>>7938
There's also a cosmopolitan undercurrent in early Christianity - it spread among the deracinated proles of the larger cities first, while the country side remained pagan for centuries. Human issues connected to living in cities include social alienation, the sundering of traditions, and out-of-control status signalling: the same issues that spurred the development of Marxism during the industrial revolution.
I'm convinced that Spengler was onto something, calling it the "grandmother of bolshevism". I've started calling it spiritual bolshevism, because where Marxist-Leninists leveraged material circumstances as the ennobling myth for the masses, Paul used the teachings of the Mystery Schools and their doctrine of 'being saved' to work the low self-esteem of the masses.
Imagine a world where elitism is the dominant order of society: the strong rise to the top of the social ladder, the brave shine in the military, the brilliant uphold the sacred arts. And way, way below them, on the level of the street and the catacombs, the masses, though fed and entertained, feel completely left behind in every respect. How tempting Pauline Christianity must be, preaching that none of all that matters once you're chosen because you believe, because you know about the one true faith that supercedes all the previous ones. It's no surprising that the powers-that-were jumped onto that as soon as they figured out what a powerful tool that is.
Tell the lowest of the low that they deserve to be on top, and voilà: a leftward ratchet that develops over centuries and parasitically feeds on a civilisation's very life-blood.