[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/tv/ - Television and Movies

Catalog

Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, swf
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


Rules Baneposting Film Star Wars Actresses

File: 1458389778212-0.jpg (150.14 KB, 1200x800, 3:2, dull surprise 1.jpg)

File: 1458389778212-1.jpg (15.91 KB, 239x328, 239:328, dull surprise 2.jpg)

 No.278546

Does anyone else think Rey from the new Star Wars is like Keira Knightley's character from Pirates of the Caribbean. The only difference is that for some baffling reason she's the main character.

It's been a repeated trend in media to have a surprisingly tough girlfriend or girl character who defies expectations (given it's so overused at this point though, it's actually become the expectation).

I'm not talking super heroes or anyone brainwashed. Just someone with 'training'. Training that allows them to win despite weight, height, body shape or gender disadvantages. For instance, I'm not talking about River from Firefly/Serenity, I'm talking about Zoe from that series.

Other examples off the top of my head include

>Black Widow

>The girl from Chuck

>The sister of Jackie Chan's character in that movie with CIA and Owen Wilson

>Asami in LoK (though she's done better than most)

>Peggy Carter

>Agent 99 in Get Smart

There introduction usually involves them flipping a character who made a comment about how they don't look tough FUCKING SHIT LORD. Whenever they get into a fight with a man, you know they're going to win because they're a woman.

It was only a matter of time before someone was stupid enough to take this lazy, overused character archetype and put it as the main character in a major film. Unsurprisingly, it doesn't work.

 No.278548

File: 1458390052038.jpg (234.84 KB, 500x502, 250:251, 1389610484792.jpg)

>>278546

> for some baffling reason

apparently OP has been living in cave


 No.278550

File: 1458390107299.jpg (102.67 KB, 950x743, 950:743, 145666789370111.jpg)

SJWs, Jews, Black Helicopters, Reptilians.


 No.278554


 No.278556

>>278554

And by kej I mean kek


 No.278595

>>278546

Nothing we already don't know OP.


 No.278789

>>278546

Zoe was not an unreasonable character all considered. I struggle to think of any Mary Sue-tier shit she did anyway (more than anyone else did in Firefly anyway).

How exactly is a military veteran being competent in a firefight defying expectations? Particularly when it's made clear those who haven't fought, male or female, are next to worthless.

The rest of your examples are fairly accurate though.


 No.278801

the problem is, instead of gradually making rey the stronk wymn like they did with ripley and sarah connor, they just hit it off the bat and shoved it down your throat. there was no buildup to her being a badass, it was just implied from the start that she's an asskicker.


 No.278809

She's the same as Hunger Games girl: set up as a strong female lead but actually makes very few decisions and has little or no agency, while escape routes and lots of men show up to help her survive the plot.

An actual strong female character would be someone like Kusanagi from Ghost in the Shell.


 No.279011

>>278809

Strong female characters only work when they have some unrealistic advantage helping them out and completely ignore being a female when fighting. Such as your example which is a cyborg and not fighting as a woman at all.

Stronk womyn on the other hand wear their animosity toward men on their sleeve, their need to prove how badass they are in every scene, and a veneer of realism overlayed over the unrealistic physics used in their fights. They can knock out men with feeble baby arms that probably punch about as hard as a twelve year old boy.

There was a reason why in the past the "badass" woman comrade character ended up fighting another woman. Nobody would take her fighting a man serious. It's a sign of how far society has been brainwashed concerning women being tough, that they are able to put it out full on without being laughed at.

What some of you don't realize is that this shit is aimed mostly at young boys who tend to idolize badasses. When all the "badasses" available are women and all the men are cucks what do you think this does to boys psychologically?


 No.279015

>>278546

Bitch somehow knew how to pilot and manage the millennium falcon better than its long time owner and somehow was skilled with everything she got her hand on. It was pure bs just like the film.

Ms. Swan however wasn't much of a Mary Sue except for in the final film which was just as poorly written as the second. I don't think it was intentional that she was written that way and was simply a product of poor writing.


 No.279017

File: 1458426029368.jpg (48.22 KB, 500x496, 125:124, 1454150541452-0.jpg)

>>278546

I'll reserve d my opinion of the character until her arc is finished and so should you.


 No.279020

>>279017

You can't undo the first movie, it's already irredeemable shit and so his her "character."


 No.279055

>>279017

>"Jeez OP just wait four to six years for her arc to be over before you cast judgement!"

Christ what a fucking moron.


