[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]

/rec/ - Anime & Manga Recommendations

Ask about recommendations and source here.

Catalog

Infinity Never
Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, swf, swf
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 5 per post.


If you're looking for source make sure to search on Google Images and TinEye before creating a new post.

For downloads/scans check Nyaa.se, Bato.to and BakaBT | For general requests >>>/r/


File: 1423539935885.png (2.89 KB, 1900x2900, 19:29, Template.png)

 No.2372

Let's make some themed recommendation list

 No.2373

Do you have something specific on your mind that isn't already covered by some other chart that was already made or are you just planning on updating one of those charts?

 No.2374

>>2373

I'd like to see a manly men and music themed anime list

 No.2378

File: 1423547462498.jpg (1.37 MB, 1652x4222, 826:2111, manly_anime.jpg)

I've been thinking about putting together a comedy specific one. If you have suggestions reply to this post.

>>2374
>manly men
Pic related.
>music themed anime
Good idea.

 No.2379

Are there any Martial Arts list?

 No.2382

>>2374
>>2378
>music themed anime
There already are, like, two different music anime lists. At the very least one of them should be on /a/ wiki.

Now what I will suggest, is specifically a list of pre-2000 OVAs and movies. There is an old anime list, but consists mainly of long-ass TV series.

 No.2383

File: 1423597492485.jpg (1.18 MB, 2700x2000, 27:20, 1367928381668.jpg)

>>2374
>music themed anime
Found one.

 No.2385

>>2383
Music themed.
I think he means stuff like Beck, Sakamichi no Apollon and Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso.
Not sure if idol shows would qualify to be on that list though.

 No.2388

>>2385
Well, fine.

Beck, Nana, To-Y, Sakamichi no Apollon, Kaikan Phrase, Furusato Japan, Hard Rock Save the Space, Shigatsu, DMC, Nodame… And that's basically it.

Assuming idol shows and K-on do not qualify, can you name anything else? Because I think 10 entry-level shows are not enough for a thematic list.

 No.2390

>>2388

It doesn't have to exclude idol stuff just have it split between it and non-idol stuff

 No.2391

>>2390
Well then, go on and make and post ver.1 of the list, as you see it, and we'll correct you if something is wrong. Just don't use the template from OP-post, if possible. Custom templates look better.

 No.2392

>>2391

I haven't seen all of these so I don't know if they are good
Let me know if something should come off or be added

Music
Ai Shite Knight
Beck: Mongolian Chop Squad
Detroit Metal City
Furusato Japan
K-On!
Kids on the Slope
Lemon Angel Project
Nana
Nerima Daikon Brothers
Nodame Cantabile
Piano no Mori
Sensual Phrase
Skip Beat!
Tari Tari
To-y
Tribe Cool Crew
Your Lie in April


Fantasy/Scifi
Black Heaven
FLCL
Interstella 5555: The 5tory of the 5ecret 5tar 5ystem
La Corda d'Oro
Shinkyoku Sōkai Polyphonica
Violinist of Hameln


Magical Girl
Fancy Lala
Full Moon o Sagashite
Princess Tutu
Suite PreCure
Symphogear


Idol
Aikatsu!
AKBoo48
Chance Pop Session
Legendary Idol Eriko
Love Live!
Lovely Idol
Miss Monchrome
Pretty Rhythm
PriPara
SoniAni: Super Sonico
Wake Up, Girls!

 No.2393

File: 1423607490480.jpg (103.68 KB, 600x680, 15:17, how_do_I_trumpetah.jpg)

>>2392
Off the topic of my head the entire Macross Franchise can be more or less added under Fantasy/SciFi. Also Sora no Woto under the normal section.

I dunno about FLCL. Yeah Haruko uses a guitar as a weapon and the soundtrack is great but music isn't actually a theme of the show.

 No.2394

>>2392
>K-On!
I don't think it fits there. Its main focus is moeblobs, and not music. They goof off all the time and have very little practice, and yet they are able to perform perfectly. Make a separate "K-on tier" for it or something. Putting it in the music category is a total mockery.

