[ / / / / / / / / ] [ b / n / boards ] [ operate / meta ] [ ]

/film/ - Film

add to your favorites by clicking this ↑ star

Catalog

The development of the fully open source software behind 8ch.net that anyone can use ("infinity") is a massive undertaking. Please consider supporting the Infinity Development Group on Flattr by clicking here. Your donations also contribute patches back to vichan, infinity's upstream and engine on which more than one hundred imageboards rely worldwide.
8chan Bitcoin address: 1NpQaXqmCBji6gfX8UgaQEmEstvVY7U32C | Buy Bitcoin easily in the US | Buy Bitcoin anonymously all over the world | Bitcoin FAQ
Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
dicesidesmodifier
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf
Max filesize is 8 MB.
Max image dimensions are 10000 x 10000.
You may upload 2 per post.


Welcome to /film/ discussion. Email: film [at] 8chan [dot] co. For mainstream movies visit our friends at /tv/.
Featured Topics: Newbie Guide - Last Watched - Best of 2014 - /film/ Charts - /tv/ Charts - Doc - Pod - OST - webm - KG - Posters - Resources - meta

File: 1426852825296.jpg (140.53 KB, 400x662, 200:331, nostalghia_poster.jpg)

 No.4056

what you think bout this?

have you watch it? Im not sure if I got it…

 No.4068

I have not seen that one yet, so all I can say is it's not unusual to be slightly confused by a Tarkovsky film. Which other ones have you seen by him?

 No.4085

>>4068

Only that one.

The film is great, the cinematography is breathtaking.
What gets confusing its the sublying plot, why are the characters there and so on.

and we have a bunch of actions that they do that leaved with "why did he/she did that"
But I think is that ambiguity lots of directors have on their films, and leave the interpretations open.

 No.4195

Bump

 No.4458

>>4056

What didn't you get?

Keep in mind that it's a very personal film to Tarkovsky. It reflected a lot of what he was going through personally before he filmed it. If you read his diary, you'll find during this point in time, he was always thinking about his wife, child and home. Hence the black and white dream scenes of Andrei's (the character) wife and family.


 No.4464

>>4458

Yea… I read the reviews and hows that was his first film away from Russia.

But, its the movie itself which I still have some troubles with, Why the dude setted himself on fire? is the candle thing just an allegory to the struggle and meaningless of life? why people made fun of the old dude when trying to use the candle? what happened to the redheaded woman?

Im planning on watching this movie some time in the future again.


 No.4465

>>4464

Domenico set himself on fire to be a martyr of sorts. To show how strong his faith was and in what he was preaching to humanity. Sacrificing himself in hopes that they'll see his undying conviction and to consider what he's told them.

I think the candle bit was Andrei (who said earlier that he understood Domenico) trying to show that he too could make a sacrifice (however small it was in scale) and putting faith in Domenico and his beliefs. Perhaps him going through with this one final test of patience and will had some great meaning or purpose to Andrei? I haven't figured this all out myself, tbh.

In the hot springs bit near the beginning they talk about Domenico, his faith and how a madman is very similar if not identical to a spiritual man. The ones in the hot springs are basically your average secular people. With no spirituality or faith in their lives, they believe only what they see and experience and act as if they're "realists". So when they see a man so devoted to his faith, they'll think he's unusual because he's not like them. So he's cast aside and labeled as a madman for his unusual beliefs and actions because they fail or maybe even refuse to see the world through his eyes.

Eugenia got fed up with Andrei's indifference towards her feelings. She wanted to be loved by him. He goes through the whole film not recognizing it or, maybe he does but will never do anything because his love for his wife and family is too great. I think it's the latter considering, Eugenia shows up in at least one of the dream scenes with Andrei's wife, I guess to make the point that Andrei perhaps sees them as similar if not the same person in this sort of confused and depressed state he's been in.

But anyways, she moves on and goes back to her boyfriend (who she brought up earlier in an attempt to make Andrei jealous but he didn't give a shit anyways) and it's obvious she's not happy with this boyfriend. He seemingly doesn't give a shit about her too.


 No.4500

File: 1430166742772.jpg (67.16 KB, 550x744, 275:372, TarkovskyZerkalo.jpg)

>>4465

Your write up is on point. There's also some foreshadowing(?) about both Domenico and Andrei's fate. Early on in the film they talk about the maid who worked very far from home and burned down her Boss's house just so she could go home. There's also a lot of ideas expressed about the men sharing a fate or soul of sorts. The mirror scene, 1+1=1 and all that eastern philosophy stuff. As you said his diary shows the inspiration for Andrei's character. He even talks about the Russian mist we see in the film. I really love this film, his personal ones are the best.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ / / / / / / / / ] [ b / n / boards ] [ operate / meta ] [ ]