a bad idea, and that he's dangerous. Cue the next scene, he sacrifices himself to get babby and you into Wellington.
No.578
>>552I just couldn't leave Kenny since I worried he would just let himself die afterwards. I was hoping there would be an option to leave AJ with someone at Wellington and go with Kenny.
No.586
>>578I felt 50/50 on that, he's a born survivor i figured he would pull himself together or lie down and die but clem around he'd be stuck in limbo. being separated is a new start/opportunity for all of them.
No.589
>>578I'm not so worried about him biting the bullet, rather the fact that he knows his survival out there is slim. I left with him, but for other anons who stayed I really hope their Clem presses on for him to come back one day ;_;
No.594
>>578>>586>>589Don't worry anons, he took the supplies. We know all to well what kind of man Kenny is, and he would never take the supplies if he intended to die after leaving Clem and AJ in Wellington, even more if you assume that one more bag of supplies in Wellington could help them, at least indirectly.
Le deranged bearded boat man is safe.
Until S3E1 tfw No.595
>>594Don't say that, anon. My boatman is with AJ and Clem and he's gonna survive ;-;
No.601
>>595That's what I want too, anon. They can make it can't they? Kenny can fix anything they need and Clementine and AJ can lend him plot armor ;_;
No.700
Both awful for different reasons.
Kenny slightly less awful.
No.701
No.704
>>701Kenny has always been a misguided, far-too-angry asshole. He can be nice but a lot of the time he's an unreasonable douchebag. He can't calm the fuck down and that is a huge problem. Even if he's justified his anger agitates anyone else in whatever group he's in. This is why he thanks you if you kill him, or insists that you stay in Wellington without him. At least he knows he's a piece of shit, makes him less awful.
Jane is retarded and fucked up. She is abandon-crazy and has much too much a hard on for Clem, such that she'd even put an innocent baby in complete danger just to prove a nonsensical point.
All that said, I shot Kenny. I stayed with Jane because I don't trust Clementine with a baby all by herself. Even Jane might be better than nothing. Not that it matters.
>telltale No.719
>>594>Until S3E1 tfwanon
anon please no
No.762
I shot Kenny because he didn't kill Arvo. He had to pay for that.
No.788
>>762His incompetent group wouldn't let him bucko, it wasn't his faul.
No.794
>>788>not doing it anywayCome on, the least he could've done is kill Arvo after he shot Clementine. For all we know he's still alive.
No.797
>>794Don't be hard on him. He was probably too busy attending Clementine's injury
No.858
Both Kenny and Jane are crazy for different reasons. Kenny is crazy because he's extremely impulsive and rash, but most of his reasons for being that way is simply because he cares too much. Jane is crazy in the more apathetic and cold way. She seems more down to Earth, but she's the type who, when an idea is stuck in her head, she sticks to it without wavering (shown by her incredibly manipulative way of baiting Kenny in to a fit of rage). At least Kenny can be kept under control for the most part.
Kenny also wants to stay with Clementine and AJ to protect them. Jane doesn't give that much of a shit about AJ and only sees Clementine as someone she can mold into another version of herself. Plus Kenny is the one with actual parenting experience.
Kenny's Wellington ending is the most emotionally impactful and satisfying of all the endings too, in my opinion.
So yeah, that's how I feel.
No.905
>>704You're one bitter anon. What happened to you? did your fav die?
No.1095
I ended on this thread googling kenny vs jane rule 34
we are on the map now, guise!
No.1097
Jane's way better than Kenny, IMO. Kenny was more on-edge and probably would've gone psycho had AJ died later on. Jane put Clementine's safety above the baby's, which is what I would've done. Maybe I'm a heartless bastard, but that baby's gonna be nothing but a potentially fatal liability for the next 7 or 8 years at the least. In the here and now, Clementine and Jane's safety are what matter most.
No.1101
>>1097You're right, you're a heartless bastard
No.1103
>>1097Agreed.
I guess I'm a heartless bastard, too. ;-;
No.1150
No.1181
>>1097What's the point in surviving after throwing the babys life away? If people don't reproduce humanity is going to die out eventually