 No.2395

>>2392
>Magical Girl
>Symphogear
Fans of mahou-shoujo would tear you a second asshole for this one. Put it in sci-fi.

Oh and also add Locodol somewhere in the moeblob tier. For the same reasoning as K-on.

And also if we include Macross, why not Megazone 23? Add it into the sci-fi category too.
Polite sage for doublepost.

 No.2396

>>2392
>Ai Shite Knight
It doesn't have complete english subs. http://forums.bakabt.me/index.php?topic=24363.0

 No.2397

>>2392
Sonico is awful though.
Even Hanayamata would be a better choice.

 No.2398

>>2397
>Sonico is awful
For a mindless music-themed ecchi it does its job pretty damn well. Just because it doesn't meet your overhyped/unrealistic expectations, doesn't make it any worse. And I think I should remind you that we're making not "The best of the best top titles list", but simply enumerating all music-themed shows which anon knows. Those who would use the list later on, have their own preferences, and can decide for themselves what to watch and what to omit.

If we follow your logic, we should also remove Shigatsu (because it's 95% dumb forced drama), Nana (because it's 95% whorehouse), and so on and so forth. Majority of the listed shows are awful in some regard. And if you insist to start picking on their flaws, in the end there would be no list at all.

 No.2421

Why isn't there a ecchi/cheesecake/fanservice list?
With categories like Catgirl, Monstergirl, Robogirl, and so on

 No.2422

>>2421
I second this.

 No.2425

>>2398
>Just because it doesn't meet your overhyped/unrealistic expectations
Nice projection.
I had zero expectations about the show and I still thought it was terribly executed from an objective point of view.

> And I think I should remind you that we're making not "The best of the best top titles list"

It's implicit that a chart is suppose to be a compilation of decent titles and not just all the related garbage you can find.

>If we follow your logic, we should also remove Shigatsu (because it's 95% dumb forced drama), Nana (because it's 95% whorehouse), and so on and so forth.

Sure. I wouldn't have a problem with that.
Quality > quantity.

 No.2428

File: 1423775606075.png (298.34 KB, 2610x3700, 261:370, 1354861375001.png)

>>2425
>Sure. I wouldn't have a problem with that.
>Quality > quantity.
As you wish. Pic related is full of quality and decent titles.

 No.2429

File: 1423778132646.png (111.63 KB, 283x463, 283:463, 1306269984234.png)

>>2428
It seems like we are done here then.

 No.2434


 No.2474

So is anyone gonna actually make a chart?

 No.2475

>>2474
There are some useful ideas in this thread.
Just pick one of them and start building the chart on Gimp or something.

 No.2478

>>2475
Would that I could but I can't into photoshop

 No.2585

File: 1424979007530.png (39.82 KB, 1900x2900, 19:29, 1423539935885.png)

>>2421

Have a shitty prototype template

 No.2586

>>2585
Too many slots.

 No.2588

>>2585
>>2586
I'd say division by arbitrary categories is not needed. Half of the ecchi will fit into multiple slots, and the other half is just "general" ecchi which doesn't lean towards any partucular category.

There should be no categories, but instead under each slot there should be some free space to write in there the most prominent fetishes of a given title.

 No.2592

File: 1425011169877.png (33.26 KB, 1900x2900, 19:29, v2.png)


 No.2594


 No.2653

>>2593

>Wicked City

>Kite

>Ninja Scroll

>Mezzo Forte

>Cleopatra

>Kanashimi no Belladonna

>1001 Nights

none of these are ecchi


 No.2654

>>2653
And your arguments are?

 No.2657

>>2654
Well for one none of them have ecchi under their genres. In fact all of those except Wicked City and Ninja Scroll are considered hentai.

Nudity ≠ Ecchi

 No.2658

>>2657
First, "their genres" are set by totally random people, most of whom are newfags. Second, genres of anime are an extremely flexible thing, and their boundaries are not set in stone. I'll give you examples if you want.