 No.279057

File: 1458429813923.webm (7.05 MB, 720x304, 45:19, plot armor awakens.webm)

her fight scene with kylo was laughably bad. look how heavily they had to edit it. if it was a static camera shot it would look like a cartoon with a 5 foot tall weakling "overpowering" adam driver. boyega's fight scene was passable because he looked physically able.

if she had beat him using force powers it would have made more sense - making a tree fall on him or something - but nope grill power is more important


 No.279059

File: 1458430187734.png (135.18 KB, 244x231, 244:231, 1442532896853-3.png)

>>279017

>I'll reserve my judgement of a poor, bland, paint-by-numbers hollywood film until I see its shitty sequel.

Assholes like you are why The Fart Awakens was successful in the first place. The second film is not going to save any of it's horrible characters.

pic is you, by the way


 No.279061

>>278546

man, keira knightley in pirates of the caribbean got me so horny as a kid…


 No.279069

>>279061

>man, keira knightley in pirates of the caribbean got me so horny as a kid…

What are you, ten? Get the fuck outta here kid.


 No.279070

>>279057

Interesting how savage and aggressive she fights. This is apparently to show how strong she is becoming as she gets angry, or something? Such lazy hack writing. Compare this Empire, where Luke fights with a similar rage and savagery and is easily defeated by the cool, reactive Vader, showing his calm mastery.


 No.279071

>>279017

She won't become a semen demon if that's what you're hoping for. Bitch is likely going to become the next supreme jedi of whatever order they make.


 No.279075

>>279069

i'm 20


 No.279080

File: 1458431163232-0.jpg (11.4 KB, 298x232, 149:116, Woman-Look-in-the-compact-….jpg)

File: 1458431163232-1.png (607.51 KB, 728x728, 1:1, Girls-Take-Selfies-Basebal….png)

The reason women respond so well to this trope as well as demand it is that they have no sense of developing a skill having it tested , failing, working harder to improve and only then prevailing through perseverance and hard work. It's not part of their value system. They'd rather pay their 8$ and say" here pander to my fantasy about how girls are really better than boys." Women are narcissists. Why else would they carry little tiny folding mirrors in their purses. Everything is a mirror to them and they demand to be shown what they want in them whether it reflects reality or not. This is why entertainment is as good as ruined from now on.


 No.279082

File: 1458431593160.png (482.5 KB, 1352x2353, 104:181, 1429225557294.png)


 No.279086

>>279080

That second picture you have there is from a baseball game between innings when the announcer told everybody to pull out their phones and take selfies.


 No.279092

File: 1458432859744.jpg (172.84 KB, 600x450, 4:3, daenerys-targaryen.jpg)

>>278809

>set up as a strong female lead but actually makes very few decisions and has little or no agency, while escape routes and lots of men show up to help her survive the plot.


 No.279094

File: 1458433387082.jpg (52.08 KB, 230x237, 230:237, Starbuck2.jpg)

This bullshit character ruined an otherwise excellent show. They even had a scene where she beats some guy up in a drunken scuffle over a poker game. My eyes were rolling hard at the fact that in order for women to feel good about themselves they have to be perceived as having as much testosterone coursing through their veins as a man.


 No.279099

>>279017

man, I'm sure glad everyone waited 38 years before having an opinion on Han Solo's character arc!


 No.279101

>>279094

in the first two seasons she wasn't that bad tbh

her downfall started with season 3, they clearly had no idea what to do with her anymore, just look how they ended their storyline


 No.279113

File: 1458437170466.webm (7.76 MB, 640x360, 16:9, Girls at Ball Games.webm)

>>279086

Try not sucking so many cocks


 No.279140

>>279113

#whitegirlsaremagic


 No.279157

File: 1458442138198.jpg (45.1 KB, 562x437, 562:437, shit.jpg)

>>279113

>Teen girls at a ball game

>spend the whole time taking selfies and not even watching the game

Selfiefags are truly loathsome.


 No.279159

File: 1458442268639.gif (6.27 MB, 400x505, 80:101, black widow twirl.gif)

>>279011

>They can knock out men with feeble baby arms that probably punch about as hard as a twelve year old boy.

It's eye-rollingly silly when Scarlet Johannson babytaps a guy or flips all of her 110lbs frame and they're sent flying.

Like you say, if there's some equalising factor (magic, future tech, etc), it's okay. But when "she's just that badass" is the only reason why a woman who would struggle with the bowling ball I use can knock me out with a punch, you just have to laugh.

On a different tangent, you'll sometimes get the men are stronger, women are faster shtick, but that's just as bullshit. Men outpace women in every physically demanding activity, whether it's sprinting or fighting.


 No.279164

File: 1458442531097.jpg (13.02 KB, 360x283, 360:283, 1451319447816.jpg)

>>279092

I don't believe there is a single person on this board who disagrees with you.


 No.279166

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

>>279113

>>279140

>>279157

Fucking #triggered!

Educate yourselves, shitlords!


 No.279170

File: 1458442990322.gif (996.46 KB, 500x228, 125:57, jpop stifled laugh.gif)

>>279113

>>279086

how does it feel being BTFO this hard?


 No.279172

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

>>279057

I noticed the choppy editing in the cinema too, and knew exactly why it had to be done.

Ever watch the special edition extras of Return of the King? They spent all day shooting the scene where Eoywn stabs the Witch King because the poor chick (Miranda Otto) playing her couldn't hack it. The huge Maori guy playing the Nazgul said he felt really sorry for her (she even broke down crying) but he was told by Jackson and the stunt coordinators to not baby her.


 No.279173

>>279070

>Interesting how savage and aggressive she fights. This is apparently to show how strong she is becoming as she gets angry, or something?

There's a disconnect there, though. I can't buy it. My brain won't accept that she overwhelmed him the same way Luke overwhelmed Vader in Jedi. Not because of sexism, but because I'm a person that's actually engaged in physical activity at least once on my life.

Ironically, Rey would probably have fit the silly, over top CG lightsaber battles from the prequel trilogy better.


 No.279328

Is it in TV Tropes yet?


 No.279339

>>279328

>SJW Tropes

Probably not.


 No.279342

>>279057

>that exaggerated jodan stance at 0:22

>not stabbing her through the gut or chopping her in half at the waist while her guard is completely down for a WHOLE second

>losing your cool while in a duel to the death

>conveniently forgetting you have force powers at all

Holy shit, it's worse than I thought.


 No.279346

File: 1458457256332.png (42.44 KB, 758x770, 379:385, 1439907360257.png)

>>279057

>mfw people praised this crap

>mfw its like Episode I all over again where it was praised for years until people finally acknowledged how bad it was

>mfw it'll probably take another 5 or 10 years for this shit to be seen as the shit pile it truly is

>mfw 10 years from now all negative critiques will still likely be silenced by calling anyone who didn't like the movie a bigot

Just fuck this gay earth already.


 No.279347

> for some baffling reason

I sincerely hope that's a facetious exclamation on your part.

Frankly, I'm surprised she isn't black to boot.


 No.279392

>>279057

As a HEMA practitioner, most Hollywood scenes involving swords are frustrating to watch, but this is certainly one of the worst.


 No.279405

>>279057

By the look on her face and angry fighting I'd say she was already Dark Side.

Oh wait they don't really care about that shit anymore do they.


 No.279521

>>279057

Her arms are too short, she'd get her ass kicked by long armed Driver.

They need lightspears since swords are so shit in comparison.


 No.279579

File: 1458493235290.jpg (270.75 KB, 1200x800, 3:2, star-wars-rey-finn-running.jpg)

>>279405

She's angry half of the time in the movie.


 No.279617

>>279579

No, that's just her running face.

Seriously, who the hell grits their teeth like that when running? How the fuck did J.J. think it was a good idea to show that?


 No.279622

>>278546

>Rey is just the same dumb 'tough female sidekick

Mate, next time watch the fucking movie before you spout nonsense like that.

Rey is a fucking mary-Sue par excellance, succeding in everything against the dumbest odds and being prefectly capable of mastering everything she touches for the very first time.


 No.279627

>>279622

Seriously. Compare her to Luke who was constantly getting the shit kicked out of him in the first two movies, particularly in Empire which could've been re titled "Luke get's the piss beaten out of him spiritually and physically for two hours."Even in his moment of glory with the Death Star still had to be saved by a surprise Han Solo.

Rey just wins all the time and almost never needs help.


 No.279640

>>279069

>not realizing the third potc was 9 years ago already

oh how time flies


 No.279670

>>279082

>women only lanes

haha, you can't make this shit up

In the name of equality they've given life to the old stereotype.

what's next, repealing their vote just so they're safer?


 No.279866

>>279617

She's running full tilt. That's why she is gritting her teeth. She can barely keep up with the Congo refugee.


 No.279871

>>279347

>I sincerely hope that's a facetious exclamation on your part.

Let's hope it is. Also yeah they originally were considering casting a black actress for the role but I guess racemixing was more progressive than two black lead roles.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]