Shounen is defined by demographics of manga magazine which published the original work. But, most of LN adaptations are also shounen.
Seinen is defined the same way. But, adaptations of proper novels are seinen too.
Slice-of-life is not obliged to have any moe, or any female characters at all.
Yet again seinen is not obliged to be "dark & bloody & gritty", it can be quite lighthearted.
Josei is not obliged to contain romance, or to depict realities of life of adult women. K-project is a total battle-josei, so to say.
Galaxy Express has nudity, implied prostitution, and a whole other can of worms, and yet it is kodomo/G-rated, and it aired in a family-friendly timeslot.
Koe de oshigoto and a couple more of shows listed above have barely censored dicks on screen, and yet they are not hentai. Majority of Go Nagai shows have sex with hardcore perversions, and yet they are not hentai.

Contrary to what you are saying, I've seen many, many newfags dropping Wicked City with the wording of "ewww it's hentai". While in fact sex ≠ hentai.

Yet again, when a typical western viewer thinks about "hentai", he thinks of non-stop fuckening with zero plot. In fact, "all of those" do not fit this definition. They excel in ecchi field first and foremost, and sex scenes do not end in themselves, not to mention in Tezuka movies they are veiled in a much better way than sex in some examples from above.

Sex ≠ hentai. Ecchi and hentai are not mutually exclusive. Think outside the goddamn box, think with your own head, and judge the shows on a case-by-case basis, instead of lumping them together in some arbitrary categories. If it causes such disputes, the whole list should be renamed to "Anime Erotica". A simple yet effective move, isn't it?

 No.2765

bump

 No.3269

File: 1430387113966.png (2.42 MB, 1900x2900, 19:29, 1425011169877.png)


 No.3280

>>3269

Some of those thumbnails look really low quality.

Did you use Paint to resize those images?


 No.3281

>>3280

I sure did

I can't into photoshop

I'm just hoping my shitty attempts will get someone mad enough to make it themselves


 No.3291

You boys doing the ecchi rec list should fit some more mixed bag comedy/action shows in there:

>Maken-Ki 1 & 2

>Sekirei 1 & 2

(Real talk I wouldn't mind a s3 of either of those shows)

>Manyuu Hiken-chou

>Kanokon


 No.4289

bump


 No.5075

bump


 No.5088

>>3291

>>Maken-Ki 1 & 2

The manga of that is way better than the anime.


 No.5122

File: 1446253310041-0.jpg (125.7 KB, 449x582, 449:582, 4710l.jpg)

File: 1446253310105-1.jpg (332.58 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, 5710l.jpg)

How about a chart about pedo/hebe related anime?


 No.5124

>>5122

Stop applying 3D pig disgusting terms to 2D. Then observe this chart: >>204


 No.5142

>>5124

>Stop applying 3D pig disgusting terms to 2D.

I'm applying the term to the target demographic of this kind of show.

>Then observe this chart: >>204

That's not what I'm talking about.

I'm talking about shows where a little girl is attracted to an adult and/or an adult is attracted to a little girl.


 No.5721

File: 1453753657004.jpg (54.83 KB, 500x357, 500:357, Dance_with_Devils_-Blight-.jpg)

>>2392

Are any of these musicals?

also there is this


 No.5722

>>2593

>no Kiss x Sis

Why are you leaving the best one out?


 No.5723

>>2658

normal > fanservice > ecchi > hentai

Obviously none of the above are mutually exclusive, but this is a ecchi exclusive thread, I think.


 No.5724

>>5721

Yeah, quite a few musical shows have aired since that post was made including Star Mu, Aira, Venus Project, Hibiki Euphonium and Show by Rock.


 No.5753

>>3281

Try paint.net, it's as easy to use as paint but the scaling isn't disgusting.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ home / board list / faq / random / create / bans / search / manage / irc ] [ ]